Phillies unravel in 10-run 5th, fall in Game 1

Kingery, Quinn take mound; club hurt by mistakes on defense

August 16th, 2018

PHILADELPHIA -- Major League Baseball allows a team to carry a 26th player for doubleheaders because 18 innings can be a lot on a pitching staff. The Phillies especially needed it Thursday after deploying seven relievers the night prior.

Then, instead of navigating the late innings of Thursday afternoon's first matchup against the Mets with calls to the bullpen, Phillies manager Gabe Kapler called on his bench. His fourth outfielder, , and backup shortstop, , threw the game's final innings because of a disastrous fifth that all but sealed an eventual 24-4 Phillies loss before the game was even halfway complete.

Kingery's pitches traveled so slowly that they didn't register on the radar gun. Kapler defended the way he managed the game with a tone more vigorous than his usual postgame statements.

Kingery delivers some slow-pitch offerings

"It's a strategy decision because we're trying to make the playoffs, we're trying to win the National League East, and the game was out of hand," Kapler said. "We now have a bullpen that we can use effectively in Game 2 of this doubleheader.

"Down the road we're going to look back on this and it's just going to be a time when we got our [butts] kicked, and we had position players on the mound. But in this game, we're better positioned as a result."

A 10-run fifth inning got the Phillies to that point. Eight of the runs were unearned. One was balked home. , who replaced rookie starter with no outs in the fifth, had been recalled earlier in the day to eat innings but allowed seven runs -- all unearned -- before he could get three outs.

Leiter's 37-pitch inning followed four frustrating frames for Suarez, who in his second Major League start surrendered eight runs (four earned) on 11 hits while walking two and striking out two. A third-inning triple for Mets catcher , who later scored, bounced off the glove of a diving . committed two costly errors.

"Unfortunately, things didn't work out today," Suarez said through an interpreter. "When you come up here, you want to get the job done. It didn't happen today, but I'm going to keep working hard to make sure it happens next time."


While Suarez's stuff was not stellar, he didn't allow 24 runs. As the Phillies fight to stay in the hunt for their first division title since 2011, their defense has become a problem. They entered Thursday with 88 errors and then committed four more to tie St. Louis with the most in baseball. They decided to address other needs at the non-waiver Trade Deadline -- namely, hitting -- and that has paid off when new additions , and have provided timely hits. But the defense has not improved.

"We didn't play good defense," Kapler said. "We put a little additional pressure on our pitchers to get additional outs. These are Major League hitters. They're going to eventually drive the baseball and that's what they did."


Two Franco errors led to three unearned Mets runs charged to Suarez. In the third, Franco booted a routine grounder that would have ended the Mets' half of the inning. Instead, it gave a bases-loaded opportunity in which he drew a four-pitch walk to give the Mets the lead. An inning later, Franco tried to make a barehanded play on a slow dribbler but his throw sailed wide of Bour at first base, allowing and Plawecki to score.

The defense didn't improve after Leiter replaced Suarez in the fifth. threw a ball into the outfield. dropped what would have been the third out in left field, only to see hit a grand slam over his head later in the inning.


Before Thursday, neither Kingery nor Quinn had pitched in a professional game at any level.


Hoskins, Franco, Alfaro and all hit solo home runs in the loss. Williams took advantage of a hanging curveball in the third inning to smash his 17th homer this season. It took one hop in the visitor's bullpen and bounced into Ashburn Alley. With a projected distance of 439 feet, according to Statcast™, it was Williams' farthest home run of the season and second farthest of his career.


"I think they were probably more entertained than they have been, frankly. I would bet that it is more entertaining to watch what we just saw than in the same kind of blowout game, one of our relievers that we see regularly." -- Kapler, on the notion that fans paid to see position players pitch three innings


After the game, the Phillies recalled RHP from Triple-A Lehigh Valley. To make room on the 25-man roster, Suarez was optioned to Lehigh Valley.