What were MLB’s 2026 award winners like as prospects? Scouts answer
A whole lot of hardware was handed out last week. Before these stars became decorated big leaguers, of course, they were prospects, and that all started when they were scouted as amateurs.
We obviously do a lot of work, both on the Draft and international scenes, so I thought it would be fun to take a look at this year’s winners -- for MVP, Rookie of the Year and Cy Young Award -- through that amateur lens. I’m including a snapshot of reports we had on these players before they started their pro careers, and I tracked down a scout who was integral in signing the player initially.
This group shows that players can come from anywhere. Five of the six came via the Draft, one from the international market. And four of the six won awards with the original team, with both MVPs having joined their current teams via trade.
AL MVP: Yordan Alvarez
Scout: Ismael Cruz
Cruz is the vice president of international scouting for the Dodgers, a post he took in November of 2015. He was at the helm when they inked Alvarez for $2 million in June 2016. Los Angeles blew past the maximum penalty in spending that period and thus weren’t able to sign pool-eligible players for the next two periods. He wasn’t on the Top 30 International Prospects list for 2015 but was known as a contact hitter who had shown some power as a teenager. Cruz had just come from Toronto and helped sign Vladimir Guerrero Jr. before moving to the Dodgers. Alvarez didn’t play an inning in a Dodgers uniform, going to the Astros at the 2016 Trade Deadline in return for Josh Fields.
“It was a Cuban frenzy time, when everyone was signing Cuban players. We got to see Yordan, the first time we saw him was in the Dominican at a World Cup event. Then we followed up with him in the States, he went to Florida and Arizona. Since the first day, we saw a great bat, a good sized guy with good makeup ... He was always a bat-first type of player, offense-oriented. We tried to get to see him at different positions, all three outfield spots, first base. Every position we put him in, there were always questions on the defensive side. I saw him four or five times. Toward the end of the Cuban signing period, shall we say, we were over the tax that year. But we liked the bat. We didn’t know where he was going to play with us, but we knew he was going to hit. It was a spectacular live BP we had with him. We had a set amount of money in mind, and Andrew Friedman went above that and got it done. He ended up at our academy for about a week [before he was traded].”
NL MVP: Pete Crow-Armstrong
Scout: Rusty McNamara
McNamara had been a college coach and then had gone overseas for a while, coming back to Southern California in 2019. PCA stood out to him right away as a junior when he was attending a high school game. Then he was hired by the Mets for the 2020 season He takes pride in having put PCA No. 1 on his preferred list, ahead of Garrett Mitchell, and the Mets took the high schooler one pick ahead of Mitchell before trading him to the Cubs at the 2021 deadline in the Javier Báez deal. We had him at No. 20 on our Draft list in 2020, with an above-average (55) hit tool and a 40 power grade.
“There’s no way in the world I thought he’d be an MVP candidate. My report probably reflected he’d be solid, maybe with All-Star upside. He was electric. Everything he did was full speed, and he's the best high school outfielder I’ve seen so far. There was some feel to hit, feel for the barrel. I loved the attitude. He had an edge. He was a good teammate, but anyone who was soft, he would get on them and help them pick up their game. I see a lot of arrogant high school kids, and you think it’s false bravado, but no, PCA knew he was good. He didn’t have to act arrogant and cocky, he just was. It was natural. He was fun to watch, he was exciting, he was explosive. I don’t know I would've ever thought he’d be a 40-40 guy, but it speaks to the type of player he is athletically as well as his confidence and his ability to play at the highest level with his tools. He’s very gifted.”
This browser does not support the video element.
AL Cy Young: Cam Schlittler
Scout: Matt Hyde
Hyde has been scouting for the Yankees for more than two decades and is responsible not only for Schlittler, but Ben Rice as well, nailing later-round picks in back-to-back Drafts. Schlittler came second, going in Round 7 of the 2022 Draft. The right-hander wasn’t on our Draft rankings, and the Yankees signed him for just $205,000 that July, a smidge under slot.
“Cam was the guy Northeastern counted on in big games throughout his career there, and the one thing that really stood out was his competitiveness. He never backed down and always wanted the ball in big moments. It was a full team effort evaluating him where we fortunately had scouts at all his best starts in 2022. I’d known Cam since his high school days, and [scouting director] Damon Oppenheimer actually saw his first bullpen ever at Northeastern when Cam was a freshman, so we had a great history with him. The icing on the cake was our relationship with Northeastern Head Coach Mike Glavine, who told me that he thought Cam had a good chance to be a Major League starter, a line that boosted our confidence in him as a player to take in the Draft.”
This browser does not support the video element.
NL Cy Young: Jacob Misiorowski
Scout: Riley Bandelow
Bandelow is closing in on a decade of scouting, having spent his entire career with the Brewers. Misiorowski was a known quantity as the 2022 Draft approached, though he came in at No. 78 on our Top 250. There were questions about durability and command, and some teams weren’t sure what to make of the junior college right-hander. The Brewers jumped in to take him in the second round, No. 63 overall, and went well over slot ($2.35 million) to sign him away from his Louisiana State commitment.
“I’ve had a lot of time to re-think everything with Miz. It wasn’t a quick process -- it started in 2019, the summer going into his senior year of high school. That was the first time I saw him live. We didn’t draft him until three years later. I had a long time to get to know him, his family, the type of kid he was. I saw the 18-year-old high school kid who was quiet, shy and timid. Would this kid be ready to go to pro ball? I saw him go to junior college, where it’s a different lifestyle, it’s a grind. I saw that evolution, him getting tougher. That was important. The first thing was the way he moved on the mound, it was different than anyone I’ve seen then or since. The athleticism in the lower half, the quick arm, no one had moved like that. The strikes weren’t there, but it was a different animal the way he moved on the mound. I was confident he was going to get better. I told our guys he’s going to get better, we just need to get him in our system and get him working with our organization. He had all the freaky tools we could ever want, and I was 100 percent confident in the makeup, the work ethic. The mental toughness, I knew it was going to translate. Everything that’s worked out is beyond expectations. I never bet on anyone more than I did on Miz, and I’ve never scouted anyone like him. But all the credit goes to him.”
This browser does not support the video element.
AL Rookie of the Year: Kevin McGonigle
Scout: Jim Bretz
Bretz has been scouting for more than a quarter century, the last dozen or so with the Tigers. As the 2023 Draft approached, McGonigle was known as one of the best pure high school hitters in the class, and we ranked him accordingly, coming in at No. 33 overall. Bretz had three players from the Northeast he signed touch the big league team in 2026, with Brett Callahan and Andrew Sears also contributing. At the time, McGonigle really was all about the bat, with many teams unsure about where he would play defensively.
“We knew we were buying the bat. Legit bats are hard to find. They’re the toughest things to assess over the long term. Every time he came to the plate, he gave you a professional at-bat. No one knew the zone better than him -- he did better than any college or high school guy I had that year. Pesky at-bats, he had a plan, a tough out every time. The professionalism, the way he took ABs, really resonated. Even the outs were hard, barrelled up the ball all the time -- he was always in a positive count, he never expanded the zone. He had plus bat speed, could hit to all fields with authority. Everything looked right, from start to finish, he never took an off-balance swing. You never saw that from an amateur. If you put that in one basket, those were the things that were attractive. Then on the defensive side, it was body control, smooth and fluid. We didn’t know if he was going to be a shortstop coming out, but we were going to throw him out there and make him prove that he’s not. He lives by challenges. He wants you to tell him that he can’t do something so he can prove you wrong. It’s never enough: 'What’s my next challenge or goal?' That’s the way he always plays and that’s what makes him great. He’s never satisfied.”
This browser does not support the video element.
NL Rookie of the Year: Sal Stewart
Scout: Andrew Fabian
Fabian had joined the Reds to scout South Florida in the fall of 2019. He had signed Jay Allen II as the No. 30 overall pick of the 2021 Draft, then had another potential first-rounder come his way in Stewart, who went No. 32 overall, after the Reds had taken Cam Collier at No. 18. Collier hasn’t panned out as of yet, but at the time the organization thought they had gotten the best left-handed (Collier) and right-handed (Stewart) hitters in the class. Stewart signed for a tad under slot at $2.1 million. In November of 2023, Fabian moved on to the Tampa Bay Rays’ international scouting department, where he currently serves as a crosschecker.
“Sal is the same fiery competitor today that he was in high school. He played with passion and confidence, embraced the spotlight and never shied away from the big moments. He was also one of the most advanced high school hitters I’ve ever scouted, with an exceptional understanding of the strike zone. One thing that doesn’t get talked about enough in my opinion is his baseball IQ and overall understanding of the game. He’s just a baseball rat.”
This browser does not support the video element.