Mets' Mathis, Reds' Holman snag Week 6 Fall League honors
Before stateside affiliated ball packed up for the winter, two prospects created a good amount of momentum for themselves heading into the long, cold offseason.
Mets' No. 13 prospect Cole Mathis and Reds' No. 23 prospect Luke Holman were named the Arizona Fall League Hitter and Pitcher of the Week respectively for Week 6 of the prospect showcase, which also included postseason play.
Hitter of the Week: Cole Mathis, 1B/3B, Surprise (NYM)
A right-handed slugger, Mathis went 4-for-8 with four walks and only one strikeout over three games for the Saguaros during the week, but the bulk of his damage came in a 10-4 win over Glendale in the AFL semifinals on Friday.
Batting out of the third spot in the lineup, the New York first baseman set a Fall League single-game postseason record (since such records started being kept in 2005) with seven RBIs, all of which came in the first five innings. The capper was a three-run homer in the fifth frame that gave the Saguaros a 10-0 lead and allowed them to coast to the AFL championship, where Mathis went 2-for-4 with a free pass in an 8-3 loss to Peoria.
This browser does not support the video element.
The award finished off an eventful 2026 season for the 2024 second-rounder.
Mathis was off to a hot start with Single-A Myrtle Beach and High-A South Bend before getting traded to the Mets straight up for Major League lefty David Peterson on June 25. He played in only 13 games for New York affiliates after the deal due to a left wrist injury, leading to the AFL assignment (his second in as many years). He went just 8-for-50 (.160) with a homer, a double and 17 walks during this Fall League spin before taking off in the postseason.
Pitcher of the Week: Luke Holman, RHP, Peoria (CIN)
Holman earned his honor by quieting the rest of the Surprise lineup in that title game Saturday. Getting the start for the champion Javelinas, the 23-year-old right-hander struck out six while scattering four hits and three walks over five scoreless innings. It was his longest outing of the Fall League, supplanting a four-frame start on Oct. 19.
The 2024 71st overall pick was one of the AFL’s most effective pitchers in 2026 before he took that dominance to the Championship Game over the weekend. He finished the regular season as the league leader in ERA (0.69) and average-against (.114) while ranking second in WHIP (0.92) over 13 innings for Peoria. He struck out 20 and walked seven in that span too.
Holman underwent Tommy John surgery in 2025 and dealt with a groin injury after his return to the mound this summer. Between both injuries, he’d managed only six regular-season starts (15 2/3 innings) in pro ball since signing out of LSU two years ago.
This browser does not support the video element.