Will Posey join rare company as first-ballot HOF catcher?

This browser does not support the video element.

Buster Posey has never been to Cooperstown.

He had hoped to make a trip there with his son for a youth baseball tournament a few years ago, but those plans didn’t end up coming together as expected. A large contingent of Giants officials traveled to upstate New York to celebrate Jeff Kent’s induction into the Hall of Fame last summer, but Posey wasn’t among them; as the club’s president of baseball operations, he had to stay behind and prepare for the Trade Deadline.

Still, the odds are high that Posey will finally get a chance to visit the hallowed baseball grounds in the near future.

Posey headlined the group of newcomers on the 2027 Baseball Writers’ Association of America Hall of Fame ballot, which was released on Monday. Candidates must receive at least 75% of the vote to be elected, with the ballot results scheduled to be announced during a live MLB Network broadcast on Jan. 19.

This browser does not support the video element.

Given his staggering credentials -- three World Series championships, the 2012 National League MVP Award, an NL batting title, seven All-Star selections, five Silver Slugger Awards, a Gold Glove Award and the 2010 Rookie of the Year Award -- Posey has a legitimate shot to join Johnny Bench, Iván Rodríguez and Joe Mauer as the only catchers to be elected to the Hall of Fame in their first year of eligibility.

“I think surreal gets thrown around a lot, but it really is surreal,” Posey, 39, said in a phone interview. “I think where my head goes when I think about something like this is, I go all the way back as far as I can remember until probably around age five or so when I was introduced to baseball and my dad and my siblings and friends and the coaches that helped along the way.

“Thinking about a potential honor like this, it's hard not to just think about all the people over the last almost 40 years of my life that have had such an impact on me and my career. Obviously with my wife, she was there from rookie ball all the way up to my entire career. It's hard to put into words. It's kind of an emotional thing. I didn't expect to think it was emotional, but it is a very emotional thought.”

Posey is already an icon in San Francisco, where he spent his entire 12-year career and served as the backbone of the Giants’ three World Series-winning teams in 2010, ‘12 and ‘14. His status as the greatest catcher in franchise history has long been secured, but getting the call from the Hall would place him in even more rarefied air.

This browser does not support the video element.

How is Posey feeling about his chances to join baseball’s most exclusive fraternity?

“I guess we'll see,” Posey said. “Obviously, it’s out of my control. I think it'll be an honor just to be on the ballot to begin with.

“I'd say curious and excited. There's definitely a little bit of the unknown. It’s something different. I think depending on how it shakes out, one way or another, it definitely has the potential to bring some really cool experiences. If it doesn't, I’m just grateful for the recognition.”

Posey’s counting stats aren’t necessarily in the same vicinity as other Hall of Famers -- he tallied 1,500 hits, launched 158 home runs and caught 1,093 games -- but he ranks 16th among catchers with 45 Wins Above Replacement, according to Baseball Reference, and recorded a .302 career batting average with a .831 OPS (129 OPS+).

His numbers are eerily similar to Mauer, who hit .306 with 143 homers and a .827 career OPS (124 OPS+) over his 15 seasons for his hometown Twins. That should certainly bode well for Posey’s candidacy.

This browser does not support the video element.

Like Mauer, Posey dealt with major injuries that curtailed his career. He was limited to only 45 games in 2011 after a devastating home-plate collision left him with a fractured fibula and torn ligaments in his left ankle. He also missed time with concussions and a right hip injury and opted out of the pandemic-shortened 2020 campaign after he and his wife Kristen adopted twin girls who were born prematurely.

Posey could have continued to chase more volume, but he decided to retire after leading the Giants to a franchise-record 107 wins in 2021. Posey was only 34 at the time and coming off a resurgent season at the plate, but he felt worn down by the physical demands of catching and wanted to spend more time with his family.

“I was pretty at peace,” Posey said. “I was very grateful that I had a good year in ‘21 and really felt like I had kind of emptied the tank. I say this humbly: I do think I could have kept playing, but just for us, it felt like the right decision.”

Posey isn’t the only Giants legend who will be up for the Hall of Fame this year. Bruce Bochy, Dusty Baker and Brian Sabean are also among the eight candidates on the Contemporary Baseball Era ballot for managers, executives and umpires, creating a strong possibility that multiple franchise greats will end up going into Cooperstown together next summer.

“It's really fun to think about,” Posey said. “I have tremendous respect for all three of those men. I know Boch and Sabes better than I do Dusty, but I have gotten to know Dusty over the years. Just three great baseball minds. In my opinion, all three deserve to be in the Hall of Fame. So I'll be watching that one closely as well. It would be a tremendous honor just to watch those guys go in, knowing what they've meant to the game.”

More from MLB.com