What are the Cubs' catching options for 2027?

This browser does not support the video element.

This story was excerpted from Jordan Bastian's Cubs Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.

CHICAGO -- The biggest items on the Cubs’ to-do list for this offseason are clear. With several pitchers hitting the open market, Chicago needs to try to add multiple starters. The potential loss of both Seiya Suzuki and Ian Happ makes addressing the outfield important. The bullpen needs reinforcements.

There is one other area the Cubs have to keep in mind: catching. The team’s primary catcher from the past two seasons, veteran Carson Kelly, is currently a free agent, giving Chicago’s front office one more part of the roster to consider. As things stand, Miguel Amaya and prospect Owen Ayers offer the two internal solutions.

“We’ll see where the free-agency world takes us,” general manager Carter Hawkins told reporters at the GM Meetings last week in Las Vegas. “We’re going to figure out where we’re going to allocate our resources over the course of the next few weeks. It could be at the catcher position.”

Let’s break down the various paths the Cubs could take behind the plate:

This browser does not support the video element.

1) Go with Amaya and Ayers

Since overcoming injuries that hurt his status as a highly touted prospect, Amaya has grown into a trusted catcher over the past four seasons in the Majors. He has stepped up as the top option for stretches and spent this past year in a timeshare of sorts with Kelly.

Although the 27-year-old Amaya did not have his best year at the plate in '26 – he posted a solid .340 on-base percentage but saw his overall production dip – he did perform better defensively. His arm strength and pop time to second improved, he did well with the new ABS system and he registered positive marks in advanced metrics in multiple categories.

“Miggy had a really good year defensively last year, and our pitchers like throwing to him,” Hawkins said.

Amaya could easily slide back into the top catching job and double as a mentor to Ayers, who is MLB Pipeline’s No. 2 Cubs prospect and No. 88 on the Top 100. Ayers soared from High-A to Triple-A last season with a standout offensive showing (25 homers, 82 walks and a .929 OPS in 125 games), and shadowed Kelly and Amaya in the final weeks of the year.

“Owen Ayers is somebody we’re really excited about,” Hawkins said. “[He] will be competing for a spot. Obviously, he has not caught at the Major League level yet. He’s been around the team, certainly. But there’s a trust that he’ll have to earn if he’s to get those opportunities.”

2) Try to re-sign Kelly

The Cubs could try to bring Kelly back, given his track record with the team over the past two years and the trust he gained with the pitching staff. That would once again put Kelly and Amaya into a 1A/1B situation, leaving Ayers waiting in the wings. It is rare for a team to get through a full season with only two catchers, so Ayers would be at the ready.

“Carson was a great player for us the last couple of years,” Hawkins said. “It could be Carson that steps up for us [in 2027], but someone’s going to need to step up, and I’m excited about our ability to do that.”

3) Add an experienced backup

If the Cubs decide to move on from Kelly and stick mostly with the internal options, they could still pursue depth behind the plate. This could come in the form of acquiring an experienced catcher to be a true backup (possibly delaying Ayers’ arrival), or adding a catcher or two on Minor League deals to create a deeper pool for a preseason competition.

“Bringing in a veteran catcher,” Hawkins said, “or someone who’s been around, certainly mitigates some of that risk of bringing in someone [like Ayers] that just hasn’t done it before. But we’ve got to take risks. You’ve got to take risks to be able to achieve the goals that we want to achieve. And we’ll be thinking about all of that and weighing all of that as we make our offseason decisions.”

More from MLB.com