Which Blue Jays have built the strongest award cases so far?

This story was excerpted from the Blue Jays Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.

Every baseball season reaches a point when the conversation begins to change. While the All-Star break serves as MLB’s symbolic midpoint, Toronto has already passed the halfway point of its season. Now, award races begin shifting from projections to results.

While the Blue Jays are still searching for the consistency that carried them to last year’s American League pennant, they’re also just one good stretch from climbing back into the postseason picture. Even amid an uneven first half, several key additions and emerging stars have put themselves firmly in the American League award conversation.

Here’s a look at who’s built the strongest case so far, and what they’ll need to do to remain in those conversations in September.

CY YOUNG: Dylan Cease
When the Blue Jays signed Dylan Cease to a seven-year, $210 million contract last offseason, they expected an ace. Halfway through the season, they’ve gotten exactly that.

Cease enters the second half with a 3.02 ERA, while his 128 strikeouts lead the American League and trail only Milwaukee's Jacob Misiorowski (146) among all Major League pitchers. After missing two starts with a strained hamstring, Cease returned June 9 with six innings and 11 strikeouts against the Phillies. He has carried that momentum through June, posting a 1.62 ERA in four starts while striking out at least seven in each of his past nine outings. Saturday’s 10-strikeout performance against the Rangers marked his fifth double-digit strikeout game of the season.

With reigning two-time AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal missing time with a left elbow injury earlier this season, the race has opened up considerably. After finishing second in voting with the White Sox in 2022, Cease knows what it takes to stay in the race. If he continues leading the league in strikeouts while taking the ball every fifth day, he’ll have a strong chance to remain near the top of the AL Cy Young Award conversation.

ROOKIE OF THE YEAR: Kazuma Okamoto
The biggest question surrounding Kazuma Okamoto wasn’t whether he could hit -- it was how quickly the three-time Nippon Professional Baseball home run champion would adjust to Major League pitching. The answer? It didn't take long.

After batting .188 through his first 18 games, Okamoto made a subtle adjustment and hasn’t looked back. Since then, he’s slashed .253/.335/.520 with an .854 OPS while leading Toronto in home runs (19) and RBIs (53) and becoming the middle-of-the-order bat the Blue Jays envisioned. He’s already within striking distance of Eric Hinske’s club rookie home run record (24), set during Hinske's 2002 AL Rookie of the Year season.

Okamoto's numbers are also earning recognition across the AL. His RBI total leads rookies and third basemen, strengthening his All-Star bid after receiving the most Phase 1 votes at the position. Only fellow Japanese slugger Munetaka Murakami (20) has more home runs among AL rookies, but with the White Sox slugger sidelined with a right hamstring injury, Okamoto has a chance to move into the lead before he returns.

If the 29-year-old slugger continues to anchor Toronto’s lineup while producing at this level, he’ll have a legitimate chance to become the Blue Jays’ third AL Rookie of the Year winner in what’s becoming an increasingly competitive race.

ROOKIE OF THE YEAR: Trey Yesavage
Before the season began, Trey Yesavage looked like the Blue Jays’ clearest Rookie of the Year candidate. As Toronto’s No. 1 prospect entering the season, Yesavage carried enormous expectations following his historic 2025 postseason. A right shoulder impingement delayed his debut until April 28, but once he joined a rotation already hit hard by injuries, Yesavage quickly became exactly what Toronto needed.

The right-hander posted a 1.07 ERA over his first five starts before hitters began adjusting. Over four June outings, Yesavage's ERA climbed to 5.70 as inconsistent command led to five or more walks in three of his past five starts. Even so, Yesavage has continued to flash the electric stuff that earned him a spot in the Blue Jays’ rotation and makes him a legitimate Rookie of the Year contender.

The swing-and-miss stuff remains intact. Yesavage’s splitter has generated a 40.3% whiff rate this season, while his slider sits at 36.2%, proving his biggest challenge isn’t fooling hitters, it’s consistently getting ahead in counts and commanding the strike zone. If Yesavage rediscovers the command that fueled his dominant start, he’ll remain firmly in the Rookie of the Year conversation throughout the second half.