Are the Blue Jays, Freddy Peralta a good match via free agency?
This browser does not support the video element.
This story was excerpted from Keegan Matheson’s Blue Jays Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.
TORONTO -- One year ago, Freddy Peralta fit the Blue Jays’ blueprint in every possible way.
He was durable and athletic with some upside still waiting to be unlocked in his 30s, the exact recipe the Blue Jays have chased in Kevin Gausman, José Berríos, Dylan Cease and others. It all came undone in 2026 with the Mets, but after a trade to the Rays and a remarkable run to the World Series, Peralta has already completed a speed run of the renaissance cycle.
We’re right back where we started, then, aren’t we? The Blue Jays have met with Tarik Skubal, as ESPN’s Jeff Passan reported, but that will be a crowded bidding war involving the Mets, Dodgers, Padres and more. Fresh off handing out the biggest pitching contract last offseason, if the Blue Jays are unable to one-up themselves and land Skubal, Peralta’s name falls next in line.
Compared to early expectations for this offseason, there’s now more of a sense that the Blue Jays could explore the top of the pitching market instead of chasing a reliable No. 4 starter. There still needs to be room for a major offensive addition -- or three -- but Peralta is expected to land closer to the $25 million range annually, far more manageable than Skubal, who’s expected to blow past $40 million per season.
This browser does not support the video element.
Projecting Peralta
At his best, you can consider Peralta closer to a Cease style of pitcher than Berríos. There will be plenty of dominant outings, but some of those last just 5 1/3 innings as his pitch count runs up quickly. That works just fine, but don’t expect Peralta to be the 200-inning workhorse.
After posting a 4.99 ERA with the Mets over the first four months of the season, something clicked with the Rays and Peralta put up a 3.25 ERA down the stretch. Then, in the postseason, he gave the Rays a 2.95 ERA over five appearances, even throwing the hardest pitch of his MLB career at 99.4 mph in the ALCS.
Even during that World Series run, it was evident that the year had worn on Peralta, emotionally.
“It was very hard for me, for my family, too, because I always had success in my whole career. And it was the first time that I was struggling like that,” Peralta said at the time. “And also in New York, an organization that traded for me, an organization that trusted me, and I wasn't able to give the best of myself. It was a little disappointing for me. I didn't feel good about it. But when I got traded [to Tampa Bay], I just felt different. For some reason, when I got here, I felt like myself again. I'm grateful because I'm here. I'm very thankful because the Rays organization traded for me, and they trusted me and the work that I'm doing now.”
What’s encouraging is that Peralta’s changes with the Rays weren’t “new," so this isn’t lightning in a bottle. The Rays worked to get Peralta back to the best version of himself from his days with the Brewers, encouraging him to pitch from the stretch and throw more changeups to complement that incredible fastball.
The simple version? Peralta is himself again, but an elevated version.
Projecting a potential fit with the Blue Jays
The extreme highs and lows of 2026 are clouding Peralta’s free agency, but he still has a fine case to be the No. 2 pitcher on the market behind Skubal. Trevor Rogers could land a deal with a similar annual value, but when we look at the Blue Jays’ recent pitching investments, Peralta fits their “type” more than Rogers. Michael King feels closer to the Peralta side of this conversation, too, and will also land in that range.
Those names represent a bit of a cliff, though, and a decision point for the Blue Jays. Two years from now, the Blue Jays may finally be feeling the benefits of their improved pitching developments and the waves of young arms, but right now, they still need to pay for pitching. Are they willing to invest at Peralta’s level on a four- or five-year deal, or would they prefer to go shorter-term with someone like Gausman, Tyler Mahle or Shota Imanaga?
Peralta’s name seems to have lived in the shadows between the top of this market and the mid-range. He fits the Blue Jays’ blueprint as well as anyone, though, and after a rollercoaster ride in 2026, he’s right back there.