How could Reds improve rotation next year? Here are some options

This browser does not support the video element.

This story was excerpted from Mark Sheldon’s Reds Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.

CINCINNATI -- The Reds came into the 2026 season feeling really good about the depth of their rotation. By the time they left Spring Training, that depth was already tested by injuries, and by mid-May, it was downright beat up.

President of baseball operations Nick Krall aims to shore up Cincinnati's starting pitching for 2027.

“Just because you have five starters doesn’t mean you’re going to have five starters throughout the year," Krall said during last week's General Managers Meetings. "We thought we had eight guys coming into the season [this] year. Obviously, we struggled at times to keep everybody on the field.

"It’s something that we just have to add pitching, no matter how it is. Starters might give you more length. It might give you more flexibility with your bullpen.”

In 2026, Cincinnati's rotation was ranked 28th in ERA (4.97) after it was ninth (3.85) in 2025. It was also third in walks and fifth in homers this season.

During Spring Training, Hunter Greene needed right elbow surgery to remove bone chips -- and later Tommy John surgery in August after making only five starts. Greene is out until 2028.

On the last day of camp, Nick Lodolo got a blister on his left index finger. More injuries came during the season, with Brandon Williamson (left shoulder fatigue) missing four months and Rhett Lowder (right shoulder pain) missing nearly a month.

Lodolo, Lowder, Williamson and a healthy Andrew Abbott all endured periods of struggles and inconsistency. Brady Singer had a rough year, but he was the only Reds pitcher to not miss a start because of injury over 2025 and ‘26. Singer is a free agent, and while most of his 2026 results weren't worthy of replication, the right-hander's durability most certainly is.

This browser does not support the video element.

There is a long list of free-agent starting pitchers. The group is headlined by Tarik Skubal, Freddy Peralta and Michael King, but they won't be in Cincinnati's price range.

Who might be? Let's take a quick look at four potential fits.

RHP Shane Bieber
Arm injuries, including right shoulder inflammation in 2026, limited Bieber to 18 starts (4.03 ERA) over his last two seasons with the Blue Jays. A former All-Star and Cy Young winner with Cleveland who also had Tommy John surgery on his right elbow in 2024, Bieber is in need of a bounceback year to show he's healthy. Perhaps it can happen in Cincinnati.

RHP Cal Quantrill
Set to turn 32 in February, Quantrill has shown versatility. He opened last season in the Rangers' bullpen before moving into the rotation and posting a 2.86 ERA over 32 games -- including 15 starts. The right-hander also had some success for Reds manager Terry Francona and new pitching coach Joe Torres over four years with Cleveland from 2020-23.

RHP Zac Gallen
An eight-year mainstay in Arizona, including an All-Star 2023 season when he pitched 210 innings over a career-high 34 starts, Gallen has made at least 30 starts with 180 or more innings three times over his career. In 2025, he threw 192 innings. But things fell apart in 2026 for Gallen, who had a 6.07 ERA over 105 1/3 innings and 22 games (20 starts). He ended the season in the bullpen.

LHP David Peterson
A 2025 All-Star, Peterson nosedived with the Mets this year -- including being clobbered by the Reds in May -- posting a 6.09 ERA in 16 games (eight starts) and getting moved to the bullpen. But the starting-pitching starved Cubs acquired him in a June trade, and things improved. The 31-year-old went 6-2 with a 3.70 ERA and 114 ERA+ over 16 games (15 starts) to finish the year.

Although the free-agent market and trades are avenues to acquire a starter, the Reds will also need to look within their own ranks for improvement. That means getting better years from Abbott, Lodolo, Lowder and Williamson. It also means getting another strong year from new ace Chase Burns, who will be in the first year of his seven-year, $105 million extension.

“When you look at our starters -- besides Chase Burns -- I think everybody took a step backwards this year," Krall said. “We need to have consistency. Those guys are all going to come in and fight for jobs. Yeah, we do need starting pitching. I think that’s everybody, every year. But we do need to figure out if there’s a way to either add a starter to the mix or add some competition to this mix somehow.”

More from MLB.com