One-year wonders? Why Red Sox don't believe that for Mead, Bauers

10 minutes ago

This story was excerpted from Ian Browne’s Red Sox Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.

BOSTON -- Back on July 26, when the Red Sox dealt a valuable piece of their present and future in left-hander Connelly Early for a hitter in the midst of a career year in , it was a calculated gamble by president of baseball operations Craig Breslow.

In dealing from an area of organizational strength (starting pitching), Boston felt like it was getting a much-needed right-handed bat and cornerstone in the lineup for the next several years. They didn’t get to see how it would play out in ‘26, as Mead had the misfortune of fracturing his left wrist in just his second plate appearance for the Red Sox.

This brings us to a much more recent event: The Red Sox formally announced the signing of free agent Jake Bauers to a four-year, $58-million contract on Tuesday.

Much like Mead, Bauers had a season far and above anything he had done previously in his career, when he bounced from team to team trying to find something that stuck.

So a pessimist would wonder if Breslow and his front office are banking too much on one season for these two players.

While Breslow understands that line of questioning, he has a lot of confidence in what his evaluations of both players tell him about the future.

“We are [confident in both of them going forward], and not exclusively because the data tells us so. But I think getting to know the players, talking to our scouts, our evaluators, looking at some of the underlying data, and then being able to identify a real change,” said Breslow. 

Specific examples of those changes?

“I think it gives us a little bit of comfort to say Jake is swinging at different pitches. He's standing in the box a little bit differently. His bat path has changed,” said Breslow. “And Curtis has moved his point of contact out in front and he's hitting the ball in the air a little bit more while still making good swing decisions. If we can't point to something as the reason that is driving this change, it becomes a little bit scarier to bank on it in the future, but being able to identify the difference is really helpful.”

Here’s the other thing to remember: Both players were once top prospects before spending years trying to justify the scouting reports.

The fact is, the scouting reports were there to begin with, which means the raw talent was always there.

It takes longer for some players to assimilate to playing at the highest level, and much of it depends on opportunity.

Struggles can lead to a decrease in playing time, and it’s hard to emerge from a slump or change a reputation from the bench or in Triple-A.

“I think [their former prospect status] enables us to say that these were highly regarded players by the industry. We weren't the only team that saw the talent. And sometimes it surfaces at 21 [years old] or 22, sometimes at 25, sometimes at 31,” said Breslow. “We can't always control that. But like I said, we are trying to understand what's driving the improved performance, and if we can put our finger on it, it becomes a lot easier to believe in.”

For Bauers and Mead, they both got their most extensive looks yet in ‘26 and pounced on the opportunity.

Nationals president of baseball operations Paul Toboni -- formerly Breslow’s right-hand man in Boston -- was on the ground floor when Mead took his game to another level. Much like Breslow, he sees sustainability with his former player.

“First and foremost, just an unbelievable dude,” Toboni said at the GM Meetings earlier this month. “He's a great teammate, great leader. I think he's going to be awesome for the Red Sox. I think where my mind goes [regarding Mead] is extremely mature and confident in who he is as a player.”

Toboni enjoyed watching Mead morph from platoon player to lineup fixture after the Nationals acquired him from the White Sox two days after Opening Day.

At first, Mead was penciled in as a player who would get most of his time with Washington against lefties. That soon changed.

“[Mead] was just really prepared and advanced in how he went about thinking about that, and then the results followed, and I think you all saw it,” said Toboni. “But he started finding himself in the lineup against righties and played well, and he can just really hit. He's got a really good understanding of how to play the game and put himself in a good position to succeed. I think he’s the type of player that Boston will really fall in love with.”