Pirates Insider: Breaking down Rule 5 decisions on potentially busy day
Tuesday could be a busy day in Pirates land, the result of two important deadlines.
First, Brandon Lowe has until 4 p.m. to sign or reject his qualifying offer of $23.15 million. If Lowe signs, that’s his guaranteed salary for 2027. If he doesn’t — the expected outcome — the Pirates will receive a compensatory pick, while Lowe can sign a longer contract extension.
Should Lowe sign for $50 million or more, the Pirates would get a pick between the first and Competitive Balance A rounds. In the unlikely event it’s below $50 million, Pittsburgh’s pick would come after Competitive Balance Round B.
We also have the Rule 5 deadline at 6 p.m. This should bring a little more intrigue, starting with the question of whether or not the event actually happens Dec. 9 in San Diego or if it’s canceled altogether like it was in 2021-22.
Should a lockout commence on Dec. 2, the annual Winter Meetings would not occur, likely taking the Rule 5 draft down with them. (For context, the Rule 5 draft didn’t happen the last time there was a lockout.)
From a strategy standpoint, the impact is two fold:
• Is it worth allocating a 40-man roster spot for something that may never happen? Plus …
• Players on 40-man rosters could not play Minor League Baseball during a prolonged work stoppage, meaning they could lose valuable development time.
Rule 5 refresher
Those eligible include prospects who signed at age 18 or younger and have been with their organization for five seasons, as well as those 19 or older who’ve been around for four. This obviously applies only to those NOT on 40-man rosters.
Teams pay $100,000 to select a player and must keep him on the MLB roster for the majority of the upcoming season. If that doesn’t happen, the player is subject to waivers and must be offered back to his original team for $50,000.
The Pirates last season added Esmerlyn Valdez, Wilber Dotel, Antwone Kelly, Jack Brannigan, Tyler Samaniego and Brandan Bidois during this phase but I wouldn’t expect that same level of activity this time.
Names to know
• 2B Termarr Johnson
He’s the biggest name, because he was the fourth overall pick in 2022. I also think it’s sort of a non-issue here. Johnson hit .199 at Triple-A last season and tore the ACL and LCL in his left knee this past August. An acquiring team could stash Johnson on the injured list, but it’s asking a lot on the other side of his recovery for someone who’s slashed .239/.372/.382 in 467 career Minor League games. Leaving Johnson unprotected would also allow him to seamlessly continue his recovery and rehab during a potential lockout.
• RHP Derek Diamond
A much more likely candidate, in my opinion. Diamond had an outstanding 2026 season and was the Pirates’ Kent Tekulve Reliever of the Year, going 7-0 with a 2.48 ERA, 57 strikeouts and a 1.02 WHIP in 37 games (58 innings). With a 3.9% walk rate, two breaking balls and a mid-90s heater, Diamond is the type who often gets poached in the Rule 5. Plus, he’s close. Would not be the worst use of a roster spot.
This browser does not support the video element.
• OF Mitch Jebb
Another strong ’26: After missing nearly three months with a fractured thumb, Jebb returned and discovering some pop, homering eight times a year after finishing with zero in 122 games. Jebb slashed .286/.364/.475 with 29 RBIs and eight stolen bases in 55 games, playing a Jake Mangum style. Intriguing skill set. But the outfield is crowded with Oneil Cruz, Bryan Reynolds, Esmerlyn Valdez, Mangum, Akil Baddoo, Jhostynxon Garcia and even Chas McCormick, who was signed to a Minor League deal Monday. We’ll see. I think it’s less likely than Diamond.
• C/1B Axiel Plaz
Plenty to like about what Plaz, the Pirates’ top-ranked prospect (MLB Pipeline No. 7) on this list, did in 2026: .305 average, , .902 OPS, 18 homers, 74 RBIs and a career-low 17.2% strikeout rate. However, Plaz has also never played above High-A. That’s a big jump. And remember, it’s often easier to sneak catchers, first basemen and power guys through for that reason.
• LHP Brandon Neeck
Tough call. On one hand, Neeck had a 2.33 ERA at Double-A Altoona and Triple-A Indianapolis, walking 47 and striking out 101 in 69 2/3 innings. Held opponents to a .184 batting average against. Very solid. It also wasn’t enough for Neeck to get a shot down the stretch, and there’s potential redundancy with Brandon Eisert and Evan Sisk, who pitched well at various times. But the Pirates want left-handed pitching depth, and Neeck’s an intriguing late-bloomer due to injury. They could do worse.
• OF Lonnie White Jr.
Things finally clicked for the former Penn State football player signed for $1.5 million out of Malvern Prep in 2021. Across two levels, White hit .270 with an .896 OPS that included 18 doubles and 26 home runs, plus 67 RBIs and 21 steals. However, White strikes out a lot, including 32.1% of the time with the Curve. That’s probably enough to dissuade teams from using an MLB roster spot on White.
This browser does not support the video element.
• 1B Tony Blanco Jr.
I’ll lump Yordany De Los Santos and Jhonny Severino in here, because it’s the same stuff. Solid seasons. Intriguing skill sets. But the jump is just too big.
Blanco hit 25 home runs and had an .897 OPS, spending the majority of time with High-A Greensboro. This was also the first time he’s played more than 40 MLB games in a season.
Severino homered 31 times for the Grasshoppers, but he’s also only 21 and a year removed from 11 dingers in the same number of games with Low-A Bradenton. De Los Santos, another 21-year-old who just finished High-A, stole 45 bases.
More on McCormick
The McCormick signing makes sense given his profile and if he can replicate what he did with the Astros from 2021-25, when the right-handed-hitting outfielder hit .247 with a .734 OPS in 500 games.
McCormick’s best season came in 2023, when he hit .273 with a .842 OPS, 22 home runs, 70 RBIs and 19 stolen bases in 115 games. It’s especially intriguing how McCormick hits left-handed pitching: an .847 OPS against it during his career compared to a .684 mark against righties.
McCormick was with Triple-A Iowa in 2026, hitting .285 with an .850 OPS in 102 games, with 14 home runs, 59 RBIs and 17 steals. The deal also includes an invitation to Major League Spring Training.
Jason Mackey: Jason.Mackey@pirates.com and @JMackey_PGH on X.