Why Abreu is one of MLB’s most underrated players

This browser does not support the video element.

When ballots for the 2026 American League Most Valuable Player Award were revealed on Nov. 12, it was little surprise that Red Sox first baseman Willson Contreras finished 10th after leading Boston’s offense throughout the season.

But just two spots below him? Right fielder Wilyer Abreu, who earned five down-ballot votes -- one fifth-place vote, one seventh-place vote, one eighth-place vote and two ninth-place votes -- to finish 12th overall.

It was well-earned recognition for Abreu, who racked up 5.9 Baseball-Reference Wins Above Replacement during an impressive all-around 2026. That was the fourth-highest bWAR total among AL position players, even ahead of AL MVP runner-up Junior Caminero (5.8).

While 2026 was easily Abreu’s best year in terms of bWAR, it was just a continuation of the strong all-around production Abreu has given the Red Sox since his big league debut in 2023.

Here are three reasons Abreu remains one of MLB’s most underrated players.

He’s a good fielder with an elite arm

One area in which Abreu consistently has received recognition is defense. After leading all players in Defensive Runs Saved in 2026 with +28, he claimed the AL Gold Glove Award in right field, joining Caleb Durbin (third base) and Ceddanne Rafaela (center field) to give Boston an AL-best three Gold Glovers. It was Abreu’s third consecutive Gold Glove win, the longest active streak by any player.

Abreu remained tops among AL right fielders despite demonstrating less range than he did in the past two seasons, racking up +2 Outs Above Average after +6 in 2024 and +8 in ’25. A major part of his defensive importance is his throwing arm, which is one of the best in the Majors: Abreu ranked ninth in MLB in arm strength at 95.3 mph, up more than 1 mph from last season (94.2). His arm is not only strong but accurate: Abreu prevented four extra runs from baserunners in 2026, tied for seventh most in the big leagues.

All told, Abreu ranked in the 78th percentile of qualifying players in 2026 with a +5 fielding run value -- down from +9 in 2024 and +8 in ’25. Even in a relative down year, he was one of MLB’s best defenders and arguably the best at his position.

This browser does not support the video element.

He’s a highly consistent hitter

It’s hard to get much more consistent from year to year than Abreu has been at the plate.

In 2024, 2025 and 2026, Abreu has posted a batting average between .247 and .253, an on-base percentage between .322 and .327 and an OPS between .773 and .781. His OPS+ in those three seasons? 118, 116, and 117, respectively, indicating that Abreu has been between 16-18% better than league average each season.

While that’s nowhere near MVP caliber (unanimous AL MVP Yordan Alvarez led the Majors with a 190 OPS+ in 2026, for instance), it’s hard to find. Among the 150 hitters with at least 400 plate appearances in each of the past three seasons, Abreu is one of just 17 hitters to post an OPS+ of at least 115 in all three years.

His offensive repertoire includes patience – he walked at an above-average 10.4% clip in 2026 -- as well as gap-to-gap ability and solid power. Abreu led the AL with 38 doubles in ’26 (thanks in part to playing his home games at Fenway Park) and also slugged a career-high 24 homers, a year after hitting 22 dingers in just 115 games.

Even with Contreras in the cleanup spot most nights, Abreu worked his way into the heart of Boston’s batting order thanks to his consistent production. In 2025, he most often batted fifth (36 games) while making double-digit appearances in the sixth and seventh spots. In 2026, he hit third in 106 of his 157 games, with Opening Day (No. 6 spot) the only time he hit lower than fifth.

This browser does not support the video element.

2026 was his best offensive year yet

Although his traditional numbers ended up in line with his past production, Abreu’s 2026 was comfortably his best offensive season in a number of advanced metrics.

By batting run value, Abreu ranked in the 76th percentile of MLB hitters with a career-high +13, up from +7 in 2024 and +8 in ’25. He ranked above the 80th percentile in expected wOBA (.346), expected slugging percentage (.468) and barrel rate (12.5%). Abreu’s .335 wOBA in 2026 meant he actually underperformed a bit due to poor batted-ball luck.

A fly-ball hitter by nature, Abreu leveled his swing out in 2026, hitting more line drives than he did in ’25 and raising his launch angle sweet-spot rate to a career-best 36.2%. The left-handed slugger also spread the ball around the field more in ’26, hitting more balls to left and center field than he did in previous years.

Bat tracking showed Abreu consistently made contact much deeper in the batter’s box in 2026: His average intercept point was 2.7 inches behind the front of home plate, compared to 1.5 inches in front of the plate in 2025. Among 210 qualifying hitters in 2026, only 18 others intercepted the ball deeper on average than Abreu did, a group including power hitters (Shohei Ohtani, Ben Rice and new Red Sox slugger Jake Bauers) and kings of contact (Jake Mangum, Steven Kwan and Chandler Simpson).

Abreu hit well enough in 2026 to become a Silver Slugger finalist for the first time: He was one of nine AL outfielders announced as finalists for three spots. Although Abreu couldn’t bring home his first Silver Slugger, his offensive stats were also up there with the best at his position.

This browser does not support the video element.

2027 outlook

Winning a Gold Glove. Being named a Silver Slugger finalist. Earning down-ballot MVP votes. Each accomplishment says a lot about Abreu’s standout 2026, but has the Red Sox outfielder reached his ceiling yet?

Abreu -- under contract with Boston for three more years -- will enter his age-28 season in 2027 hoping to surpass what will be a hard all-around year to beat. Speed is one area in which he could stand to improve: Abreu has never stolen more than eight bases in a season, even though his sprint speed was up to 28.0 feet per second (67th percentile) in 2026.

There’s always a possibility Abreu’s remarkable offensive consistency doesn’t last, leading to an uncharacteristically poor season at the plate. His range in right field could continue to trend downward, too. But there’s little reason to expect a player entering his prime -- and coming off a year as solid as Abreu’s 2026 -- to suddenly falter.

That’s especially true with Contreras in the mix, Bauers set to provide left-handed pop and Roman Anthony expected to be healthy for the Red Sox in 2027. With no pressure to be Boston’s lone offensive star, Abreu can continue to do what he does best. And if he does it just a little bit better than he did in 2026, 12th place in MVP voting might just be his floor.

More from MLB.com