These 3 pitches hold the key for free agent Trevor Rogers

This browser does not support the video element.

The free-agent market is flush with quality starting pitchers behind the offseason’s crown jewel, Tarik Skubal.

But who is the best arm of the non-Skubal bunch? Maybe it is Trevor Rogers.

The 29-year-old left-hander made 48 starts over the last two seasons. We can divide those 48 starts into three distinct stretches.

Stretch 1: May 24-Sept. 26, 2025
A dislocated kneecap delayed Rogers’ season debut by close to two months. But for the Orioles, it was well worth the wait. Rogers was brilliant (1.81 ERA, 2.82 FIP) with a 17.5% strikeout-minus-walk rate in 18 starts, looking the part of a true frontline starter.

Stretch 2: March 26-May 29, 2026
That sort of dominance did not carry over into the next season, at least not at the start. Rogers struggled (6.84 ERA, 4.85 FIP) through his first 10 starts of 2026 while also spending time on the IL with an illness. His 9.1% strikeout-minus-walk rate was nearly half of what it was in ‘25.

Stretch 3: June 4-Sept. 25, 2026
And then the old Rogers returned with a vengeance. He dominated (2.90 ERA, 2.89 FIP) in a 20-start stretch and, in some ways, looked even better than he did in 2025. His 20.5% strikeout-minus-walk ratio ranked among the best in that span.

Which version of Rogers will see in 2027? His three main pitches -- a four-seam fastball, changeup and sweeper -- will tell the story. Let's dive in.

Can the four-seam fastball stay elite?

It's not hyperbole to say that Rogers has one of baseball's best fastballs.

According to Statcast’s run value stat, only two four-seam fastballs have prevented more runs than Rogers’ heater since his 2025 season debut. You may have heard of the pitchers who throw them.

Most valuable four-seamers, since May 24, 2025

  1. Cam Schlittler (NYY): +37
  2. Jacob Misiorowski (MIL): +33
  3. Trevor Rogers (BAL): +28
  4. Yoshinobu Yamamoto (LAD): +26

It's the two reigning Cy Young Award winners followed by Rogers, a low-slot lefty whose 93.7 mph average fastball velocity ranked in the 38th percentile of MLB in 2026.

This browser does not support the video element.

This sounds a whole lot like Guardians All-Star Parker Messick, another funky left-hander who has a better fastball than you'd expect. Messick doesn't throw all that hard, but his fastball is successful at least partially because of a velo bump he experienced from 2025 to '26. It's a similar story for Rogers, whose average fastball velocity dipped to just 91.9 mph in 2024.

That offseason, Rogers visited Driveline, the cutting-edge facility that attracts so many from around the game. An initial strength assessment revealed that Rogers lacked the lower body strength necessary to throw hard. So, the Orioles, Driveline and Rogers worked together to devise a training regimen that would recoup that lost velo.

Rogers' four-seamer averaged 93.8 mph in 2026, his fastest in a single season since '22. That's just a hair better than league average -- which is 93.5 mph, for a left-hander -- but this fastball doesn't play like a league-average pitch.

"We got bullied tonight with the fastball," Dodgers manager Dave Roberts said in June after Rogers fired seven one-hit innings.

This browser does not support the video element.

"I thought there was extra life on his fastball," Nationals skipper Blake Butera said one week later, when Rogers allowed one run over 6 1/3 frames. "A little bit more than we expected."

The "expected" part is key here, because Rogers has an unusual fastball given his arm slot. His arm angle is 22 degrees, and low slots tend to lend themselves to pitch shapes with horizontal movement. While Rogers' fastball averages 11 inches of arm-side run, it also averages 15 inches of Induced Vertical Break, or rise. There's some two-plane movement here, which other low-slot pitchers tend to lack.

Last season, only three pitchers threw at least 100 fastballs from an arm angle below 23° while generating at least 15 inches of IVB on the pitch. The group was Rogers, Devin Williams and Craig Kimbrel.

Combine that with the fact that Rogers hides the baseball well, and you get a pitch that can bully a lineup even without top-shelf velocity.

And Rogers sure will bully you.

Rogers is at his best when his four-seamer is pounding the strike zone. That was one of the biggest "red flags" when he endured an underwhelming 10-start stretch to begin the 2026 season. But from June 4 through the end of the year, only three pitchers -- Kevin Gausman, Logan Henderson and Sean Manaea -- (min. 500 fastballs thrown) threw their four-seamer in the zone at a higher clip than Rogers.

Rogers' in-zone rate with his four-seamer

It makes sense that Rogers is at his best when he is filling up the zone. Hitters have trouble picking the four-seamer up because of its outlier shape and his funky motion, so why not come after them? It's his main weapon, too, regardless of count leverage.

Can the changeup bounce back?

Rogers is a fastball-changeup pitcher -- that's his bread and butter. But the changeup betrayed him for much of last season.

Rogers in 2025

Rogers in 2026

Rogers had the least valuable changeup among 48 qualified offerings in 2026, and it wasn't particularly close, either. No changeup allowed a higher batting average (.336) or a higher slugging percentage (.477).

It's not really clear what triggered the drop-off, although the models give us a bit of an idea. Stuff+ -- which attempts to quantify the “nastiness” of a pitch -- gave Rogers' changeup the lowest grade of his career last season. The same is true of his changeup's Location+ score, which grades a pitcher's ability to put a pitch in the right place. At the same time, neither grade was all that different from 2025, when it was still plenty valuable.

What we can do, though, is show how the absence of a reliable changeup impacted Rogers. For one, it affected his ability to get right-handed hitters out. A year after batting just .185 against Rogers, righties hit .269 off him in 2026. This was most notable with two strikes. Rogers allowed a .231 batting average to right-handed hitters in two-strike counts, which ranked among the highest in all of baseball (min. 100 PA ending in a two-strike count).

This browser does not support the video element.

His changeup was no longer a factor in these spots.

Rogers' changeup with two strikes to RHB

As it became less of a weapon, he threw it less often. Rogers used his changeup just 15.7% of the time in September, his lowest usage rate with the pitch in a single month in his career.

Can his sweeper take another step?

All of those changeups that Rogers stopped throwing? A lot of them turned into sweepers.

In many ways, the sweeper filled the void left behind by the changeup. He even threw both pitches in similar spots.

On his fruitful trip to Driveline, Rogers toyed with different grips and used the Edgertronic camera until he found something that worked. This gave his arsenal a new look. He didn't have a big breaking ball shape to break away from left-handed hitters and bend into righties. His three other main offerings -- the four-seamer, two-seamer and changeup -- all move in the other direction.

Rogers held the opposition to a .183 batting average with a 31.7% whiff rate against his sweeper last season. The pitch also had a more defined movement profile than it did in 2025, benefitting from three additional inches of horizontal break. That gave it even more of that side-to-side break in the opposite direction from his other primary pitches.

What next?

When things are clicking, here's how this is all supposed to look.

That is Rogers at his best. The fastball plays above the zone, the changeup dips below the knees, and the sweeper forces a chase off the plate.

Rogers showed he can succeed even without his changeup, relying on a deceptive four-seamer and the new sweeper to put away hitters. If he can rediscover his changeup -- and that will almost certainly be a point of conversation among Rogers and his new club -- then he will have three legitimate putaway pitches to use against opposite-sided hitters. That's why he's one of the best non-Skubal pitchers out there.

More from MLB.com