What the Padres' improved infield defense might mean for their offseason

38 minutes ago

The Padres are coming off their third consecutive postseason berth, earned in part because of a mid-year resurgence from  and routine excellence from . But don't overlook another key factor that helped spur San Diego's success -- one that will be equally important to consider when assessing the club's offseason activity. 

The Padres played undeniably poor infield defense in 2025. They proceeded to turn things around in a big way in '26. 

Padres' infield defense, by year

2025: -10 OAA, -13 FRV
2026: +17 OAA, +21 FRV

Let's get a few housekeeping items out of the way first. "OAA" stands for Outs Above Average, a range-based defensive metric from Statcast. "FRV" is short for Fielding Run Value, a composite metric that combines all of Statcast's defensive components -- fielding range, outfielder arms, first-base scoops and so on -- and puts them onto a scale.

Either way you look, the Padres improved their infield defense pretty significantly. Using FRV -- which, again, is a composite metric -- they had one of the best infield defenses in all of baseball.

Best INF defense, by FRV, 2026 

  1. Cardinals, +50
  2. Cubs, +29
  3. Royals, +22
  4. Padres, +21
  5. Diamondbacks, +20

This passes the smell test. The Cardinals have two of baseball's best defenders anchoring their middle infield. The Cubs had a historically great defensive unit. The Royals have Bobby Witt Jr., a perennial MVP candidate in no small part because of his glove. 

And the Padres? Where did these improvements come from, and how might San Diego approach its offseason to sustain this level of success in 2027? Let's take a look around the diamond to see what happened here, beginning with the highest-graded position. 

First base (+8 FRV)

This is all about , a free agent whom the Padres are interested in bringing back -- and for good reason. France won his first Gold Glove Award in the AL in 2025 and finished as a finalist this past season; his +10 FRV ranked second best among qualified first baseman behind Atlanta's Matt Olson. 

France has leaned into advanced metrics to become one of baseball's best defensive first basemen. In 2024, his -11 OAA ranked dead last among qualified first basemen, largely because he struggled to get to anything to his right, or his backhand. With help from then-Twins teammate Carlos Correa, France repositioned himself, moving back and to his left to try and cover more ground. 

No first baseman (min. 100 PA) had a deeper average starting point in 2026 than France. That paid off. 

France's OAA, lateral toward 3B

  • -12, 2024
  • +2, 2025
  • +2, 2026

France is also deft at receiving and scoops, ranking second best among qualifiers in our new Receiving OAA metrics. He makes these plays look rather easy.

France's play was a notable upgrade from Luis Arraez. San Diego shoehorned the bat-first Arraez at first base in 2025, and in 117 starts, he ranked last among qualifiers with -9 FRV. He also brought up the rear with -7 Receiving OAA, which is to say he was exceptionally poor at collecting throws from his infielders. That has a trickle-down effect on the rest of the infield. 

Third base (+6 FRV)

Two things can be true. is a gifted fielder. He also had one of the worst defensive seasons of his career in 2025, according to Statcast (-4 FRV, -6 OAA). 

But the 34-year-old turned back the clock with a vintage Machado performance last season, ranking in the 97th percentile of MLB with +12 OAA.

A good way to evaluate Machado's success is by looking at his success rate, or how many opportunities a player turns into outs. This is similar to fielding percentage, though it cares less about whether a batted ball was ruled a hit or an error, as determined by the official scorer. Success rate is simply about making a play or not making a play. 

Machado's success rate at 3B

  • 69%, 2024
  • 69%, 2025
  • 74%, 2026

What that tells us is that Machado made more plays last year. His 74% success rate was tied for the sixth highest among 41 qualified third basemen.

It's not as if Machado was getting easier plays to make, either. Estimated success rate -- which is based off things like distance, time and runner speed -- determines how many plays a player should make based on the difficulty of his opportunities. Machado's estimated success rate was 71% in both 2025 and 2026. So, last season, he made more plays than we'd have expected given the opportunities that he was presented with. In 2025, he made fewer plays than expected. 

If we take the difference between the plays he made (74%) and the plays an average player would have made (71%), we get a gap of +3%, tied for second among third basemen behind Milwaukee's Joey Ortiz. 

In other words: He looked a whole lot like Manny Machado.

Shortstop (+4 FRV)

owns a 101 OPS+ in four seasons with the Padres since signing an 11-year, $280 million deal, which has left a bit to be desired. But, by OAA, he's been solid in the field -- and actually much better in that regard than he was with the Red Sox. 

Bogaerts regressed a bit in 2026, recording +3 OAA after posting +7 OAA in 2025. Is that the beginning of a decline that might force San Diego to move him off shortstop, or can he continue to play above-average defense? 

For one, he's still elite at fielding the ball on the run, a skill that he emphasized with a new defensive setup four seasons ago. Only six qualified shortstops graded better at fielding balls "in" last season, per Statcast.

On the other hand, Bogaerts is entering his age-34 season and just posted the lowest sprint speed (27.1 ft/sec, which is roughly league average) in a full season under Statcast. It's probably not a coincidence that he had less lateral range, both toward third base and toward first base. In 2025, he accumulated +5 OAA moving side-to-side; that dipped to -4 OAA in '26.

Second base (+2 FRV)

Five players saw time at second base for the Padres in each of the last two seasons. The guys in 2026 were simply not as bad as the guys in '25. 

Padres second basemen posted +2 FRV last season, which ranked in the middle of the pack in MLB. Could this be even more of a strength in 2027? 

Two players under contract for next season figure to play a role here. The first is , the longtime utility man who has seen the bulk of playing time at second base in each of the past two seasons. Since 2024, though, Cronenworth ranks as one of the game's worst defenders at second base.

Then there is , the 30-year-old who signed a four-year deal with the Padres last offseason after coming over from the KBO. He hit just .191 across 78 games in his first taste of the big leagues, but he did play plus defense at three infield positions, including second base. If he could hit just a little bit more, the glove makes it easy to justify playing him.

It's clear that the Padres' infield defense played a role in their success last season. Here's another piece of food for thought: How did  pitch to a 3.21 ERA in 32 starts despite a career-high walk rate and a career-low strikeout rate? In part because San Diego's infielders recorded +11 OAA when King was on the mound. Put another way, no pitcher benefitted in a bigger way from their infield defense than King did last season. This matters, and we'll see how the Padres try to put together another strong infield as we head toward 2027.