Examining the Yankees' options at third base for 2027
This browser does not support the video element.
Who's on third?
No, he's on first. But for the Yankees, the current answer to that question for 2027 may be, appropriately, "I don't know."
The Yankees will certainly look to upgrade at the hot corner this offseason. Let's run through their options internally as well as some players they may pursue in free-agent and trade markets.
On the roster
Ryan McMahon: The cupboard isn't completely bare. McMahon, who turns 32 years old next month, is owed $18 million in 2027, which is the final year of his current contract. Often a standout defender, he was just league average at third base (0 outs above average) in 2026. And offensively, McMahon has a lowly .211/.289/.349 slash line with a 30.8% strikeout rate since New York acquired him ahead of the 2025 Trade Deadline. Those struggles are why the Yankees are monitoring the third-base market in the first place.
This browser does not support the video element.
José Caballero: Caballero played 37 games at third base for the Yankees this past season, starting 23. He also saw time at second base, shortstop and all three outfield positions. He came through with some big hits upon joining the Yankees in the second half of the 2025 season, but he has been a below-average bat throughout his career and posted an 83 wRC+ this past season. Caballero is best deployed as a Swiss Army knife/pinch-runner off the bench.
Anthony Volpe: Volpe made his first MLB start at third base in the penultimate game of the regular season. He also played the final two innings of ALDS Game 3 at third. He could be an option in theory, but it's much more likely that he spends the majority of his 2027 season at second base. Perhaps things change if the Yankees land one of the best available players at second, like left-handed slugger Brandon Lowe.
Prospects? There doesn't appear to be anyone ready to break through immediately. Of the Yanks' Top 30 Prospects according to MLB Pipeline, the only player who is expected to arrive in 2027 and has experience at third is left-handed hitter Coby Morales, their No. 29 prospect. But he has yet to play above Double-A and is probably better suited at first base or a corner outfield spot.
Free agents
Teruaki Sato: The 2025 Central League Most Valuable Player and 2026 Triple Crown winner, Sato is one of the most sought-after hitters available this year. MLB.com's Mark Feinsand wrote Tuesday that the 27-year-old is high on the Yankees' list of third-base options. Sato's game is similar to countryman Munetaka Murakami's -- lots of power, lots of K's, lots of uncertainty about his best fit on defense. While the Yankees would probably love to add his power to their lineup, the questions about his ability to handle third base as well as his high-whiff approach from the left side of the plate make him an imperfect match. Sato is widely expected to sign with an MLB team by Dec. 1.
This browser does not support the video element.
Alec Bohm: We know there has been some interest here. The Yankees reportedly met with Bohm during last week's GM Meetings in Las Vegas. But sources told Feinsand that the Yankees "aren’t high on the long-time Phillies infielder."
That said, Bohm does check a few boxes for New York: He's a right-handed hitter who makes a lot of contact and has been an above-average bat during his seven-year career (107 wRC+). Bohm also ended the 2026 season on a tear, batting .305 with an .821 OPS over his final 47 games with Philadelphia.
However, that hot streak coincided with Bohm moving across the diamond from third to first, and that was a sensible shift since the 30-year-old has consistently rated out as a poor defender at third. He owns a career -16 OAA as a third baseman, including a -8 in 2026. Would the Yankees give him another shot to prove himself there despite his struggles?
Si Hwan Roh: Roh is a right-handed hitter who has been one of the top players in the KBO since the start of 2023. During that four-season span, he put up an .863 OPS and 116 home runs. This past season, he slashed .283/.360/.505 with 29 home runs in 127 games for the Hanwha Eagles. He will be just 26 years old in December and although a scout said “he’s a little bit weak defensively," he has the arm strength to stay at third. The MLB negotiating window for Roh will expire on Dec. 1 at 5 p.m. ET.
J.P. Crawford: A longtime shortstop with Seattle, Crawford played 33 games at third base in 2026. It was his first action at third since 2018, and he was league average on defense (0 OAA). He doesn't chase out of the zone and commonly logs high walk rates. The lefty hitter has shown some pop at the plate, highlighted by a 19-homer season in 2023. He hit 14 homers and posted a 105 wRC+ this past season in 116 games as he dealt with injuries to his right hand and left wrist. Crawford, who turns 32 in January, has a .245/.340/.367 slash line and a 104 wRC+ over 10 seasons.
This browser does not support the video element.
Jazz Chisholm Jr.: Chisholm had an up-and-down three-season run with the Yanks. After winning a Silver Slugger Award in 2025 -- a season in which he played 29 games at third base -- he produced below-average offensive numbers in '26. Even coming off a down year, Chisholm is reportedly drawing interest from more than one-third of the league. It's unclear if the Yankees have any desire for a reunion, but the fact that they chose not to extend a qualifying offer to him hints that they do not.
Eugenio Suárez: With 351 career homers, Suárez carries a very powerful bat from the right side. He also strikes out a ton and makes more sense at DH instead of third base as he enters his age-35 season. The Yankees already have a logjam there.
Possible trade targets
Isaac Paredes, Astros: Houston exercised Paredes' $13.35 million club option earlier this month. But after attempting to trade him last offseason, the Astros will likely try again this offseason to clear up their excess of corner infielders. The 27-year-old Paredes is coming off a stellar 2026 season in which he had a 130 wRC+ and a career-best 4.4 FanGraphs WAR. Conversely, he is a subpar defender at third, and his pull-happy approach from the right side might lead to some fly balls that would have been homers inside Houston's Daikin Park just being long outs at Yankee Stadium.
Corey Seager: Seager hasn't manned the hot corner since playing a small handful of games there during his 2015 debut season. But the Yankees and Rangers have reportedly discussed the 32-year-old star, and MLB Network insider Jon Heyman believes the Yankees could ask Seager to shift to third, keeping George Lombard Jr. at shortstop. Seager is still a potent hitter when healthy, but injuries have forced him to miss significant time in each of the previous four seasons. He has a partial no-trade clause and is owed about $155 million through 2031.
This browser does not support the video element.
Matt Chapman, Giants: The two-time Platinum Glove winner at third was viewed as a trade fit for the Yankees during the summer, and the Giants would probably like to move him this offseason. Chapman's defense remains strong, but he had a career-worst year offensively in 2026, is heading into his age-34 season, owns a full no-trade clause and still has four seasons left on his six-year, $151 million contract.