Breaking down the surprisingly robust second-base market

14 minutes ago

The 2026-27 free-agent and trade market might be underwhelming compared to recent years, but there is one area that certainly isn’t lacking: second base. 

MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand has four second basemen listed in his top 30. It’s the same number of second basemen for his trade candidate list. There’s no shortage of teams who need a new second basemen and there is buzz aplenty.

Here’s a breakdown of the second-base market.

Who are the top free agents?

(Feinsand’s No. 7 free agent) is the top second baseman on the market and one of the best all-around hitters, period. The 32-year-old Lowe owns a career .810 OPS and has slugged 192 home runs -- and he is coming off a career season, when he had an .824 OPS with 35 home runs and a career-best 4.9 WAR, per FanGraphs, thanks to much-improved defense.

(No. 12) is next up behind Lowe and is likewise coming off an excellent season, while boasting an impressive resume. Arraez’s .316 average is the best among active players and he has a preternatural ability to put the bat on the ball (career 5.8 percent strikeout rate). Arraez’s lack of power (42 career homers) will always cap his ceiling, but like Lowe, he improved his defense at second base, leading to the highest WAR (4.1) in his career. 

(No. 15) is coming into free agency in a very different situation than Lowe and Arraez. Chisholm had a career year in 2025 (.813 OPS, 4.3 WAR, 31 homers, 31 stolen bases), but saw his offensive numbers drop near a league-average level (.711 OPS, 19 home runs). Chisholm made up for some of that with excellent defense (15 Outs Above Average) and baserunning (41 steals), but there are questions about his offense. 

Rounding out this group of top free-agent second basemen is (No. 21). The days of Torres hitting 25-plus homers a season are likely gone, but he has essentially swapped out one valuable skill set (power) for another (plate discipline). Since 2025, Torres’ .361 OBP is tied for the 14th-best mark among all hitters with 1,000 plate appearances, while his 13.5 percent walk is tied for 10th-best. He’s the type of bat you can slot near the top of the order as an on-base machine.

Who could be available in a trade?

If teams miss out on one of those four, there’s a strong group of potential trade targets that could be viable options. 

The top guy is Arizona’s , who could be the best player traded this offseason. Marte has found himself in trade rumors for the better part of this year and that possibility might come this offseason, although his 10-and-5 rights mean he has a say on where he goes. The 33-year-old Marte owns a career .815 OPS with 193 home runs and had a .748 OPS with 22 home runs this past season.

Marte might be the best second baseman traded this offseason, but 22-year-old could be the most interesting one. The No. 1 pick in the 2022 Draft and a consensus top prospect before debuting, Holliday has had an up-and-down career to date, with a .654 OPS through 307 games. Holliday, though, has the age, pedigree and upside that other teams will jump all over to acquire. 

has been a steady producer in his first four seasons and is still just 27 years old. What he lacks in power (career .371 SLG) is made up for by an excellent average (.291), walk rate (9.6 percent) and strikeout rate (14.8 percent). He’s also been profiled much better at second base after beginning his MLB tenure at shortstop.

Rounding out this list is , the 25-year-old who has found himself with a clear lane to a full-time position. Selected by the Cubs in the first round of the 2023 Draft, Shaw quickly blossomed into one of the best prospects in baseball, but only has a .704 OPS through his first 203 games. With Alex Bregman, Dansby Swanson, Nico Hoerner and Michael Busch locked into full-time infield positions for Chicago, Shaw already experimented with time in right field last season, but a change of scenery might be in store.

Which teams have a need?

Perusing the FanGraphs Depth Charts, you can scroll to the bottom of the second-base rankings and target some teams that could use an upgrade. There’s the Dodgers, who might have a rosier outlook if didn’t struggle with injuries in recent years -- he hasn’t cleared 100 games in a season since 2023. 

The Mets, too, might be in the market for a new second baseman after endured a career-worst season (.620 OPS, -0.5 WAR). The 36-year-old Semien is owed $46 million through the 2028 season, so there’s a financial incentive to stick with him, but the club might need to find a more viable long-term option.

Other playoff hopefuls that could be targeting second basemen include the Yankees, Orioles, Tigers, Reds and Pirates. But there are plenty of other clubs that could be in on this market. 

What’s the latest buzz?

  • MLB Network insider Jon Paul Morosi reported on Nov. 12 that Chisholm is drawing “broad interest” and that 11 teams have engaged in discussions with his representatives. 
  • MLB.com’s Jake Rill reported on Nov. 14 that the Orioles have had a dialogue with the D-backs about Marte. That’s obviously notable given that Holliday is viewed as one of the more intriguing trade targets. The division-rival Blue Jays, too, are shopping for plenty of hitters, which reportedly includes Marte.