So many teams need starting pitching ... which potential sellers will capitalize?
This browser does not support the video element.
Starting pitching is always at a premium, no matter the time of year. But with the way this season is shaping up, that demand could hit a fever pitch ahead of this year’s Trade Deadline.
As usual, chatter around pending free agents such as Tarik Skubal and Freddy Peralta figures to lead much of the trade conversation. But there also could be an especially robust market for non-rental starters, enough to make clubs that might otherwise hang onto those pitchers think twice.
Here’s a look at why -- and which teams could be positioned to capitalize if they’re willing to deal.
1. Several unlikely contenders have emerged, and they all need rotation help
One of the defining storylines of the first half has been the unexpected rise of the White Sox, Nationals and Cardinals. None of those teams was built with 2026 in mind, but all three have leapt into contention behind an impressive collection of young position players.
We’ll throw the Athletics into this mix as well. They haven’t looked nearly as strong as the other three teams, but they are right in the thick of the American League West and AL Wild Card races thanks to their own core of superb bats.
The problem? None seems to have enough starting pitching to make it through a 162-game season. Seriously. Check out the stats: ERA. FIP. Expected wOBA allowed. For the most part, the numbers aren't pretty.
All four teams seem to be facing the same reality as the Trade Deadline approaches -- they need more pitching to make a real playoff push.
That said, it probably doesn’t make sense for any of these upstarts to burn future assets on a two-month rental, especially with so few difference-makers readily available in that market (more on that below). The more logical target is a starter who can help in 2026 and beyond.
This browser does not support the video element.
2. There may not be many desirable rental arms to be had
Several factors are working against teams hoping to find a needle-mover on the rental market.
For one, the standings are extremely bunched together, and there’s little indication that is going to change over the next few weeks. Take the Blue Jays as an example. The reigning AL champions have had a disappointing season but are firmly in the AL Wild Card picture anyway. Even if they continue to tread water, it’s unlikely that they are going to drop down far enough to trade pending free agent Kevin Gausman.
The emergence of clubs like the Cardinals could also end up diminishing the supply of coveted rental pitchers. When St. Louis signed Dustin May to a one-year, $12.5 million contract over the winter, the expectation was that he’d spend a few months there and then be traded to a contender. But the Cards are winning, and May has emerged as their ace over his past 12 starts (2.54 ERA, 2.68 FIP).
The Red Sox could sell, but Sonny Gray has a full no-trade clause.
Then there’s Skubal and Peralta. The Tigers may very well trade Skubal, but the asking price is likely going to be prohibitive for many clubs. The Mets are also going to want a lot back for Peralta after giving up two top prospects -- Jett Williams and Brandon Sproat -- to acquire him over the winter.
This browser does not support the video element.
3. It's a weak year for the reliever trade market
For teams that can't land a starting pitcher at the Deadline, the bullpen is usually a reliable fallback. But after reliever deals dominated the Trade Deadline in 2025 -- Mason Miller, Jhoan Duran, David Bednar, Ryan Helsley, Griffin Jax, Tyler Rogers were all moved -- the pool of high-end relievers figures to be considerably smaller this year. Red Sox lefty Aroldis Chapman may be the only reliever of that caliber available.
All of which points to one conclusion: controllable starters are going to be the most coveted commodity at this year's Deadline. And the buyers won't just be the White Sox, Cardinals, Nationals and Athletics. A long list of additional clubs -- from perennial contenders to teams on the fringe -- could be in the mix as well, which only drives the price higher.
We saw the type of return starters like that can fetch over the offseason when MacKenzie Gore (Nationals to Rangers), Shane Baz (Rays to Orioles) and Edward Cabrera (Marlins to Cubs) were dealt.
That brings us to the key question: Which potential sellers should be looking to capitalize on the demand?
There are five in particular.
Kansas City Royals
Kansas City made the playoffs in 2024 and won 82 games a year ago, but the club has cratered in ’26. The Royals aren’t going to launch a full-scale rebuild when they have Bobby Witt Jr. in his prime, but they badly need to retool.
With starters Cole Ragans (controllable through 2028) and Kris Bubic (pending free agent) both injured, their best chance to do that is dealing veteran hurlers Seth Lugo and Michael Wacha, each of whom is signed through 2027 with a ’28 club option.
Los Angeles Angels
You can usually count on the Angels to stick with the status quo, but this is about to be their 12th straight season without a playoff berth. It’s probably time to change up the approach. Mike Trout likely isn’t going anywhere, but the Halos have a chance to land one of the biggest prospect hauls of any team at this year’s Trade Deadline if they put starters Reid Detmers and José Soriano on the table. Detmers and Soriano are both under 28 years old and controllable through 2028, but it’s hard to believe either pitcher is ever going to have more trade value than he will this summer.
Detmers has been quite inconsistent during his career and even spent all of 2025 in the bullpen, but the former top prospect is having a breakout campaign in ’26. He’s recorded a 1.36 ERA with 39 K’s over his past five starts and entered Friday with the fourth-lowest expected ERA (2.77) among pitchers who have faced at least 250 batters, behind Jacob Misiorowski, Paul Skenes and Shohei Ohtani.
Soriano has faded after a historic start to the year and tends to get wild at times, but a hard-throwing 27-year-old who misses bats and racks up grounders should generate plenty of trade interest nonetheless.
This browser does not support the video element.
Minnesota Twins
Minnesota was one of the most active sellers last summer but didn't commit to a full rebuild, retaining starters Joe Ryan and Pablo López along with center fielder Byron Buxton, who has a full no-trade clause.
After losing López to UCL repair surgery, the Twins shouldn't wait any longer to flip Ryan. He's going to be a free agent after 2027, and the Twins are unlikely to contend before then. Even with Buxton having a career year and Ryan pitching like an ace, they were four games under .500 and had been outscored by 24 runs entering play on Friday.
San Francisco Giants
The Giants have made the playoffs only once (2021) in the past nine seasons and are closer to the cellar-dwelling Rockies than they are to the first-place Dodgers in the National League West this year. It’s time for a change by the Bay. However, while multiple sources told MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand that the Giants have let other teams know they are willing to trade a number of veterans -- including Rafael Devers, Willy Adames and Matt Chapman -- they apparently have no plans to move ace Logan Webb.
The issue for the Giants is that, with all of the money still owed to Devers, Adames and Chapman, none is likely to bring back a huge return. The same goes for pending free agents Luis Arraez and Robbie Ray. Dealing Webb might be the best chance for the team to retool its roster. It would be difficult to part with him, but San Francisco shouldn’t be completely opposed to it if another team is willing to pony up.
Texas Rangers
The Rangers won a World Series in 2023 and looked like they were set up to contend for a long time to come after that season, but it hasn't worked out that way. Texas was a sub-.500 team each of the past two years and is under .500 again in 2026. The team needs to consider a shake-up.
They likely aren’t going to trade Gore after they just gave up so many prospects to get him, but they also have two-time Cy Young winner Jacob deGrom and proven postseason performer Nathan Eovaldi signed through 2027. The Rangers may have to eat some money, given what deGrom and Eovaldi are still owed, but both pitchers could be popular trade targets for playoff contenders.