Each team's all-time single-season ace

Which pitcher should take the hill with everything on the line?

September 22nd, 2018

The thing about baseball is that you can have the best lineup in the history of the game, but if it runs up against a hot pitcher at the wrong time, it's essentially useless. Nothing happens until the pitcher throws the ball; we're all reacting to him. And when you have a truly great one, it doesn't matter how fantastic a hitter you are: He can get you out regardless. A true ace can be unhittable.

Imagine, then, a tournament of the future, one that transcends space, time and death, in which every franchise had to win one game, with its best pitcher ever, for its own survival. That'd be fun, right? Who would you want throwing in that game? This conversation happens a lot this time of year, when we look ahead to the Wild Card Games, where one dominant pitching performance can change everything. (Remember in 2014 and '16?)

With all of this in mind, we take a look at each franchise's One Game To Live pitcher, the one pitcher, during his one peak season, who you'd put on the mound with it all on the line. You just get to pick one pitcher, and one season, when he was at the height of his game. Who's your pick? Here are mine.


Blue Jays: 1997 Roger Clemens

21-7, 2.05 ERA, 292 K

As tempting as it might be to pick a Dave Stieb or Roy Halladay season, Clemens was unbelievable in 1997; according to bWAR, this was, in fact, the best season of his career. This was the season in which he won the fourth of his seven Cy Young Awards; he won one each of his two seasons in Toronto. (Clemens was really good.)

Orioles: 1975 Jim Palmer

23-11, 2.09 ERA, 10 shutouts, 323 IP

Palmer was never a huge strikeout pitcher, all told, but as many innings as he pitched, he didn't need to be. This was the second of his three Cy Young Award-winning seasons. Palmer somehow threw 25 complete games.

Rays: 2018

21-5, 1.90 ERA

Yeah, we'll opt for this year. 's 2012 was close, but Snell has struck out more batters a game and may end up even winning more games. And he's pretty much the only starting pitcher on his team!

Red Sox: 2000 Pedro Martinez

18-6, 1.74 ERA, 284 Ks, 2.17 FIP

This was peak Pedro, at the absolute apex of his powers. There may have never been a more viscerally enjoyable pitcher to watch than Martinez at the turn of the century.

Yankees: 1978 Ron Guidry

25-3, 1.74 ERA

Guidry got a relatively late start to his career and battled injuries in his mid-30s, so he never quite had the longevity to be a Hall of Famer. But 1978, at the age of 27, Guidry was as good as any Yankee has ever been.


Indians: 1946 Bob Feller

26-15, 2.18 ERA, 348 K

We'll never know how hard Feller truly threw … but to batters, judging from the numbers, it must have looked about 150 mph.

Royals: 2009 Zack Greinke

16-8, 2.16 ERA, 242 K

It's close between Greinke and a couple of late-1980s Bret Saberhagen seasons, but Greinke's lone Cy Young Award-winning season is probably the call. His ERA actually jumped two runs the next season.

Tigers: 1968 Denny McLain

31-6, 1.96 ERA

Advanced stats would argue this wasn't even McLain's best year, and there are some great seasons not here, as well as the great 1976 Mark Fidrych year … but 31 wins are 31 wins.

Twins: 2004 Johan Santana

20-6, 2.61 ERA, 265 K

We're not counting the Washington Senators era here, obviously, or it would be any one of about nine Walter Johnson seasons.

White Sox: 1917 Eddie Cicotte

28-12, 1.53 ERA, 346 2/3 IP

Cicotte should have had 30 wins in 1919, but White Sox owner Charles Comiskey ordered him benched so he wouldn't get a 30-win bonus he would be owed. That led, of course, to Cicotte taking money to fix the 1919 World Series, the scandal that would get Cicotte banned from baseball.


Angels: 1977 Nolan Ryan

19-16, 2.77 ERA, 341 K

An argument could be made that teammate Frank Tanana had an even better year in 1977 than Ryan … but with one game to decide the fate of your franchise, you really would rather face Ryan than Tanana?

Astros: 1986 Mike Scott

18-10, 2.22 ERA, 306 K

Apologies to some wonderful Roy Oswalt years, not to mention a couple of great Clemens ones, but Scott was otherworldly in 1986.

Athletics: 1931 Lefty Grove

31-4, 2.06 ERA

Grove threw 27 complete games in 1931 … and notched five saves to boot.

Mariners: 1995 Randy Johnson

18-2, 2.48 ERA, 294 K

One gets shivers just thinking about having Johnson staring down at you during this era. So much hair!

Rangers: 1974 Ferguson Jenkins

25-12, 2.82 ERA, 225 K

Jenkins has always been underappreciated. This was his first, better stint with the team.


Braves: 1995 Greg Maddux

19-2, 1.63 ERA

Maddux was an absolute magician. It was unfair what he could do while making it look so simple.

Marlins: 1996 Kevin Brown

17-11, 1.89 ERA

Brown's general orneriness had a tendency to mask how dominating a pitcher he could be.

Mets: 1985 Dwight Gooden

24-4, 1.53 ERA, 268 K

is Jacob deGrom, and Tom Seaver was Tom Seaver … but no one was ever better than 1985 Dwight Gooden. At the age of 20!

Nationals: 2017 Max Scherzer

16-6, 2.51 ERA, 268 K

We're -- controversially! -- ignoring the Expos and sticking with the Nats here. It's possible this year has, in fact, been better.

Phillies: 1972 Steve Carlton

27-10, 1.97 ERA, 310 K

This was the year after the Cardinals traded him, by the way. And on a Phils team that had 59 wins. Carlton won 46 percent of their games!


Brewers: 1986 Teddy Higuera

20-11, 2.79 ERA

It is very tempting to go with 2008 , who, after all, only made 17 starts.

Cardinals: 1968 Bob Gibson

22-9, 1.12 ERA, 268 K

How in the world did Gibson lose nine games?

Cubs: 1992 Greg Maddux

20-11, 2.18 ERA

Sorry John Clarkson, Pete Alexander and Three Finger Brown, but we had to stick with modern era. So it's Maddux again!

Pirates: 1945 Preacher Roe

14-13, 2.87 ERA

For such a storied franchise, the Pirates don't actually have a ton of incredible individual starting pitching seasons.

Reds: 1993 Jose Rijo

14-9, 2.48 ERA, 227 K

Kids, ask your loud uncle: Rijo is the greatest pitcher no one remembers was a great pitcher.

Video: [email protected]: Big Unit completes Opening Day shutout


D-backs: 2002 Randy Johnson

24-5, 2.32 ERA, 334 K

Somehow, Johnson was 38 when he did this.

Dodgers: 1966 Sandy Koufax

27-9, 1.73 ERA, 317 K

It's probably too late for to ever match this.

Giants: 1908 Christy Mathewson

37-11, 1.43 ERA, 259 K, 42 BB

We make an exception for our "modern era" rule because … jeez, look at the K/BB ratio.

Padres: 1998 Kevin Brown

18-7, 2.38 ERA, 257 K, 49 BB

Bet you didn't imagine seeing Brown on this list twice, did you?

Rockies: 2018

16-7, 2.84 ERA

The only season that's even close is 's 2010 season … and Freeland may end up having considerably more staying power.