By the time the MLB postseason starts on Oct. 7, the dust will have settled on an action-packed regular season, as well as the ebbs and flows that come with it. Winning and losing streaks alike will be things of the past.
That includes the September hot streak enjoyed by the Guardians, who entered the month with a one-game lead over the Twins and the knowledge that in all likelihood, no AL Central team would qualify for one of the three Wild Card spots. They responded by going 21-8, leaving them with an astounding 11 1/2-game division lead as of Sept. 30.
But now the question is whether Cleveland's overall success down the stretch, will translate into postseason glory. More broadly, does late-season “momentum” -- or a lack thereof -- carry over into the playoffs? Let’s look back at recent history and see what it means for the Guardians and the rest of the postseason field.
Note: Mentions of "September" or the "final month" refer to regular-season games played in both September and October.
As impressive as Cleveland's run has been, the club’s 21-8 record in September is not the best final month from a postseason team in recent history. Most recently, the 2021 Cardinals played themselves into a playoff spot with the help of a 17-game win streak, but were ultimately eliminated by the 106-win Dodgers in the NL Wild Card Game. Also notable is Cleveland's 2017 squad, which won 22 straight games beginning in late August en route to a 26-4 season-ending record. They were eliminated in the ALDS that year. The '02 A’s suffered the same fate after going 42-12 in the final two months, including a 20-game win streak.
The 2022 Guardians also bring to mind the '07 Rockies, who made a mad dash to the postseason by winning 14 of their final 15, including a tiebreaker Game 163 against the Padres. That club seemed to keep its magic going, sweeping the NLDS and NLCS, but it lost four straight to the Red Sox in the World Series.
In fact, entering 2022, only two of the 32 teams to post a final-month winning percentage of at least .700 in the Wild Card Era (since 1995) went on to win the World Series. Those were the 2020 Dodgers (17-7, .708) -- although the final month accounted for nearly half of that shortened season -- and the '17 Astros (21-8, .724).
How has the hottest team fared?
In the nine previous full seasons since the second Wild Card was introduced (2012-21), only the '12 Giants -- who tied the Braves that year with a 20-10 final-month record -- went on to win it all after posting the best final-month winning percentage among playoff teams. Of the other seven “hottest” teams, only the '19 Astros even made it to the World Series.
Hottest playoff teams by final-month record (in the multi-Wild Card Era, since 2012)
2021 Giants (23-7) -- lost NLDS
2020 Dodgers (17-7) -- won World Series
2019 Astros (19-6) -- lost World Series
2018 Astros (21-6) -- lost ALCS
2017 Indians (26-4) -- lost ALDS
2016 Red Sox (19-10) -- lost ALDS
2015 Cubs (23-9) -- lost NLCS
2014 Nationals (19-8) -- lost NLDS
2013 Indians (21-6) -- lost ALWC
2012 Giants/Braves (20-10) -- won World Series/lost NLWC
So while it certainly doesn't hurt to hit your stride during the stretch run, it hardly guarantees a title is in a team's future.
What about last year's Braves? They played well over the final month (18-11), but their .621 win percentage over that stretch was only fourth highest among playoff teams, behind three fellow NL clubs: the Giants, Dodgers and Cardinals.
What about the coldest team?
Final-month records can admittedly be deceiving, as teams that clinch a postseason berth early might rest players once their playoff seeding is settled. For example, the 2015 Royals were the first team to clinch a division title when they locked up the AL Central on Sept. 24, and they still retained home-field advantage throughout their championship run despite posting a 15-17 record to close the regular season. They are the only team in the multi-Wild Card era to win a World Series after going under .500 in the final month.
Coldest playoff teams by final-month record (in the multi-Wild Card Era, since 2012)
2021 Brewers (14-15) -- lost NLDS
2020 Astros (10-17) -- lost ALCS
2019 Yankees / Braves (14-11) -- lost ALCS / lost NLDS
2018 Indians (14-14) -- lost NLDS
2017 Twins / Rockies (15-14) -- lost ALWC / lost NLWC
2016 Blue Jays (13-16) -- lost ALCS
2015 Astros (13-17) -- lost ALDS
2014 A's (10-16) -- lost ALWC
2013 Dodgers (12-15) -- lost NLCS
2012 Rangers (15-16) -- lost ALWC
On the other hand, four of the 10 World Series winners during that span actually ranked among the bottom half of all playoff teams in final-month winning percentage. The only team to win the World Series from the second Wild Card slot was the 2014 Giants, and they backed into playoff position by dropping the NL West lead on July 26 and going 30-28 afterward, including 13-12 in September.
In other words, don’t worry too much about the postseason prospects of teams with less impressive final months, such as the Mariners (15-14), Rays (14-17) and Phillies (14-15).
Do eventual champions finish strong?
Incredibly. Or not at all. It depends. In terms of winning percentage, teams such as the 2012 Giants and '17 Astros were at least 85 points better across the season’s final month than they were overall. At the same time, teams such as the '15 Royals and '18 Red Sox were just as far off their full-season record in the other direction, but nonetheless “flipped the switch” and went on to hoist the Commissioner's Trophy once everything was said and done.
Every other team in the second Wild Card Era found itself somewhere in between. Even champions -- such as the 2019 Nationals (who clawed back from a slow start) and the '16 Cubs (who posted a dominant 50-23 second-half record) -- weren’t markedly better in the final month than their overall record, despite feeling like teams that created momentum heading into the playoffs.
At FanGraphs, Jay Jaffe pooled together the numbers all the way back to the 1995 season and found that the results remained the same, adding that “[final-month] winning percentages just don’t tell us very much at all about what happens in [the playoffs].”
What are the implications of Game 162?
Some teams may have a lot on the line on the final day of the regular season. But does the result of that 162nd game matter once the postseason begins? Almost certainly not. And yet, recent seasons have seen a curious trend.
Each of the past eight World Series winners won their final regular-season game. The same goes for 18 of the past 20 AL or NL pennant winners, with the lone exceptions being the 2012 Giants and the '13 Red Sox.
Momentum may be a myth, but the confidence that comes with being a successful team winning big games late in a season is still very real. Per FanGraphs, the average win percentage of a pennant-winning team between 1995 and 2019 was .590 from the start of a season through August and .591 over the final month. So while a team hustling to the finish line or coasting in may not be predictive of postseason success, the overall records of the past 50 pennant winners average out to that of about a 96-win team. Simply put, the cream rises to the top.