Globe iconLogin iconRecap iconSearch iconTickets icon

Matt Carpenter bunted to beat the shift and wound up with a stand-up double

The infield shift. Is it "ruining" baseball? Is it the wave of the future? Is it actually not any of those hyperbolic concepts, but rather just an at-times savvy defensive maneuvering employed by number-crunching teams?

Whichever camp you belong to from the options above, you'll likely have a strong reaction to what took place during the Cardinals' 5-0 win over the Marlins on Monday night with Matt Carpenter at the plate.

Miami put on a very dramatic infield shift, leaving nobody within three zip codes of the third-base bag. OK, that's an exaggeration, but you get the point. Anyway, Carpenter bunted and wound up on second base with a stand-up double:

It was weird.

Those who mash their keyboards, shouting "JUST BUNT THE BALL! BEAT THE SHIFT!" might see this display from Carpenter and feel justified. They might think this is precisely how this scenario will play out every time.

But if you watch enough baseball, you'll know ... the batter will most definitely not end up with a double on a sneaky bunt attempt every time. How he fares has everything to do with the technique he uses, the pitch thrown by the pitcher, and so on. Carpenter did everything to perfection, and beat the system this time. But will the same thing happen next time he or somebody else tries it? Probably not. Who knows?

Baseball is weird.