Amir Garrett earned a reputation as a high-octane big league reliever. That extended both to his arm -- pumping high-90s fastballs from the left side -- and his personality. He was always fiery on the mound after a key strikeout.
But did you know that Garrett almost didn’t play baseball?
An excellent athlete at 6-foot-5, the Nevada native stood out in youth baseball circuits but flashed the most on the hardwood. He was a four-star prospect, ranked inside the top 70 recruits nationwide. That led Garrett to a commitment to play his college basketball at St. John’s.
But Garrett’s father asked him to give baseball one more shot. To work out for one month and see how his arm developed.
“I’m sitting there like, ‘Aw man, forget this baseball stuff. I don’t wanna play baseball,’” Garrett said, recalling his journey on the latest episode of the 6-1-1 Podcast with Jimmy Rollins and Ryan Howard. “For you [Dad], I’ll do it.”
And it’s a good thing he did.
Garrett’s velocity -- he said he threw 93-94 mph when he was first clocked around age 13 -- immediately came back. He impressed at a workout, originally thought to be in front of just one or two MLB scouts, before Garrett said every team showed up. The southpaw’s upper-90s fastball quickly grabbed attention.
“At that point, I’m kind of like a ghost. It was like, ‘Is this real or is this not real?’” Garrett said. “Like, nobody’s ever seen this kid throw a baseball except for when he was younger. And now he just popped up out of nowhere?”
Yep. It was real.
Garrett did one more workout, then was selected by the Reds in the 22nd round of the 2011 Draft as he was preparing for his freshman year at St. John’s. He and the Reds negotiated his signing, which Garrett said reached $1 million and also allowed him to keep his St. John’s basketball commitment.
“I’m forever indebted to [the Reds],” Garrett said.
Garrett played his freshman and sophomore seasons with the Red Storm. He appeared in 54 total games and averaged 6.3 points in his career. Meanwhile, he spent brief portions of his summers in the Minor Leagues early on before eventually focusing on baseball, earning his debut in 2017.
“I tell people all the time, the route I took, it’s not a route that should have led to success,” Garrett said. “God gifted me. Like with anything, it’s a lot of luck, timing, word of mouth and stuff like that.”
Garrett dove more into his journey to MLB, as well as some of the most iconic moments of his career, alongside Rollins and Howard in the full podcast episode.
You can tune into the 6-1-1 Podcast on MLB.com, MLB.TV, all podcast platforms and YouTube.
