TORONTO -- The early weeks of each offseason tend to follow the same script, and this November, we’re flipping through those pages quickly.
Once the buzz of free agency wears off, the trade market always represents the next level of excitement in the MLB offseason. November is a time for dreaming, whether you’re a fan of a contender looking to repeat or a disappointment -- like the Blue Jays -- trying to climb that mountain again.
Coming off a weekend in which trade speculation dominated the discourse for Blue Jays fans, some notes on the market:
Nothing new … yet … on Ketel Marte
The Blue Jays will remain linked to Ketel Marte until his situation with the D-backs is settled, one way or another. Nothing has changed in recent days, though. The Blue Jays are interested, and very much should be interested in a player of Marte’s caliber, but they’re not about to overextend themselves at the current ask.
Our D-backs reporter, Steve Gilbert, reported the same over the weekend, adding there’s “nothing new” regarding Marte. The initial conversations are certainly happening, including with one of the Blue Jays’ AL East rivals in the Orioles. Our Jake Rill reported over the weekend that the Orioles have held dialogue with the D-backs.
Still, it’s easy to see why the Blue Jays continue to be linked to Marte, and why that interest stretches back to last offseason.
Marte, now 33, is one of the game’s top offensive talents at second base, widely underrated even after 12 excellent seasons in Arizona. He’s coming off a messy season, though, including the headlines when he failed to show up for a game in Boston, then was eventually placed on the restricted list and IL. When he was on the field, it was a down year, as he posted a .249 average with 22 homers and a .748 OPS over 141 games.
Unfortunately, that “down year” still would have made Marte one of the Blue Jays’ top hitters. Over the three seasons before 2026, Marte hit .283 with an .887 OPS, averaging 30 home runs per year. If the Blue Jays and other suitors believe there’s still some of that left for Marte’s mid-30s, he is clearly one of the most attractive players available, a talent who could completely change a lineup.
One complicating factor is Marte’s contract, which still has four seasons remaining and a player option for 2031. It’s a complex deal with $89.25 million in guaranteed money remaining. He also holds 10-and-5 rights, meaning he’d need to approve any trade. That financial commitment would factor into the package the D-backs demand, but if the Blue Jays need any help getting Marte to accept a trade to Toronto, they can lean on Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Marte is married to Guerrero’s cousin.
Other options and assets
The trade market will have some other headliners, including Corey Seager from the Rangers, but the Blue Jays aren’t expected to be big players in that market. There are also younger options still under club control, like Dylan Crews of the Nationals. However, the Blue Jays would be wise to explore free agency first. They remain a perfect fit for Seiya Suzuki, who’s one of the top players available and expected to land a deal worth north of $20 million per season.
The Blue Jays’ front office is still wrongly tagged as conservative. Over and over again, this front office has dealt top-ranked prospects and former No. 1 picks, and more often than not, they’ve nailed those moves. Prospect capital will not be an issue and the Blue Jays can shop in any market.
Don’t forget their big league options, either. Depth players like Charles McAdoo or Sean Keys could represent a “right now” piece if the Blue Jays are dealing with a rebuilder, while Brandon Valenzuela is an attractive name across the league right now … but it would take a lot for the Blue Jays to move him.
The truth
Rarely do the Blue Jays make the obvious move on the trade market. We need to acknowledge that out loud.
There are plenty of recent examples, like the Louis Varland deal, which came completely out of left field, but they have worked very well.
A more useful example here -- given that the Blue Jays may be shopping for an infielder -- is the Andrés Giménez trade two years ago. That was not a hot name on X and not an aggregation darling. As fun as it is to predict the offseason, the Blue Jays have repeatedly surprised us on the trade market, so the safest bet of all might be the mystery box.
