Commissioner Manfred ‘can’t imagine’ owners ratifying a deal without salary cap and floor

14 minutes ago

As the calendar moves closer to the Dec. 1 expiration of the Collective Bargaining Agreement, Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred left no ambiguity regarding the owners’ stance on their negotiations with the MLB Players Association.

“The owners want a deal with a salary cap and floor,” Manfred said in a press conference following the owners meetings at the league office. “I know there’s a lot of rhetoric out there that characterizes this as not serious or whatever. It's serious.”

Manfred said the 30 clubs “are 100% unanimous in support of the proposals that have been made,” adding that he “can't imagine the owners ratifying a deal that does not include a cap and floor.”

“There's plenty of room for compromise, but there's one thing that I will not compromise, and that's the issue that we're hearing from the vast majority of our fans,” Manfred said. “They want a salary cap and floor, and on that we will not compromise. We are not prepared to tell 70% of our fans that they're wrong on this issue. Competitive balance is a serious problem, and it needs to be addressed. And it's one that we can't avoid just because the negotiation can be difficult.”

MLBPA interim executive director Bruce Meyer responded to Manfred’s comments in a statement released by the union. 

“There can be no clearer example of the league’s lack of seriousness than their insistence that they will not negotiate over the economics outside of a radical change to the system that would dramatically reduce overall player compensation for all categories of players and strip fundamental rights from players like the ability to have truly guaranteed contracts,” Meyer said.

“There should be no illusions about the owners’ true motivation in pushing for this system. They want to make more money in profits and franchise values by artificially suppressing player salaries.”

The MLBPA has repeatedly referred to the league’s proposals as “not serious,” given the attachment of all provisions to a cap and floor system. The league has noted multiple times that they have accepted a number of the MLBPA’s proposals throughout the process, but the union has refused to even engage in conversation about the core economic system being proposed by MLB.

“The clubs have made proposals – all admittedly within a cap and floor framework – that meaningfully address the concerns that the MLBPA brought to the table; we offered a big increase in the minimum, we offered an increase in the pre-arbitration bonus pool, and for the first time since the ‘70s, we agreed to the union's proposal on free agency,” Manfred said. “This is a classic collective bargaining effort to address the other party's concerns while preserving your own. What has the MLBPA done? They've engaged in a lot of rhetoric. 

“They've characterized our proposals as not real or not serious. They've criticized and mischaracterized aspects of the cap and floor system in an effort to promote player opposition. What the MLBPA has not done is made any meaningful effort to move towards us. In fact, they have not made a significant economic proposal since their opening proposal. Indeed, there's a paucity of responses even on topics that do not directly impact our economics.”

Some have pointed to last month’s small-market World Series matchup between the Brewers and Rays as a sign that competitive balance is not a problem in baseball, but Milwaukee became the first small-market club to win a championship since the 2015 Royals. Between the NFL, NBA and NHL, 16 small-market teams had been crowned champs between the Royals and Brewers’ triumphs.

“This should not be a once-in-a-decade phenomenon for us,” Manfred said. “All of baseball would benefit from the opportunity to have this occur more regularly, like it does in other sports.”

Despite the possibility of a lockout, Manfred said it is his “overriding objective to make an agreement and to play an uninterrupted 162-game schedule,” something that was achieved five years ago during the last CBA negotiations. That deal was struck on March 10, allowing for a complete schedule to be played following some minor tweaks. 

Manfred suggested that while some believe this negotiation will be different due to the league’s desire for a cap and floor system, that is “not the real culprit here,” pointing to the deal that was struck in 2022 and how Meyer – the MLBPA’s current interim executive director – has characterized the most recent CBA. 

“In the last round of bargaining, we never proposed a cap and floor, and yet we came within inches of losing games,” Manfred said. “That entire negotiation took place within the context of the current existing system, and the MLBPA has proudly proclaimed publicly that they achieved important concessions from the clubs in that round of bargaining.

“Bruce Meyer recently described the details of the last negotiation in a public setting. He described three sequentially improved proposals from ownership in a very short period of time in a last-ditch effort to avoid losing games, and he said that those proposals added half a billion dollars of value to the table. According to Bruce, even with all of those concessions, there was a portion of the MLBPA leadership that was prepared to lose games in order to get more, and that he was sympathetic to that portion of the leadership. 

“The problem the last time, and a big part of the problem now, is that the MLBPA wants more, and its proposals further undermine the competitive quality of our game.”

This is the first negotiation for the MLBPA being led by Meyer, who was a deputy to former executive director Tony Clark during the bargaining in 2021-22. Manfred pointed out that he has negotiated successful CBA deals with former union heads Don Fehr, Michael Weiner and Clark.

“My approach in bargaining has always been: you have to take what the other side brings to the table as serious,” Manfred said. “I missed the chapter on collective bargaining where you could make proposals go away by saying over and over again the other side isn't serious. That's not a productive part of the process.”

The league’s most recent proposal included a $258.2 million salary cap and a floor of $180.2 million, a system that would not be implemented until the 2028 season. 

Based on end-of-season payrolls from 2026, 12 clubs (Marlins, Guardians, Cardinals, Rays, Nationals, White Sox, Twins, Rockies, Pirates, Athletics, Reds and Brewers) would be required to increase payroll by a combined $636 million to meet the floor, while eight clubs (Dodgers, Mets, Yankees, Phillies, Blue Jays, Padres, Red Sox and Cubs) would be required to reduce their payroll by a combined $528 million to meet the cap. 

Among the other proposals that MLB has made in recent months – many of which the MLBPA proposed in the first place – are earlier access to free agency for players at least 30 years old with five years of service time, the elimination of the qualifying offer system, increases to both minimum salaries and the pre-arbitration bonus pool, rules changes to reduce roster churn and Rule 5 Draft changes to help players reach the Majors quicker. 

“We have offered the type of cap and floor proposal that our fans have asked for,” Manfred said. “It promotes competitive balance and guarantees the players 50% of revenue, ending a two-decade decline in the percentage of revenue being devoted to player compensation. We've offered to dramatically raise the minimum salary, which is the amount earned by more than half our players. We have also proposed earlier free agency. In every other negotiation since 1976, free agency has been a sacred cow; the owners have been unable to entertain earlier free agency because it's anti-competitive for our small and mid markets in the current system. For the first time since ‘76, earlier free agency is a right that today's players can attain.

“Our proposal would allow MLB to finally join the other major North American sports in a cap and floor system, and I feel confident in predicting that the proposal will free our players from a system that has produced salary growth slower than the NBA, the NHL and the NFL.”

Since 2003, revenues have grown $9.2 billion, but player salaries have grown at a rate of only 35% during that period. The league’s proposal includes a 50-50 split of all revenues. 

“All this debate about is it 50? Is it 51? What should it be? I'm happy to have that debate,” Manfred said. “But the fact of the matter is that the system, as it exists today, has not treated our players as well as the systems in the other sports.”

The MLBPA made its initial proposal back in May, proposing a change in the reserve system from six years to five for players 30 and older, the elimination of the qualifying offer system, an increase in the minimum salary, an increase in the Competitive Balance Tax threshold and a competitive integrity tax among other items.

The league has accepted some of the MLBPA’s proposals, albeit only in a cap and floor system. 

“The proposals that they make actually exacerbate our competitive problems,” Manfred said. “The union keeps pushing taxes, penalties and bonuses, even though those tools have objectively failed to level the playing field in the past – and we've been at those tools for more than two decades.”

The decision on whether to have a lockout “is one that we’re going to make at the last possible moment,” Manfred said. With the CBA set to expire in less than two weeks, it remains to be seen how many more bargaining sessions will take place between the two sides. 

“So what's next? I know what's next for us; in the sessions leading up to expiration, we'll continue to address the priorities reflected in the MLBPA's proposals, and equally important, we stand ready to modify the cap and floor system to address their criticisms,” Manfred said. “Those are the two paths by which you move to the middle in a negotiation. We will remain committed to the bargaining process in an effort to reach an agreement that's good for our fans and fair to the players.”

“I think it's time that the MLBPA needs to realize that this proposal is serious. I’m not suggesting they need to accept it whole-cloth; I think they need to look at the proposal and try to find some ways to move to the middle, as opposed to making no proposal at all.”