Tigers ink Pagán to 1-year deal to bolster back end of 'pen

9 minutes ago

DETROIT – Tigers president of baseball operations Scott Harris got a Halloween treat when veteran closer declined his $10 million option with the Reds and became a free agent. Harris had valued Pagán in the past, including last offseason before Pagán re-signed with Cincinnati.

“As soon as he opted out, I picked up the phone and called his agent immediately,” Harris said.

With Pagán back on the market, the Tigers didn’t want to miss again. Baseball’s GM Meetings, usually where front offices lay the groundwork for offseason deals, had barely started when Detroit reached an agreement with Pagán on a one-year, $11.5 million contract.

The deal became official on Tuesday. It includes an additional $1 million in performance bonuses: Pagán can earn $200,000 each for 35, 40, 45, 50 and 55 games finished, a further bump for a pitcher who made $10 million as the Reds’ closer this past season.

“We're excited to add Emilio because he does a lot of things that we value,” Harris said on a Tuesday afternoon call with reporters. “He pounds the zone, he misses bats, he gets righties out, he gets lefties out. He has two different secondary [pitches] that miss bats, and both complement his fastball really well. He also gets a ton of popups year over year, and at this level, popups are the same as strikeouts because they take the ball out of play. 

“So he's the type of arm that we want to add to the back end of our ‘pen, and we feel like he's going to make us better in a number of ways. It's a guy that we've been after for a number of years now.”

Whether he’s the Tigers’ closer next season is up to manager A.J. Hinch, Harris said, but he gives Detroit a very good option as a replacement for Kenley Jansen in a market that’s thin on reliable options – and got thinner Tuesday with David Bednar’s decision to accept a qualifying offer from the Yankees.

The Tigers were an unlikely fit for Bednar. Signing him would’ve required Detroit to give up a Draft pick as compensation, a heavy price for an organization that prides itself on building through the farm system. Still, Bednar’s return to New York means one less closer on the market for teams to pursue, giving the Tigers extra reason to be thankful for having already added one as they look for more relief help.

“Whether we're going to be able to [add], I can't tell you confidently right now,” Harris said. “But as soon as I get off this call, I'm gonna be hard at work trying to find ways to get better in the next couple of weeks, and we'll see what happens for the rest of the winter.”

Pagán has been a closer for just three of his 10 Major League seasons, including the last two years in Cincinnati, but he has been effective in the role. The right-hander has saved 57 games in 66 opportunities over the last two years. He was dominant in 2025, including a 2.88 ERA, just 41 hits allowed over 68 2/3 innings and 81 strikeouts.

His numbers weren’t quite as dominant in an injury-shortened 2026 campaign. But after missing two months with a left hamstring strain, he returned in July and looked like his previous self the rest of the way: 19-for-19 in save chances, a 1.88 ERA, .186 batting average against and a 34-to-5 strikeout-to-walk ratio over 28 2/3 innings. His fastball velocity averaged 95 miles per hour, while his splitter became a nasty swing-and-miss pitch again in tandem with his cutter.

“He's capable of getting outs in high-leverage spots,” Harris said. “We know he's going to throw strikes, we know he's going to miss bats, we know he's going to be a really tough matchup against righties and lefties. That's the blueprint for a really good closer at this level, and if A.J. decides to use him that way, that's how we're going to use him.”