These 7 free-agent reunions would make perfect sense

15 minutes ago

One of the most exciting parts of free agency is imagining all these players in new uniforms. Sure, by now you’re used to seeing Juan Soto in a Mets jersey, but remember that initial shock? Or Albert Pujols in an Angels jersey? Heck, Shohei Ohtani in a Dodgers jersey? It’s sort of a Photoshop Hot Stove: Getting that guy on this team is a big part of the fantasy baseball fun.

But you know what else is fun? Reunions. The arc of a baseball career is long enough that it can mean something profound, even lasting, to see a guy who had left a team he starred for return to it years later -- and finding that the uniform fits perfectly. The canonical example of the last few years is Andrew McCutchen. It felt odd that he ever left the Pirates in the first place, and thus it only felt right when he returned. Also, it didn’t really work out, but it sure was great seeing Justin Verlander back in a Tigers jersey last year, wasn’t it?

So, in the spirit of Cutch, here’s a look at seven free agents and potential fits for them back with former teams.

David Bednar, RP, Pirates

Bednar didn’t just grow up a Pirates fan, when he returned to Pittsburgh for the first time after being traded to the Yankees in 2025, the team made sure they had his favorite local beer ready for him. Does that sound like someone who has moved on from Pittsburgh?

Bednar is one of the top free-agent relievers on the market, after a season in which he had 35 saves and was terrific during the postseason. That could, theoretically, put him out of the Pirates’ price range.

But this was a better-than-you-realized Pirates team in 2026, one that nonetheless could use some bullpen help after finishing 15th in relief ERA (4.06) and tying for the 12th-most blown saves (25) in the Majors. Nobody would fix that better than the local kid. After all, his favorite beer will always be nearby.

Jack Flaherty, SP, Cardinals

Flaherty had an excellent first half with the Tigers in 2024, which allowed him to be traded to the Dodgers, with whom he won a World Series ring. But other than that first half, he has struggled to replicate the success he had with the team he came up with, the Cardinals. Flaherty’s best season came in St. Louis in 2019, when he had a 2.75 ERA over 33 starts and led the National League with a 0.97 WHIP, ultimately finishing fourth in NL Cy Young Award voting. He hasn’t gotten a Cy Young vote since.

Flaherty is obviously a different pitcher than he was seven years ago, but he’s only 31 and he still misses bats, helping him post a 75th-percentile strikeout rate in 2026 (26 percent). After a rough couple of years back in Detroit (4.58 ERA across 2025-26), he could use a good season to rebuild his value. A reunion could make him the Cardinals’ 2027 version of Dustin May, who signed a one-year deal last offseason, enjoyed perhaps the best stretch of his career, then fetched them a good haul from the Brewers at the Trade Deadline.

Kevin Gausman, SP, Orioles

There were few young pitching prospects Orioles fans were more excited about than Gausman. Baltimore took him No. 4 overall in the 2012 Draft out of LSU, and he rated among MLB Pipeline’s top 40 prospects going into both the 2013 and ’14 seasons.

However, it never quite worked out as expected for Gausman with his original team. In 150 games (127 starts) for the Orioles across parts of six seasons, he had a 4.22 ERA (100 ERA+).

He didn’t become Kevin Gausman until a half-decade after he left Baltimore, finishing in the top 10 in Cy Young voting three straight seasons from 2021-23 and making two All-Star teams.

The Orioles could use another arm in the rotation, and while Gausman is no longer at his peak, he’d still be an extremely helpful addition, one that would bring his career full circle.

Lucas Giolito, SP, White Sox

In 2026, the White Sox returned to the playoffs for the first time since 2021, and what better way to connect that era of contention and the current one than by bringing back the ace of that ’21 team?

Frankly, Giolito’s career hasn’t been the same since that season, when he received AL Cy Young Award votes for the third year in a row. And things really took a turn after Chicago traded him to the Angels at the 2023 Deadline. In seven years with the Sox, Giolito made 162 starts; in the five years after, for five different teams, he has made only 47. Injuries have ravaged him, and did so again in 2026, but he was good for the Red Sox as recently as 2025 (3.41 ERA in 26 starts).

The White Sox obviously need some starting pitching to support their good, young lineup. Giolito returning could be a feel-good story for everyone.

Nick Martinez, SP, Padres

Martinez actually started his career with the Rangers before heading to Japan from 2018-21. The Padres then brought him back to MLB, and he had a successful two-season stint in San Diego as a swingman, posting a 3.45 ERA in 110 games (19 starts).

This season with the Rays, Martinez made himself into an All-Star, in large part because he slashed his walk rate to 3.6 percent, the lowest among qualified pitchers. That’s well under half of what it was with the Padres (8.9 percent).

Martinez is 36 now, and it’s quite possible 2026 was his peak. But the Padres’ rotation is full of holes right now, and Martinez could fill one of those … perhaps even better than he did last time.

Joc Pederson, DH, Braves

The pearls! Bring back the pearls! The tastefully adorned Pederson was a hero for the 2021 World Series champion Braves, who acquired him from the Cubs that July, and it’s possible he’ll be forever identified with the team despite only playing 64 games for them in his career.

A return could make some real sense for a team that could use a little bit more punch in the lineup, especially if the Braves choose not to bring back Jurickson Profar following his second suspension for a banned performance-enhancing substance. Pederson is a platoon bat, but he had an .834 OPS against right-handed pitching in 2026, and he could bring back all sorts of happy October memories for Atlanta.

Robbie Ray, SP, Diamondbacks

Remember when Robbie Ray won a Cy Young Award? He did! That was back in 2021 with the Blue Jays, when, not coincidentally, he posted the lowest walk rate of his career (6.7 percent). That rate has shot back up in the years since -- even though he did make an All-Star Game in 2025 with the Giants -- climbing all the way to a scary 12 percent last season. When paired with a 19.9 percent strikeout rate, that’s not great.

But Arizona could be a good destination for Ray to perhaps get his career back on track as he reaches his mid-30s. The Diamondbacks certainly could use the rotation depth, especially with Corbin Burnes being a major question mark. Ray’s first stint in the desert was somewhat up and down, but he was an All-Star there in 2017. His 147 starts as for Arizona are still by far his most for any team.