Look back at every No. 1 overall pick in history

List of former top picks shows the inexact science of drafting

June 3rd, 2019

With great power comes great responsibility, and that old adage holds true in the Major League Baseball Amateur Draft.

A team has the pick of thousands of talented high school and collegiate ballplayers when it holds the No. 1 overall pick in the Draft, and the player it eventually chooses could have long-lasting consequences - for better or worse. History shows drafting in baseball is an extremely inexact science, and one doesn't need to look any further for proof than the list of players chosen with the top overall pick. Some of them went on to change the courses of history for both their clubs and the Major Leagues as a whole. Others, sadly, never fulfilled the potential accompanying their lofty statuses thanks to unforeseen circumstances.

Here's a look at all the No. 1 overall picks in history dating back to the event's first installment in 1965.

2019: Adley Rutschman, Orioles
School: Oregon State
Career WAR: N/A
As was widely anticipated, the Orioles took Rutschman first overall. He became the first catcher to be taken first overall since Joe Mauer in 2001. It's just the second time the Orioles have had the first overall pick -- they took Ben McDonald first overall in 1989.

2018: Casey Mize, Tigers
School: Auburn
Career WAR: N/A
As many expected, Mize went first overall to the Tigers and he joined 2009 top pick as players to go from undrafted out of high school to the top overall pick in college. Mize has already twirled a no-hitter in the Minors and appears to be on the fast track to the Major Leagues.

2017: Royce Lewis, Twins
School: JSerra Catholic HS (San Juan Capistrano, Calif.)
Career WAR: N/A

Lewis was a surprise No. 1 pick to some talent evaluators, but he was the top-rated high school prospect in the 2017 Draft thanks to his premier athleticism both at the plate and at the shortstop position.

2016: Mickey Moniak, Phillies
School: La Costa Canyon HS (Carlsbad, CA)
Career WAR: N/A

Moniak cited the great Mickey Mantle as his favorite baseball player, but for his talents on the field much more so than the common name. The Phillies believed they found their next great outfielder when they used their No. 1 pick on Moniak, who slugged .921 in his senior season at La Costa Canyon. Silver Slugger and Gold Glove Award winner was Moniak's most frequently cited comp at the time of the '17 Draft.

2015: , D-backs
School: Vanderbilt University
Career WAR (entering 2019): 2.8
Swanson had an unforgettable Draft day, hitting a homer in the NCAA Super Regional final for the Commodores and then watching the D-backs select him with the No. 1 overall pick. Arizona traded Swanson that winter alongside pitcher and center fielder in exchange for hard-throwing righty , who would eventually need Tommy John surgery after tearing his ulnar collateral ligament. Swanson enjoyed a strong cup of coffee with the Braves in 2016 but struggled in his first full season the following year. The shortstop is putting things together in '19 and still has plenty of time to meet the lofty expectations bestowed him by the Atlanta faithful.

2014: Brady Aiken, Astros
School: Cathedral Catholic HS (San Diego, Calif.)
Career WAR: N/A
At age 17, the southpaw Aiken drew comparisons to and Andy Pettitte. Standing 6-foot-4, Aiken appeared to have the whole package as the Astros continued to rebuild with their third consecutive No. 1 overall pick. Health issues and a disagreement over Aiken's signing bonus precluded him from signing with Houston before the July 18 deadline, however, making him the first No. 1 pick not to sign since Tim Belcher in 1983. Aiken re-entered the Draft in 2015 but underwent Tommy John surgery before the Indians selected him with the No. 17 overall pick.

2013: , Astros
School: Stanford University
Career WAR: N/A
The Pirates selected Appel with the eighth pick of the 2012 Draft, but the right-hander opted to return to Stanford for his senior season instead of signing with Pittsburgh. Houston took Appel No. 1 overall in '13, but the righty was unable to rise through the ranks and the Astros traded him to the Phillies in a deal involving back-end reliever . Elbow and shoulder injuries followed for Appel, who eventually announced in February 2018 that he was stepping away from baseball.

2012: , Astros
School: Puerto Rico Baseball Academy
Career WAR (entering 2019): 18.1

The only one of the Astros' three consecutive No. 1 picks to even appear in a Major League game, Correa emanated star potential from the get-go. The hulking shortstop captured the American League Rookie of the Year Award at age 20, helped Puerto Rico reach the final of the 2017 World Baseball Classic and helped lead the Astros to their first-ever World Series title later that fall.

2011: , Pirates
School: UCLA
Career WAR (entering 2019): 16.5

Originally drafted by the Yankees in the first round of the 2008 Draft, Cole chose UCLA instead and developed his high-velocity arsenal to convince the Pirates to take him first overall three years later. As a rookie in 2013, Cole helped the moribund Pirates achieve their first winning season and secure their postseason berth in 20 years. He led them to the Wild Card Game as staff ace again in '15 before Pittsburgh traded him to Houston in January 2018 for pitchers and Joe Musgrove and position players and . He's risen to another level in the Lone Star State, earning his second All-Star nod and placing fifth in the AL Cy Young Award vote while leading MLB starters with 12.4 strikeouts per nine innings in 2018.

2010: , Nationals
School: Southern Nevada College
Career WAR (entering 2018): 27.4

Harper was on the cover of Sports Illustrated in 2009 at the age of 16, and he is one phenom who lived up to the hype. He won the NL Rookie of the Year in 2012 at the age of 19, and was named the unanimous NL MVP in 2015 when he hit a league-leading 42 homers. Harper began the next chapter of his career when he inked a record-setting 13-year, $330 million free-agent deal with the Phillies before the '19 campaign.

2009: , Nationals
School: San Diego State University
Career WAR (entering 2019): 26.3

Among the most closely-watched pitching prospects in baseball history, Strasburg and his electric arsenal made him a no-brainer No. 1 pick for Washington. Strasburg signed for a record $15.1 million, then quickly rose through the ranks and delivered one of the most memorable debuts in history: A 14-strikeout performance against the Pirates in front of a raucous crowd at Nationals Park. Strasburg paced the NL with 242 strikeouts in 2014 and memorably struck out 22 batters over two starts against the Cubs in the 2017 NLDS.

2008: Tim Beckham, Rays
School: Griffin (Ga.) HS
Career WAR (entering 2019): 5.1
Designated as a legitimate five-tool player out of high school, Beckham overcame two violations of the league's Joint Drug Prevention and Treatment Program and a subsequent 50-game suspension to serve as a utilityman for Tampa Bay in 2015 and '16. The Rays traded Beckham to the Orioles at the 2017 non-waiver Trade Deadline, after which Beckham proceeded to record 50 hits in August -- second only to Cal Ripken Jr. (53) for the most hits by an Oriole in a single calendar month. Beckham signed a free-agent deal with the Mariners before the '19 season.

2007: , Rays
School: Vanderbilt University
Career WAR (entering 2018): 38.2

Price found himself on Tampa Bay's roster just a year after the Draft, and he made an immediate impact by earning the save in Game 7 of the 2008 ALCS against the Red Sox to spur the Rays to their first World Series appearance. From there, Price developed into the Rays' ace. The southpaw started the 2010 All-Star Game for the AL and captured his first Cy Young Award in '12 after leading the Junior Circuit with 20 wins and a 2.56 ERA. Price went on to help the Tigers, Blue Jays and Red Sox to postseason appearances as one of the most accomplished starters in baseball, and claimed his first World Series ring with some clutch October outings for Boston in 2018.

2006: , Royals
School: University of Tennessee
Career WAR (entering 2019): 3.5

Hochevar didn't truly gain attention until he struck out 154 batters and recorded a 2.26 ERA while going 15-3 for Tennessee in his junior year, plenty good enough to earn SEC Pitcher of the Year Honors as well as the Roger Clemens Award given to the nation's top NCAA Division I pitcher. Hochevar struggled with consistency as a starter at the big league level and ultimately had to undergo Tommy John surgery in 2014, but he eventually returned as a valuable setup man for the resurgent Royals. In 2015, Hochevar went into the history books as the winning pitcher in Kansas City's decisive Game 5 victory over the Mets in the World Series.

2005: , D-backs
School: Great Bridge HS (Chesapeake, Va.)
Career WAR (entering 2018): 35.1

Drafted as a shortstop out of high school, Upton's head-turning power was clear from the start. Upton moved to the outfield as a professional and helped lead Arizona to a surprise three-game sweep of the Cubs in the 2007 NLDS. He earned the first of four All-Star Game selections in 2009 before going on to hit at least 25 home runs in a season for the D-backs, Braves, Padres, Tigers and Angels.

2004: Matt Bush, Padres
School: Mission Bay HS (San Diego, Calif.)
Career WAR (entering 2019): 2.6
Originally drafted as a shortstop, Bush encountered a long and winding road to the Majors. Bush was suspended before his first professional at-bat after he was involved in an altercation, and a series of off-field incidents followed as both the Padres and Blue Jays traded him and then the Rays released him following the 2012 season. Bush was converted to a pitcher along the way, and his high-90s fastball eventually earned him a callup with the Rangers in May 2016.

2003: Delmon Young, Rays
School: Adolfo Camarillo (Calif.) HS
Career WAR: 2.4
The younger brother of two-time All-Star Dmitri Young, Delmon was highly-touted and the hype swelled after he was named Baseball America's 2005 Minor League Player of the Year. Young finished second to Red Sox second baseman in the 2007 AL Rookie of the Year vote before the Rays traded him to the Twins in a deal involving pitcher Matt Garza and shortstop Jason Bartlett. He hit 21 home runs and drove in 112 runs while finishing 10th in AL MVP voting with Minnesota in 2010 before helping the Tigers and Orioles to ALCS appearances.

2002: Bryan Bullington, Pirates
School: Ball State University
Career WAR: -0.3
Bullington captured attention after going 15-0 during his senior year of high school before earning first-team All-American honors at Ball State. Bullington made his Pirates debut in Sept. 2006 before undergoing surgery for a torn labrum on his pitching shoulder. Pittsburgh designated Bullington for assignment in 2008 and he went on to make 20 combined Major League appearances for the Indians, Blue Jays and Royals before going on to find success in Japan's Nippon Professional Baseball League.

2001: Joe Mauer, Twins
School: Cretin HS (St. Paul, Minn.)
Career WAR: 55.0

As local a hero as it gets in modern baseball, the Twins drafted this three-sport Minnesota high school star the top of the 2001 Draft and watched Mauer develop into one of the sweetest-swinging catchers in recent history. Mauer became the first backstop to claim the AL batting title in 2006 -- his first of three batting crowns -- and captured the '09 AL MVP after leading the Junior Circuit in average, OBP and slugging. Mauer helped lead the Twins to four AL Central division titles in a span of seven seasons from 2004-10, and collected his 2,000th career hit in 2018 before retiring at the end of the season. The Twins are set to retire Mauer's No. 7 in June.

2000: , Marlins
School: Eastlake HS (Chula Vista, Calif.)
Career WAR (entering 2019): 42.2

The first infielder to be taken first overall since Alex Rodriguez in 1993, Gonzalez was traded by the Marlins in June 2003 to the Rangers, who promptly dealt him to the Padres that offseason. It was in San Diego that the powerful Gonzalez became a franchise icon, etching his name into the top-five of several of the Padres' all-time offensive lists before he was traded to the Red Sox in Dec. 2010. Gonzalez was an All-Star again for Boston in 2011 before moving on to the Dodgers via a mega-deal in Aug. 2012. He paced the NL with 116 RBIs for Los Angeles in 2014 and helped lead the Dodgers to five straight NL West titles from 2013-17.

1999: Josh Hamilton, Rays
School: Athens Drive HS (Raleigh, N.C.)
Career WAR: 28.3

Hamilton was considered a can't-miss prospect with prodigious power before injuries and a drug addiction set his career on a roller-coaster path. The outfielder resurfaced with an excellent rookie season for the Reds in 2007, followed by a breathtaking stretch of power with the Rangers that included a legendary performance in the '08 Home Run Derby, the 2010 AL MVP and back-to-back World Series appearances in '10 and '11. Injuries again slowed Hamilton after he signed a 5-year, $125 million deal with the Angels in Dec. 2012.

1998: Pat Burrell, Phillies
University of Miami
Career WAR: 18.9

A Golden Spikes Award winner with the Hurricanes, Burrell placed fourth in the 2001 NL Rookie of the Year vote before belting a career-high 37 home runs in '02 for the Phillies. Burrell (33 homers) served as a main power source alongside and for the Philadelphia club that captured the '08 World Series title, and proved to be a valuable veteran piece on the Giants' world championship club two years later.

1997: Matt Anderson, Tigers
School: Rice University
Career WAR: -0.6
Anderson set numerous career records at Rice and owned a sub-1.00 ERA in the Minors before the Tigers called him up to be a reliever at age 21 in 1998. Anderson started strong as a rookie but could never find that form in subsequent years, finishing his big league career with a 5.19 ERA over 257 relief appearances for the Tigers and Rockies.

1996: Kris Benson, Pirates
School: Clemson University
Career WAR: 12.9
An undefeated junior season at Clemson earned Benson the top overall slot, and hopes were high in Pittsburgh after the righty placed fourth in NL Rookie of the Year voting in 1999 and followed up with an even better season in 2000. Benson unfortunately required Tommy John surgery immediately after that campaign, but rallied to record three more productive seasons for the Mets and Orioles between '04-'06.

1995: Darin Erstad, Angels
School: University of Nebraska
Career WAR: 32.4

Both a talented collegiate hitter and a starting punter for the football team at Nebraska, Erstad's athleticism translated to a highly productive 14-year career in the Major Leagues. Beloved by Angels fans, Erstad led the AL with 240 hits and batted .355 in 2000 while also becoming the first leadoff hitter in history to record 100 RBIs. Two years later, Erstad helped lead the Angels to their first World Series title with a key home run in Game 6 against the Giants. Erstad became the first player in MLB history to win a Gold Glove Award as both an outfielder and an infielder when he was honored at first base in '04.

1994: Paul Wilson, Mets
Florida State University
Career WAR: 2.0
Part of the Mets' hyped "Generation K" alongside Jason Isringhausen and Bill Pulsipher, Wilson never quite fulfilled expectations over parts of seven Major League seasons. Wilson's best season came in 2004 with the Reds, when the righty went 11-6 with a 4.36 ERA over 29 starts.

1993: Alex Rodriguez, Mariners
School: Westminster Christian HS (Miami, Fla.)
Career WAR: 117.8

Rodriguez ranks among the greatest players in MLB history, and also one of its most controversial following repeated use of performance-enhancing drugs. Coming of age as part of a new age of shortstops alongside Nomar Garciaparra and Derek Jeter, Rodriguez captured three AL MVP Awards and five league home run crowns, appeared in 14 All-Star Games and helped lead the Yankees to the 2009 World Series title. He resides in an exclusive group with Hank Aaron, Willie Mays and as players with both 3,000 hits and 600 home runs, finishing his career fourth on the all-time homer list with 696.

1992: Phil Nevin, Astros
School: California State University Fullerton
Career WAR: 15.9
Nevin was a bona-fide star at Cal State Fullerton, leading the Titans to the championship game of the 1992 College World Series and capturing the Golden Spikes Award as the nation's best collegiate player. Memorably drafted ahead of Jeter, Nevin eventually came into his own as a Major League third baseman, earning an All-Star Game selection with the Padres in 2001 when he hit .306 with 41 home runs and 126 RBIs. Nevin appeared in parts of 12 Major League seasons before transitioning to a coaching role with the Giants and Yankees.

1991: Brien Taylor, Yankees
School: East Carteret HS (Beaufort, N.C.)
Career WAR: N/A
Once called the "best high school pitcher I've seen in my life" by high-profile agent Scott Boras, Taylor signed with the Yankees for $1.55 million after New York selected him with the top pick. Billed as the game's top prospect by Baseball America in 1992, the southpaw injured his pitching shoulder in an off-field altercation and was never able to fully recover. Taylor retired in 2000 after seven seasons in the Minors, following Steve Chilcott as just the second No. 1 overall pick to never appear in the Majors.

1990: Chipper Jones, Braves
School: The Bolles HS (Jacksonville, Fla.)
Career WAR: 85.2

Jones, somewhat incredibly, was not Atlanta's first choice for the No. 1 overall selection; the team went with Jones after pitcher Todd Van Poppel stated publicly that he would not sign with Atlanta. All Jones did was become one of the most important players in franchise history, earning eight All-Star Game selections, the 1999 NL MVP and the 2008 NL batting title while establishing himself as one of the best third basemen in history. Jones retired in '12 as the only switch-hitter in MLB history to hit at least .300 while slugging at least 400 home runs, as well as the only switch-hitter with a career .300/.400/.500 slash line over at least 10,000 plate appearances. He was elected to the Hall of Fame on his first time on the ballot in 2018, garnering 97.2 percent of the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA) vote.

1989: Ben McDonald, Orioles
Louisiana State University
Career WAR: 20.8
A two-sport star at LSU, McDonald helped lead Team USA to a gold medal at the 1988 Olympics in Seoul before earning the Golden Spikes Award in '89. McDonald twirled a shutout against the White Sox in his first Major League start on July 21, 1990, and went on to record double-digit wins in four separate seasons for the Orioles and Brewers.

1988: Andy Benes, Padres
School: University of Evansville
Career WAR: 31.5
Benes hit the fast track after his top billing in the 1988 Draft, going 6-3 over 10 starts with the Padres in '89 to place fifth in the NL Rookie of the Year race. The righty earned his lone All-Star Game nod in '93 before leading the NL with 189 strikeouts the following year. Benes' most decorated season came in '96 when he went 18-10 for the Cardinals and finished third in Cy Young voting.

1987: Ken Griffey Jr., Mariners
School: Archbishop Mueller HS (Cincinnati, Ohio)
Career WAR: 83.8

Nicknamed "The Kid," Griffey made an immediate impact in center field for the Mariners, memorably hitting back-to-back homers with his dad in 1990 and recording 10 consecutive seasons with both a Gold Glove Award and All-Star Game selection from 1990-99. A generational talent with an unforgettable left-handed swing, Griffey dominated the sport with three consecutive seasons of 48-plus homers from 1997-99, including becoming the '97 AL MVP when he paced the Junior Circuit with 56 homers and 147 RBIs. Griffey was traded to his hometown Reds before the 2000 season and finished his career fifth on the all-time home runs list with 630. In 2016, Griffey earned a record 99.3 percent of the BBWAA vote to become the first No. 1 overall pick to eventually earn a plaque in the Hall of Fame.

1986: Jeff King, Pirates
School: University of Arkansas
Career WAR: 16.8
King proved a competent hitter over 11 Major League seasons, finishing his career with a .256 average and 154 home runs. King hit in the heart of the Pirates' order amid Pittsburgh's three consecutive NL East championship clubs from 1990-92. In '96, King joined Hall of Famers Andre Dawson and Willie McCovey as the only players in history to homer in the same inning on two separate occasions in their career.

1985: B.J. Surhoff, Brewers
School: University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
Career WAR: 34.4

A super-utility man who played everywhere on a Major League diamond except pitcher, Surhoff proved a valuable player on the roster over 19 seasons for the Brewers, Orioles and Braves. Surhoff's best season was probably 1999 with the Orioles, when he finished second in the AL with 207 hits and was named the team's most valuable player while also earning his lone All-Star nod. Surhoff retired in 2005 with 2,326 career hits, 1,153 RBIs and 440 doubles.

1984: Shawn Abner, Mets
School: Mechanicsburg (Pa.) Area HS
Career WAR: -1.3
The Mets were high on Abner when they took him first overall following the success of their other recent picks in Doc Gooden and Darryl Strawberry, but the Pennsylvania outfielder ultimately never played in a New York uniform. The Mets traded Abner after the 1986 season to the Padres, with whom he played in a part-time role for four and a half seasons. Abner made cameos with the Angels and White Sox before a knee injury he suffered in a pickup basketball game brought his career to a close.

1983: Tim Belcher, Twins
School: Mount Vernon Nazarene University
Career WAR: 26.0
Belcher's road to the Majors was anything but conventional -- he refused to sign with the Twins, was later taken by the Yankees in the supplemental draft, picked up by the A's and then traded to the Dodgers -- but he certainly looked the part once he got there. Belcher beat his former Oakland club in Game 4 of the 1988 World Series and paced the Majors with eight shutouts the following season. The right-hander wound up pitching for seven different clubs, winning 15 games in two different seasons.

1982: Shawon Dunston, Cubs
School: Thomas Jefferson HS (N.Y.)
Career WAR: 11.5
The Brooklyn native became the first No. 1 overall pick from the New York City area and represented himself when he signed a $100,000 contract with the Cubs in 1982. Dunston beat out Larry Bowa for the Cubs' starting shortstop job to begin the '85 season and eventually stuck as Ryne Sandberg's double-play partner for the '89 NL East division champions. Dunston made two All-Star Games with the Cubs before moving on to the Giants, Pirates, Indians, Cardinals and Mets over an 18-year career.

1981: Mike Moore, Mariners
School: Oral Roberts University
Career WAR: 27.9
Moore spent his first seven years with the Mariners but is known more for his four-year tenure with the A's from 1989-92. The righty won 19 games and earned his lone All-Star Game nod during his first year with Oakland in '89, also winning all three of his postseason starts including Games 2 and 4 of the World Series against the Giants. Moore finished his 14-year career with a 161-176 record and 4.39 ERA.

1980: Darryl Strawberry, Mets
School: Crenshaw HS (Los Angeles, Calf.)
Career WAR: 42.2

Strawberry ranked among baseball's most feared sluggers during his 1980s heyday with the Mets, beginning with his NL Rookie of the Year-winning season in 1983 when he clubbed 26 homers at age 21. Launching tape-measure blasts against hapless opposing pitchers, Strawberry helped to turn New York into World Series champions in '86 and earned eight consecutive All-Star Game selections from 1984-91. Strawberry was handed multiple suspensions for substance abuse off the field, but battled back to become a valuable veteran presence for three Yankees world championship clubs in 1996, '98 and '99.

1979: Al Chambers, Mariners
School: John Harris HS (Harrisburg, Pa.)
Career WAR: -0.5
The Mariners thought they might be getting the next Jim Rice when they drafted the 6-foot-4, 215-pound Chambers out of Harrisburg, with team scout Bill Kearns memorably stating "people will pay just to watch this guy take batting practice." But Chambers would play just 57 games for Seattle between 1983-85, batting .206 with two home runs before the Mariners released him in the spring of '86.

1978: Bob Horner, Braves
School: Arizona State University
Career WAR: 21.9

Horner won the 1977 College World Series MVP Award and became the first Sun Devil to capture the Golden Spikes Award in '78 before the Braves picked him at the top of the Draft. Horner would memorably appear in the Majors that same year, bypassing the Minors entirely and homering off future Hall of Famer Bert Blyleven in his MLB debut. Horner hit 23 total home runs that year to beat out Ozzie Smith for NL Rookie of the Year honors and would top 30 homers three times before injuries began to hamper his promising career. On July 6, 1986, Horner joined the select group of players to hit four homers in a single game.

1977: Harold Baines, White Sox
St. Michael's HS (Easton, Md.)
Career WAR: 38.7

Tracked by White Sox owner Bill Veeck since he was a Little Leaguer, Baines became one of the 1980s' best run producers as a first baseman and later designated hitter on the South Side. A career .289 hitter over 22 big league seasons, Baines hit at least 20 home runs in 12 different seasons and drove in at least 80 runs in 11. The six-time All-Star is a member of the National Baseball Hall of Fame's Class of 2019, and he's honored with both a statue at Chicago's U.S. Cellular Field and enshrinement in the Orioles Hall of Fame thank to seven excellent seasons in Baltimore.

1976: Floyd Bannister, Astros
Arizona State University
Career WAR: 26.3
Bannister made just seven Minor League appearances before opening the 1977 season on the Astros' big league roster. The southpaw pitched two years in Houston before he was traded to the Mariners, where he led the AL with 209 strikeouts and appeared in his only All-Star Game in '82. Bannister reached 16 victories twice over his 15-year career, finishing with a 4.06 lifetime ERA.

1971 and 1975: Danny Goodwin, Angels
School: Southern University and A&M
Career WAR: -1.7
Goodwin holds the distinction of being the only player to be chosen first overall in two separate drafts, turning down the White Sox's top pick in 1971 to attend Southern University before the Angels picked him first again in '75. The Halos fastracked the catcher for a 10-at-bat cameo, but Goodwin was unable to lock down a full-time job with the Angels, Twins and A's before he moved on to Japan's Nippon Professional Baseball (NBP) League in '86.

1974: Bill Almon, Padres
School: Brown University
Career WAR: 4.6
Almon spent just 39 games in the Minors before debuting in Sept. 1974 as the Padres' starting shortstop. The Ivy Leaguer suited up for seven different clubs over a 15-year career, finishing with a .254 average.

1973: David Clyde, Rangers
School: Westchester HS (Houston, Texas)
Career WAR: 0.6
This hard-throwing left-hander from Houston drew comparisons to Sandy Koufax, but his career took a more tragic turn. Cited by many as a pitcher who was mishandled and rushed to the Majors too quickly, Clyde developed shoulder problems and was out of baseball by the end of the decade.

1972: Dave Roberts, Padres
School: University of Oregon
Career WAR: 0.4
Roberts jetted straight from the Draft to the Majors in 1972, but struggled to hit competitively at the big league level. The infielder and backup catcher hit .239 over parts of 10 big league seasons with the Padres, Rangers, Astros and Phillies.

1970: Mike Ivie, Padres
School: Walker HS (Atlanta, Ga.)
Career WAR: 7.3
Ivie showed plenty of power in the Minors, at one point hitting 21 homers in a span of 21 games. The utility man eventually found a home in San Francisco, where he hit a memorable grand slam against the Dodgers amid a tight pennant race in 1978 and clubbed a career-high 27 homers the following year. Ivie was known league-wide for his batting practice power performances, but he was out of baseball by the end of '83.

1969: Jeff Burroughs, Senators
School: Woodrow Wilson HS (Long Beach, Calif.)
Career WAR: 17.8

Burroughs featured plenty of power at the plate, knocking at least 20 homers five times between 1973-78. The outfielder became the first Texas Ranger to capture AL MVP honors in '74 when he hit. 301, homered 25 times and drove in an AL-high 118 runs. Burroughs went on to knock a career-high 41 homers for the Braves in '77.

1968: Tim Foli, Mets
Notre Dame HS (Sherman Oaks, Calif.)
Career WAR: 5.6
Known most for his glove around the infield, Foli twice paced MLB shortstops in fielding percentage in 1980 and '82. The Mets dealt Foli to the Expos alongside Ken Singleton for Rusty Staub before the '72 campaign, and the utility man later became the first Montreal player to hit for the cycle in '76. Foli proved instrumental in the "We Are Family" Pirates' run to the '79 World Series title, collecting a hit in six of Pittsburgh's seven Fall Classic games.

1967: Ron Blomberg, Yankees
School: Druid Hills HS (Atlanta, Ga.)
Career WAR: 9.4
Blomberg will forever be known as baseball's first designated hitter after he drew a bases-loaded walk against Red Sox ace Luis Tiant on April 6, 1973. He proved plenty capable of the "hitter" moniker, finishing with a .293 average and a .360 on-base percentage over parts of eight Major League seasons with the Yankees and White Sox.

1966: Steven Chilcott, Mets
School: Antelope Valley HS (Lancaster, Calif.)
Career WAR: N/A
Chilcott's promising career was hampered by a season-ending shoulder dislocation in 1967, setting off a string of injuries that eventually ended his career at age 24. MLB's second No. 1 overall pick unfortunately became one of the few to never step foot on a Major League diamond. Future Hall of Fame slugger Reggie Jackson famously went second overall to the Kansas City A's.

1965: Rick Monday, A's
School: Arizona State
Career WAR: 33.1

The first pick in the first-ever Draft, Monday never became a superstar, but he made a pair of All-Star teams (1968 and 1978) and hit a go-ahead, ninth-inning home run in the decisive Game 5 of the 1981 against the Expos to send the Dodgers to the World Series. He is perhaps most famous for tackling two protesters who attempted to burn an American flag on the outfield grass of Dodger Stadium during a game on April 25, 1976.