First, the pitch hit the inner-middle of Benintendi's bat toward the handle, and then it drifted toward the end of the bat, before rolling into center for a hit.
"Yeah, I really didn't even know what was going on," said Benintendi. "I heard it, and I thought my bat hit the catcher's glove. I didn't know. But once I saw it, I knew it must have hit my bat twice."
Has Benintendi ever had a double-contact hit before?
"That's the first time that's happened to me," Benintendi said. "That's crazy."
Unfortunately for Benintendi, he only got credit for one hit in the boxscore.