So picture this: It's February 2026, and the Yankees have seen enough -- they want Ben Rice to be their first baseman.
But they developed Rice as a catcher. Which is why they have Paul Goldschmidt on hand to spell him -- he can start against lefties, but maybe more importantly, he's a great first baseman, and he has already spent time mentoring Rice, who will be much better acclimated and fully prepared to take over his new position in 2027 with the training wheels off.
You may have heard that the catcher-to-first transition isn't actually that simple. Rice is serviceable there, but he's a massive downgrade from Goldschmidt, defensively speaking. He needs reps, hence the setup. Then Aaron Judge gets hurt, suddenly the Yankees are way too left-handed, and now they really need Goldschmidt in the lineup. And if he's going to play, the optimal defensive alignment has him at first base. Rice has to DH. Not ideal, but fair enough.
Then the Yankees trade for Luis García Jr., historically a second baseman, now firmly planted at first base. They still need offense; it's hard to object. But García, also a lefty, is now Goldschmidt's platoon partner, and from there, Rice plays first base just two more times.
That brings us back to the present day. 2027 is a little over five weeks away, and the Yankees spent most of ‘26 not preparing Rice to play first base. This is a problem for many reasons. Aside from the fact that Goldschmidt is a free agent and they really shouldn't bring him back, Rice is delivering on all of their other expectations for him, which makes their sacrifice of his defensive skills look even worse. Meanwhile, García, a 26-year-old in his final year of club control who just had his first 30-homer season, also needs somewhere to play.
They can't both play first base. At least not simultaneously. You can't make a platoon of two lefties who should be playing every day, either. But they both need to play a position, for their own sakes and for the Yankees'. They're going to need somewhere to put guys like Giancarlo Stanton, who does not have a position, and Judge, whose health needs to be preserved at basically any cost. Having a healthy 20-something taking up the DH spot just isn't an option.
If the Yankees have figured this out internally, it's unclear. So let's just brainstorm some solutions for the García/Rice pileup.
Rice to 1B, García to 2B
If the Yankees elect to keep García -- more on the prospect of them not doing that in a second -- this is just what makes sense. García isn't the greatest defensive second baseman in the world, but he knows how to play the position, and he has had some perfectly adequate seasons there. This plan would also surely involve the Yankees drilling both of these players at his given position all through Spring Training, which would probably benefit everyone.
So this would work, and it is probably the most likely outcome. But if the Yankees are actually committed to turning over a new leaf, their infield defense can't be this questionable. Part of the argument for letting Jazz Chisholm Jr. walk is his inconsistency in the field, but when Chisholm has it all together, he's unbelievably dynamic. Replacing him with García, who does not have that upside, sounds more like a downgrade than anything else. With enough work, both he and Rice could become defensive wizards, but more likely, at least one of them is going to remain a minor liability in 2027 -- and that's your whole right side you're taking chances with.
Rice to C, García to 1B
This one almost certainly isn't happening, but in the spirit of being thorough, we do kind of have to touch on it. Rice ended up slotted in as a first baseman on New York's depth chart because that was the position he was promoted to fill in 2024, but he was originally a catcher, and it isn't as if Austin Wells is setting the world on fire. Wells’ defense won out over Rice's two years ago, but that was two years ago.
The problem with this is that Rice didn't catch at all in 2026. He has actually played there so little overall in the Majors -- just 37 times in 342 games -- that it seems safe to assume the Yankees were much higher on his makeup than his actual ability behind the plate.
Someone plays LF
We say "someone," but it's probably García. He has made a successful move before, his arm is a bit better and the Yankees have no long-term investment in him -- he won't factor into the conversation of who's covering first base two years from now, when it's just Rice left.
It's fun to talk about drastic position changes, but there's not much else to this. The Yankees have good coverage at their corner outfield spots, and outsourcing your logjam to another position solves nothing.
García gets traded
Does it seem like this town just isn't big enough for the both of them?
We'd offer the scenario in reverse as well, but it's almost impossible to see the Yankees parting with Rice. Not only are they less attached to García, but he has never been more desirable coming off the 30-homer season, and the power surge could well have been a one-time thing. 2027 will also be his final year of team control, so if the Yankees are going to move him, they kind of have to do it now.
