Gardner’s inclusion on HOF ballot reflective of legacy as an essential Yankee

9 minutes ago

’s name is on this year’s Baseball Writers’ Association of America ballot for the National Baseball Hall of Fame, appearing there for the first time. And it will likely be the only year it is on the ballot, as it is unlikely that Gardner will be named on enough ballots to be around in a year.

But it does not diminish his heart or grit or talent to state that he was never a Hall of Famer across a 14-year career, when his lifetime batting average was .256 and the most home runs he ever hit in a season was 28, and the most RBIs he ever had in one season were 74, and his highest single-season OPS was .829.

None of that will ever be enough for Gardner, one of the great gamers of his time in baseball, to make it to Cooperstown. He might never make it out to Monument Park, which the Yankees and their fans view as their own Hall of Fame.

Gardner, though, was something else in his time at Yankee Stadium, both the old one and the new one: He was an essential New York Yankee.

He is the Yankee who played all of his 1,688 regular-season games in pinstripes, and 68 more in the postseason before his retirement. He was the kind of dirty uniform the Yankees haven’t really had since he left, in the infield or in the outfield or maybe even in the Yankee clubhouse. In so many ways, he is the third-round Draft choice out of Charleston two decades ago whose distinctive presence still hasn’t been replaced.

There have been a lot of gamers and grinders like him for the Yankees across the years. There are other essential Yankees who never made it to Cooperstown even if some of them were honored with plaques in Monument Park the way Don Mattingly, Bernie Williams, Paul O’Neill, Willie Randolph, Tino Martinez and the late Thurman Munson have been just from the era that began when George Steinbrenner bought the team.

But there are other Yankees like Gardner from the past half-century, ones who honored the uniform the way Gardner did: Lou Piniella, Roy White and Scott Brosius to name a few. Again: Not Yankee immortals. Just champion Yankees who, at their best, made themselves seem like indispensable figures in Yankee history, and were embraced by Yankee fans.

Gardner was absolutely one of those, even as he chased a second World Series title to go with the one he and his teammates won in 2009 until the end of his career.

Gardner was nearing the end of his career as Aaron Judge was beginning his own, as they both made runs at the World Series in 2017 and '19, especially, getting knocked out by the Astros in both of those years. Judge always spoke so highly of Gardner, as a ballplayer and teammate and as a Yankee most of all. And he never forgot Gardner inviting him to stay at his home in Armonk when Judge needed to get away from the city.

No. 99 once said this about No. 11: “He was everything that you look for in a guy to lead the team.”

And also this: “[Gardner] poured everything into every single guy.”

And every single game. CC Sabathia once described Gardner as the “heart and soul” of the Yankee teams and the Yankee seasons that they shared.

“I take great pride in being a Yankee,” Gardner himself once said, “and trying to do things the right way.”

He always did. Never a star of the sport. Just someone who felt like a star Yankee, even if the highest batting average he ever had in the big leagues was .277, and the most bases he ever stole in a single season was 49 before he finally retired at the age of 37.

Here is something Gardner said to our Bryan Hoch one time: “The best compliment I feel a player can get is when fans say that they enjoy the way you’re playing the game.”

Of course there were other Yankees like this in the '50s and '60s, wonderful names out of the past like Bobby Richardson, Elston Howard, Bill Skowron, Hank Bauer, Tony Kubek and Tom Tresh. Older Yankee fans know that this is the short list of position players who played the game the way Gardner did, and exhibited old-Yankee values even when they were young the way Gardner did.

Gardner was just one of those players: He never made a lot of noise once the game was over. But his teammates sure knew he was in the room.

You know who had a bunch of guys like Gardner this season? The world champion Brewers did. Sal Frelick, the kid in right field, another undersized guy, plays the game the way Gardner always did.

So now Gardner is honored just by seeing his name on the writers’ ballot for the Hall of Fame.

“He was always there for us,” Judge once said. He always was. Guy doing the little things. They just seem bigger around the Yankees since he left.