Baseball's greatest player-team reunions

January 13th, 2023

It's always nice to see a franchise icon return home, and now appears to be doing just that.

McCutchen and the Pirates agreed to a one-year contract on Friday, per a source, sending the 36-year-old back to the club that drafted him 11th overall in 2005, brought him to the Majors in '09 and watched him develop into a five-time All-Star who won NL MVP honors while helping the Pirates snap a long postseason drought in '13. It was gutting for both sides when the Bucs traded McCutchen to the Giants in January '18, although the deal netted Pittsburgh an outfield prospect named Bryan Reynolds.

McCutchen now looks to be in the twilight of his career after spending time with the Giants, Yankees, Phillies and Brewers over the past five seasons. He returns to the Steel City ranked fourth in the franchise's long history in home runs (203, 37 behind Roberto Clemente) and needing just 13 big flies to reach the 300 mark while wearing black and yellow.

Of course, McCutchen is hardly the first to chart this course. Throughout MLB history, plenty of aging players have returned to the teams where they became stars, including Zack Greinke to the Royals and Albert Pujols to the Cardinals in 2022.

Note: These are players who returned to an old team for the final stage of their careers. Other players who had a homecoming but then went on to play for other teams aren't included here -- Rickey Henderson with the A's, Greg Maddux with the Cubs, Tim Raines with the Expos, Jim Thome with the Indians and Phillies, Tom Seaver with the Mets and so on.

Here are MLB's greatest player-team reunions.

, Cardinals 
First stint: 2001-11 | Returned: 2022 

After a decade away from St. Louis, Pujols put on the Cardinals uniform for one last ride alongside Adam Wainwright and Yadier Molina, reuniting the iconic trio that led the Cardinals to the 2006 World Series championship. In his first 11 years with the Cardinals, Pujols won two rings and three MVP Awards, and established himself as one of the greatest hitters to ever play.

Pujols' final season had plenty of memorable moments, too. He shone at the Home Run Derby, joined the All-Star Game along with fellow legend Miguel Cabrera, led the Cardinals to a division title, homered in his final regular-season at-bat at Busch Stadium, singled in his final career at-bat in the postseason -- and, of course, hit his milestone 700th home run, joining Barry Bonds, Hank Aaron and Babe Ruth as the only members of that exclusive club.

, Mariners
First stint: 2001-12 | Returned: 2018

Ichiro's career came to a close with an emotional two-game farewell with the Mariners in Japan to open the 2019 season. Seattle was fittingly the final stop for the future Hall of Famer, back where it all began.

Ichiro was a Mariners fan favorite from the start. He burst onto the Major League scene in 2001 by winning both the American League MVP and Rookie of the Year honors, and he became a franchise icon over the next decade, making 10 straight All-Star teams, winning 10 straight AL Gold Glove Awards and two batting titles and leading the Majors in hits seven times -- including setting the MLB single-season record with 262 in 2004. He was traded to the Yankees in 2012, but after six years away from Seattle, he returned in 2018.

, A's
First stint: 2000-06 | Returned: 2015

Zito was the 2002 AL Cy Young Award winner and a three-time All-Star in Oakland from 2000-06, and he helped lead the A's to five postseason appearances in his first seven big league seasons. The left-hander crossed the Bay to the Giants in a blockbuster free-agent signing in December 2006, but he never quite recaptured his Oakland dominance in San Francisco.

After seven years with the Giants -- and a year out of baseball in 2014 -- Zito returned to Oakland in '15 and made his final three big league appearances in September. That included a start against the Giants and former teammate Tim Hudson, in honor of the A's Big Three of the early 2000s -- Zito, Hudson and Mark Mulder, who was in attendance for the game.

, Mariners
First stint: 1989-99 | Returned: 2009-10

The Kid is both a Mariners and MLB legend, and his career came full circle with Seattle. With his iconic left-handed swing, Griffey slugged his way to four AL home run crowns and the 1997 AL MVP Award over his first 11 big league seasons with the Mariners.

After leaving for the Reds at the turn of the millennium, Griffey returned to the Mariners at the tail end of his career in 2009. In his first game back with Seattle in nearly a decade, Griffey homered. Just more than a week later, on April 15, he hit his 400th home run in a Mariners uniform. Griffey retired the next year, ending a 630-homer Hall of Fame career.

, Braves
First stint: 1987-2002 | Returned: 2008

Glavine, Greg Maddux and John Smoltz formed the nucleus of maybe the best starting rotation of all time, with the Hall of Fame trio leading the Braves teams that dominated the National League East from the 1990s through the early 2000s, when Atlanta won 14 straight division titles.

Glavine spent his first 16 seasons in Atlanta, winning two Cy Young Awards (1991 and '98) and finishing in the top three in voting four other times. He left to sign with the Mets before the 2003 season, but he came back to the Braves for one last stint at age 42 in 2008. The left-hander's 305th and final win came in an Atlanta uniform on May 20 of that season.

, Yankees
First stint: 1999-2003 | Returned: 2007

The Rocket's final big league season came with plenty of fanfare: Clemens announced his return via a news bulletin and public announcement during a May 2007 game at Yankee Stadium. His prorated one-year, $28 million contract made plenty more headlines in the following days, and Clemens' return was fully embraced by New York fans, with the Yankees trailing the rival Red Sox in the AL East.

The 44-year-old made his much-anticipated debut in early June, holding the Pirates to three runs over six innings while striking out seven. But the rest of Clemens' season lacked the luster Yankees fans had come to expect (he finished 6-6 with a 4.18 ERA), as Boston won the World Series for the second time in four years.

, Red Sox
First stint: 1978-84 | Returned: 1998

Eckersley cemented his Hall of Fame status in Oakland, but he came into his own as a Red Sox starter, most notably in 1978, when he led Boston with 20 wins and a 2.99 ERA during the club's famous pennant race with the Yankees.

Eck appeared as a starter in all 191 appearances during his first Boston tenure, but he was a full-time reliever by the time he signed with the Red Sox as a 43-year-old in the winter of 1997. The right-hander chipped in 50 relief appearances as the Red Sox captured the AL Wild Card with a 92-70 record, and he even got one last save on May 15.

, Expos
First stint: 1974-84 | Returned: 1992

Few players, if any, were more beloved in Montreal than Carter, and his trade to the Mets in December 1984 arguably turned the tide of both franchises for the rest of the decade. Carter finished his first Expos tenure with seven All-Star Game nods, three Gold Gloves and three Silver Sluggers, before helping the Mets capture the '86 World Series.

But after brief stops in San Francisco and Los Angeles, the catcher returned to Montreal in 1992 for a final victory lap at age 38. Carter's new teammates still jokingly referred to him as "The Kid," and perhaps his presence galvanized the Expos, as they improved by 16 wins from the previous year.

, Dodgers
First stint: 1966-80 | Returned: 1988

Sutton was a workhorse front-line starter for 15 years in Los Angeles, bridging the gap from Sandy Koufax's last season in 1966 to the doorstep of "Fernandomania" in '81. He moved on to form a stacked rotation with Nolan Ryan and Joe Niekro in Houston, and then pitched for the Brewers, A's and Angels before winding his way back to Chavez Ravine for one final season in 1988.

Then 43, Sutton started 16 games and compiled a 3.92 ERA before the Dodgers released him in early August -- though he still joined the team's World Series celebration at the White House that winter.

, A's
First stint: 1968-75 | Returned: 1987

The A's drafted Jackson with the No. 2 overall pick in the second MLB Draft in 1966, and he moved with the franchise from Kansas City to Oakland as the A's ascended from cellar-dweller to perennial powerhouse. The slugger powered Oakland's dynastic three-peat of World Series titles from 1972-74, claiming the Series MVP honor in '73, and finished his first A's tenure with 254 home runs before building his "Mr. October" persona in the Bronx.

At age 41, Jackson returned to the Bay Area in '87 and hit 15 homers for Oakland to finish with 563 -- good for sixth on the all-time career list when he hung up his spikes. He singled in his final Major League at-bat on Oct. 4.

, White Sox
First stint: 1951-57 | Returned: 1960, '64, '76, '80

Minoso made history as one of the first Cuban players in the Major Leagues and one of the first Latin Americans to play in the All-Star Game. A versatile outfielder and third baseman, Minoso led the AL multiple times in triples and stolen bases while routinely hitting over .300 in his first tenure with the White Sox from 1951-57, and then he returned to the South Side multiple times during the latter half of his career.

But Minoso's most memorable reunions with the White Sox came in 1976 and '80, when he came out of retirement at ages 50 and 54, respectively, to become one of the oldest Major Leaguers to ever take the field. Because his career began in 1949, Minoso, incredibly, played in five different decades.