Each team's ideal HR Derby participant

June 19th, 2021

As we inch closer to the Midsummer Classic, the basic fun fact of this All-Star Game becomes more forefront in the mind: This thing is in Colorado. The T-Mobile Home Run Derby is going to be ridiculous. I have always thought they should at least consider having the Home Run Derby in Denver every year, no matter where the actual game is. This is certainly a bad idea for a variety of reasons, but you can understand the appeal of it.

That’s yet another reason to appreciate this year’s. So today, we look at the player from each team who would be the ideal Home Run Derby participant. Obviously, not everyone here will get to be a part of it. But they’d all be terrific. And hey, who’s up for a 30-player tournament at Coors Field? The more the merrier!

AMERICAN LEAGUE EAST

Blue Jays:
He was the runner-up to Pete Alonso at the last Home Run Derby in 2019, and he was just as impressive as Pete. It sure feels like he’s got a real chance to be talked about at this HRD in Denver the way we talk about Ken Griffey Jr. at the last one in Denver.

Orioles:
Every Home Run Derby needs an unabashed fan favorite, and there is no more ideal nominee for this position than Mancini.

Rays:
He’s not the top home run hitter on this team, but he’s the player everyone remembers from last postseason, and we certainly know he can get on a hot streak.

Red Sox:
Martinez has said in the past he doesn’t like the stress of the Derby … which just makes us want him to be in it even more.

Yankees:
Injuries or not, it is likely that no person has ever hit a ball harder and farther than Stanton. (And yes, Aaron Judge is also an acceptable answer here.)

AMERICAN LEAGUE CENTRAL

Cleveland:
We still think he should do half his swings left-handed and half of them right-handed.

Royals:
The offense has fallen off dramatically over the past two years, but the raw, unadulterated power is still there.

Tigers:
C’mon, once more, for old time's sake.

Twins:
He’s in his 40s and still crushing dingers.

White Sox:
We’ll have to wait for next year for Eloy Jiménez or Luis Robert.

AMERICAN LEAGUE WEST

Angels:
Dreams do come true. He’s the guy everyone wanted to do the Derby, and on Friday, it was announced he will be in it.

A’s:
His teammate and fellow Matt -- Chapman -- has been in the Derby before, but Olson, the real power hitter of the Matts, never has.

Astros:
It hasn’t manifested itself this season, but it really wouldn’t be surprising if he hits 45 homers one of these years.

Mariners:
Seeing Haniger healthy and raking again has been one of the pure joys of this Mariners season.

Rangers:
The most surprising story of the Rangers’ season, and maybe the best thing they’ve got going moving forward.

NATIONAL LEAGUE EAST

Braves:
He lost to Alonso in the 2019 semifinals. Here’s hoping he gives it another run.

Marlins:
He’s got surprising power from his frame, and it’d be a blast to see him show it off in a venue like this.

Mets:
He has won it already in 2019, and it was an absolute joy to experience. That makes him the defending Home Run Derby champion.

Nationals:
An event like the Derby doesn’t really capture what Soto does best, but it sure does showcase one of his many, many skills.

Phillies:
He won one as a National, so now it’s time to win one as a Phillie.

NATIONAL LEAGUE CENTRAL

Brewers:
Maybe the Derby will get Yelich’s home run swing to return?

Cardinals:
With as much pure power as anyone in the Majors, O'Neill could make the Derby his perfect coming-out party as a slugger.

Cubs:
Would this help him heading into free agency, or hurt him?

Pirates:
They might want to wait until he has a full year under his belt, but you will absolutely see him in this event at some point.

Reds:
He would find a way to pump up the crowd, antagonize it, or both.

NATIONAL LEAGUE WEST

D-backs:
Did you have any idea Escobar had hit so many home runs this year (15)? I’ll confess, I absolutely did not.

Dodgers:
Obviously, there are many, many players to choose from here. But come on. Wouldn’t this be a blast?

Giants:
Did you know the Giants haven’t had a Derby participant since Barry Bonds? That Posey might be the answer here is a good hint as to why. Would be fun, though.

Padres:
It’s either Vlad Jr. or him who is providing the Griffey Jr. moment here.

Rockies:
If you’re gonna have a hometown guy, you might as well pick the one Rockie currently in double figures in homers.