Jason Mackey’s mailbag: What are the Pirates’ top priorities this offseason?

2:43 PM UTC

Good morning, Pirates fans. Been too long for one of these. But plenty being talked about with the team right now, and I thought it would be a good time to bring the mailbag back. Hope you enjoy this week's version.

Bob Smizik (@BobSmizik): Assuming Brandon Lowe will sign elsewhere, what is the Pirates’ top priority this offseason? Just one.

Jason Mackey: First off, I must say, it’s an honor to have Bob Smizik reading and participating in my Pirates mailbag. I grew up reading and idolizing Bob. Then, to break into the business and get to know him personally, realizing what a wonderful person he is on top of being a legendary member of the Pittsburgh media scene, so cool.

As far as their top priority, general manager Ben Cherington has phrased it as building a stronger, deeper roster. I get that, but it’s vague. I see three specific areas where the roster could use more strength and depth. (Sorry, Bob. I know I’m breaking the rules.)

• Biggest priority needs to be replacing Lowe’s 35 home runs — again, assuming he signs elsewhere. Easy first move would be shifting Nick Gonzales to second base. Improves defense and provides some level of offense from that spot.

Yes, Gonzales had a .755 OPS compared to .824 for Lowe, but that’s still really good for a second baseman; only four teams, including the Pirates, had a better team OPS out of second base in 2026.

In that scenario, the add would come at third base.

My preferred option would be Nolan Arenado from the Diamondbacks, who posted an .806 OPS with 30 homers this past season. Arenado’s salary is very reasonable ($6 million in the final year of an eight-year deal), he also had an .894 OPS against left-handed pitchers.

The question is whether the Diamondbacks would be willing to trade him.

Houston’s Isaac Paredes also makes sense. Had an .806 OPS and 25 homers in 2026. He, too, will be a free agent after the season. Similar to Arenado, Paredes hits lefties well.

I’ve seen other options mentioned like Alec Bohm, Edmundo Sosa and Eugenio Suarez, even Jazz Chisholm Jr. and Xavier Edwards. I’d much rather have Arenado, Paredes or even someone like Casey Schmitt, who’s apparently available in San Francisco for the cost of young pitching.

• Another area to strengthen and deepen: left-handed starting pitching.

The Pirates have done a very good job with soft-tossing lefties like Tyler Anderson, Jose Quintana and Bailey Falter in the past. Some of it involves PNC Park’s dimensions and facing more right-handed hitters.

They also brought out better versions of those guys by either playing up their changeups or making delivery tweaks, plus offering opportunity. They need to run this idea back in 2027.

Who to add probably depends on the market and free-agent demands, but I’d be fine with any of the following, some more plausible than others: Foster Griffin, David Peterson, Matthew Boyd, Kris Bubic or Robbie Ray.

• Last part is a little more simple: bullpen depth. I like the look of the bullpen with Mason Montgomery, Luke Weaver, Yohan Ramirez, Lake Bachar and a few others. It would be great, in my opinion, if Carmen Mlodzinski became a full-time reliever.

But we’ve seen how much depth matters here. Add a seventh-inning guy who could potentially do more if the situation dictated.

Craig Hibell (@CraigHibell): How close is Seth Hernandez? Why does everyone get shuffled around the lineup except Bryan Reynolds? Who’s playing first base?

Jason Mackey: Craig had a few more, but I had to cut him off. I’m sorry. Great questions, though. Let’s go a little quicker with this one:

• Ability-wise, Hernandez is very far along. Temperament, too. What a mature, delightful kid to be around, with an exceptional feel for what he’s doing.

I expect him to start at Double-A — he was very close to a promotion before getting injured — and I doubt he faces much resistance. The issue is building volume.

He’s still so young and obviously very important for the Pirates’ future. It wouldn’t surprise me if he pitched in the Major Leagues in 2027, but I also don’t think they want to skip steps when it comes to his development or his overall innings total.

Teams are super cautious with pitchers these days, and while I personally think it can be too much at times, I get why they do it.

• In a similar vein, there’s shuffling because the Pirates are trying to maximize matchups against pitchers, avoid pockets where they can be pitched to easier (like a run of lefties), and like it or hate it, baseball players in this era get more days off than they used to.

Believe me, the Pirates aren’t the only ones who shuffle their lineup. Follow the Brewers or Rays for a month and chart what they do. It’s the same thing.

I used to rip it when I was a columnist, so I get it. But if they’re going to finish sixth in runs, which they did, I personally don’t care whether they roll out 162 different lineups.

First base: Ryan O’Hearn and Spencer Horwitz. Those two rotating between first and designated hitter.

Rieder79 (@rieder79): Why do you think the Pirates left Tony Blanco Jr., Lonnie White Jr., Jhonny Severino and Yordany De Los Santos unprotected for the Rule 5 draft? These five had 100-plus homers last year between them.

Jason Mackey: I think it comes down to the rules and setup of the Rule 5 draft — if it even happens.

Those guys had excellent seasons, no doubt. But three of the four didn’t play above High-A. Though he reached Double-A, White struck out more than 32% of the time.

That matters because acquiring teams must keep Rule 5 players on their MLB roster for the majority of the year. Are any of these guys ready for that responsibility? Maybe. But it’s much more likely that they’re not.

My own $0.02: It would be surprising if another team picked one of these guys, along with Termarr Johnson. Saw that being talked about, too. But he hit .199 at Triple-A and would be coming off major knee surgery. Not ideal circumstances for someone to make his MLB debut.

heypgh (@Mccafferty67287): How do they shop Mitch Keller coming off the injury?

Jason Mackey: Certainly plenty of Mitch Keller trade talk out there. But I have my doubts on whether anything actually happens.

Given Keller’s performance this past season (poor) and contract ($18.4 million), it won’t be easy. I’d think the Pirates would need to eat some money and/or attach prospect capital, and there’s probably a limit to where that makes sense.

Are you paying half the contract and losing a potentially important prospect to free up $10 million or whatever the money would be? What if Keller pitches the way he did from 2022-25, when he was worth an average of 2.5 wins above replacement, per FanGraphs?

I don’t think Keller is washed. He needs to change some things, potentially concentrating his pitch mix and leaning into the control/ground-ball-inducing way of getting outs.

But I think the Pirates should view this more as a problem to solve than a player they need to jettison. At least not when his value is relatively very low because he was both hurt and bad in 2026.

Maggie (@_Maggie30): With O’Hearn at first base, do you think they’re going to sign an outfielder as a platoon/bench player? Tyrone Taylor and Randal Grichuk are lefty mashers and can play all three outfield spots. They have depth in Indy, but if there’s an injury, none of them should be starting if they’re serious about making the playoffs.

Jason Mackey: I’m completely in favor of signing a platoon bat who can hit lefties because as a team the Pirates weren’t anywhere near good enough in that area in 2026. But I’m not sure I see the fit coming in the outfield.

They already have Bryan Reynolds, Oneil Cruz, Esmerlyn Valdez and Jake Mangum. Plus Akil Baddoo, Chas McCormick and now Mitch Jebb. Yes, they can certainly improve upon that group, but I see more opportunity at second or third base — depending, of course, on what happens with Lowe.

Jason Mackey: Jason.Mackey@pirates.com and @JMackey_PGH on X.