Ranking the Padres' biggest remaining offseason needs

4 minutes ago

This story was excerpted from AJ Cassavell's Padres Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.

SAN DIEGO -- The Padres’ shopping list this winter remains a long one.

Thus far, San Diego has made one external addition -- fringe right-hander Ryan Weiss -- while adding a pair of prospects to their 40-man roster. The major moves are still to come.

Here’s a look at the Padres’ biggest needs (there sure are a lot of them!), ranked in order of importance:

1. An ace

Tarik Skubal would fit nicely atop this rotation, wouldn’t he?

OK, sure, he’d fit nicely atop any rotation. The Padres are in the Skubal sweepstakes, but they’re certainly not the favorite. And there are other places they can look for an ace.

Michael King and Freddy Peralta have probably shown enough to qualify for that moniker entering the 2027 season. There are also a handful of other avenues the Padres could explore via trade.

2. Two more quality starters

General manager A.J. Preller wasn’t kidding when he said last month that his rotation offered him a “blank canvas.” King opted out of his deal, and the Padres declined Nick Pivetta’s option (which came with a tricky player option after the 2027 season that made bringing him back untenable).

That left the Padres with one surefire returnee in right-hander Randy Vásquez -- a perfectly competent back-end starter -- but major question marks everywhere else. What’s Joe Musgrove’s role? Is Yu Darvish back? What do the Padres get from JP Sears, Luis Gutierrez and other types of fringe arms?

Preller is under no illusions. The Padres need starting pitching in bulk.

“You can never have too much from a starting-pitching standpoint,” Preller said last week. “We’re going to need multiples.”

3. A big bat

The Padres’ offensive core remains mostly intact. Key word: “mostly.”

Ty France is a free agent. He was perhaps the team’s most valuable offensive player last season. The Padres are going to need to find a way to replace that production if they want to keep their offense humming the way it was in the second half.

There is, naturally, a case for simply re-signing France. But France’s numbers were markedly better than they were in any of his three previous seasons. It’s fair to appreciate France’s season, while perhaps being a bit skeptical that he can maintain that level. Which, presumably, is why the Padres have been linked with Seiya Suzuki and Teruaki Sato.

4. A lefty reliever

Unlike with France, the Padres can be reasonably confident in what they’d get if they were to bring back Adrian Morejon. He’s been one of the steadiest relievers in baseball for the past three seasons.

But Morejon is the top reliever on the market and likely to command a hefty payday. The Padres are likely to prioritize their needs elsewhere.

Still, there’s a need to fill in the bullpen. Sure, Yuki Matsui’s breakout season has him in the mix. Sure, righties Bradgley Rodriguez and Jeremiah Estrada can cover setup innings. But Preller is not one to skimp in the bullpen. The Padres need one more high-leverage arm. And, after Morejon’s departure, ideally it’s a lefty.

5. Another corner/bench type bat (or two)

So you’ve already added one big bat. Maybe you’re convinced France’s resurgence was for real, and you re-sign him. Maybe you add Suzuki and consider moving Fernando Tatis Jr. back to the infield a bit more regularly.

At that point, what else do you need on offense? It depends on these two questions: 

1. Do you believe in a Dustin Harris/Samad Taylor platoon as a viable option in left field?

2. Did you trade one of your catchers to address any of the above needs?

If you’ve traded Luis Campusano, you need another bench bat. (If you’ve traded Freddy Fermin, you probably do, too, because then Campusano is catching semi-regularly.)

Meanwhile, it’s worth remembering that the Padres lost Austin Hays and Miguel Andujar from their bench mix and could still use a replacement in that righty-hitting platoon/pinch-hit role.

6. Two depth starters

Asked last week whether the Padres needed three starters -- or maybe four -- Preller said: “Keep going.”

Some people are treating those comments like he was joking. I don’t think he was.

That’s not to say the Padres need to add five rotation staples. But they certainly need depth options. 

Think of it this way: A year ago, they signed Walker Buehler, Griffin Canning and Germán Márquez at the start of Spring Training. They did not expect all three to pan out. It was a volume play. They figured if they hit on one of those three, the investment would be worth it. Sure enough, they hit on Buehler. Investment, worth it.

7. More bullpen depth

With one high-leverage left-hander, you could make the case this is a complete bullpen. (Especially if that’s where Musgrove ends up.) But bullpens are fickle. Injuries and regression hit hard.

“Every year you’ve got to remake your ‘pen a little bit,” Preller said. “The bullpen’s not a spot where you’re like, ‘Hey, we can just run it back.’”

Of all the Padres’ needs this winter, low-leverage bullpen arms rank very low. It’s still a need.