Pirates may use September to evaluate talent

Team sits eight games under .500 after Wednesday's loss

August 31st, 2017

PITTSBURGH -- The Pirates entered the final day before the last full month of the season eight games under .500 -- a season-high 10 games out of first place -- after losing 13 of their last 18 games.
"We've been grinding the whole time. We're not giving in any games," catcher said after a 17-3 loss to the Cubs on Wednesday. "We're coming out trying to win every single ballgame. Just hasn't been going our way."
That competitive attitude will not change. But realistically, the Pirates will spend September looking toward 2018. They've already taken steps in that direction, letting setup man go to the Phillies after placing him on irrevocable outright waivers.
So, what can the Pirates attempt to accomplish down the stretch? Consider that the first of many questions they must answer.
Start from the top. General manager Neal Huntington and manager Clint Hurdle have club options for next season that have not yet been picked up. Will they be back?
Their current rotation is set to return next season, while and will make some September starts. Can finish an up-and-down season on a high note, reassuring fans that he can be a top-of-the-rotation arm next year? Will get some rest and finish strong?
How will , and hold up at the end of their first full big league seasons? The Pirates must decide where their young arms best fit. Is Kuhl a starter or reliever? Has Williams' performance given him an edge heading into next year? It seems unlikely that they will call up prospect , but he will be out of Minor League options next season. What role will he play?
The Pirates dropped Nicasio with the intent to use younger and/or controllable pitchers in high-leverage situations down the stretch, Huntington said. So expect to see a lot of (when he's healthy), , and A.J. Schugel in front of .
The Pirates view Neverauskas and Santana as future back-end-of-the-bullpen arms. Will that future begin next year? It would help if , under contract for $5.5 million next year, carves out a role for himself. After Hudson took a step back this year, they could use some certainty in the 'pen heading into next spring.
Health may not seem like a priority for a team evaluating its future options, but it is important for , and to return. It's particularly critical for Polanco, who will be expected to take a step forward next year, to enter the offseason healthy.
Which catcher will back up Cervelli? , 26, will be out of Minor League options next season, making him the likely choice. Stewart has a $1.5 million club option for 2018, but owns a meager .446 OPS on the year. Is Diaz ready to play every day if Cervelli gets hurt again? September may be a good time to find out.
Which young players will step forward and join and Frazier on the bench next year? First baseman/outfielder , infielder and outfielder may receive more playing time to help answer that question.
Finally, keep an eye on two of the season's bright spots. Rookie first baseman Josh Bell is developing into a middle-of-the-order hitter in his first full year, slashing .306/.377/.538 since the beginning of July. found his MVP-level form in June and July then faltered in August. How will he finish? And will the Pirates commit to bringing him back?