Inbox: Tigers in market for top-tier free agent?

Beat reporter Jason Beck fields questions from fans

January 22nd, 2018

DETROIT -- Second inbox of the new year. Pitchers and catchers officially report to Spring Training three weeks from Tuesday.
The Tigers have money, do you think they could try and sign a big free agent or two and try to be competitive, and if things don't work out, they can trade them at the Deadline for more prospects?
I think the Tigers could sign a low-risk deal with a free agent or two over the next few weeks once the market finally begins to move and pitchers try to get into camps. But as far as a big contract with one of the top free agents, like what they did years ago with Ivan Rodriguez and Magglio Ordonez, I'd be shocked. They're certainly not in the business of multiyear contracts at this point after laboring to free up payroll over the past several months. Anything they do the rest of this offseason I would expect to be one-year contracts or non-roster invites.
:: Submit a question to the Tigers Inbox ::
As for next winter, we'll see. The Tigers are in a much better situation on payroll at that point, with just and under guaranteed contracts, but they'll also have prospects nearing the point of competing for jobs on the big league roster.
Early prediction on starting five?
If everybody gets through Spring Training healthy, I would expect a pretty familiar group, with Zimmermann, , Matthew Boyd and joining Mike Fiers. But like you said, it's early, with the Tigers still possibly bringing in another starter to give Boyd and Norris a push and provide injury protection in case Fulmer or Zimmermann need more time for whatever reason. will also be giving a push, having signed a Major League contract early in the offseason.

Who is the underrated player that should make the 2018 team?
Not sure if there really is one candidate, but there's a decent opportunity for , a non-roster invite the Tigers signed from the Indians' organization last month. He played every position but left field and catcher last year at Triple-A Columbus, and he posted a .778 OPS and 17 home runs. The Tigers, meanwhile, have a need for a utility player with gone and sliding to second base to take over for . Pete Kozma will be in camp, too, but he's a few years older and hasn't done as much at the plate the past few seasons.
Second base is Machado's, right? Who would even be the next in line for it? With Romine gone, who will be our bench players?
The Tigers want Machado getting at-bats after spending most of last year on the bench. Unless is injured or traded, Machado will be getting those at-bats at second. Rodriguez and Kozma would likely get a chance if second base suddenly opened up, though they could also bring in another candidate under that scenario. has a chance to be the Tigers' second baseman of the future, but he has yet to play above Double-A.

Do you think the Tigers would move Miggy if he has a bounce-back year like JV did?
It certainly would make Cabrera more appealing on the trade market, but I think Cabrera's contract makes any trade much more complicated than what the Tigers put together for . Detroit is paying part of Verlander's salary this year and next. Cabrera is under contract through 2023, so anything involving splitting up his salary between clubs would impact Detroit's payroll for much longer. I'm not saying it can't be done, or that the Tigers wouldn't pursue a deal, but it's a bigger challenge.