Who was each club's best player of 1990s?

December 30th, 2021

It's far too soon to know for sure who will be the stars of the 2020s, but what we can do is look back at decades of the past. We already identified the best player for every franchise in the 1980s. Now let's turn our attention to the '90s.

We will use cumulative WAR (Baseball Reference's version) as a guiding force, but just as a guide: We want to capture a team's decade spiritually as much as statistically. Which player best represents your team's decade? Here are the most '90s stars for each team.


Blue Jays: , 1B
Key fact: Olerud (1993) is the only player since Lou Gehrig and Harry Heilmann in 1927 to post at least a .360 average, a .470 OBP and 50 doubles in the same season.

Pat Hentgen was probably the best player over the course of the decade, but when you close your eyes and think of the Blue Jays of this period, you think of Joe Carter's homer, and Olerud and his helmet.

Orioles: , 3B
Key fact: Barry Bonds is the only position player in the past 50 years to produce more single-season WAR (per Baseball Reference) than Ripken did in his American League MVP Award-winning 1991 campaign (11.5).

Ripken was, of course, the Orioles' player of the '80s as well. He pretty much had the century wrapped up.

Rays: , 1B
Key fact: Hit exactly 300 home runs in the decade.

This is kind of a fun one, considering the Devil Rays were only around for two years of the decade. The Crime Dog is the clear answer here: He hit 48 homers for the Rays this decade!

Red Sox: , RHP
Key fact: From 1990-92, Clemens became the first pitcher to lead the AL in ERA for three straight seasons since Boston's Lefty Grove from 1934-39.

Clemens pitched well into his 40s, and terrifically, but his prime will always belong to the Red Sox.

Yankees: , CF
Key fact: Led the 1990s Yankees in games, plate appearances, runs, hits, homers, walks, steals and WAR

Many Yankees legends made their debuts this decade, but while Derek Jeter (for example) didn't play a full season until 1996, Bernie began his Yankees tenure in 1991. If we're talking just about the 1990s, Bernie is the pick, as he topped Jeter by more than 10 WAR during the decade.


Cleveland: , CF
Key fact: Led the AL in steals every season from 1992-96, averaging 65.

An incredible decade for Cleveland, one that featured stars everywhere, from Albert Belle to Jim Thome to Manny Ramirez. But Lofton had both the production and the longevity with the club. Plus: He was the most fun player to watch.

Royals: , RHP
Key fact: From 1990-97, posted five of the top 14 single-season ERA+ figures in Royals history, led by his AL-best 179 in '93.

This wasn't the most glorious decade for the Royals, but Appier was quietly excellent pretty much the whole decade.

Tigers: , 1B
Key fact: Owns one of two 50-homer seasons in Tigers history, hitting 51 in 1990 to join Hank Greenberg (58 in '38)

Fielder didn't play the longest and he wasn't the greatest Tiger this decade -- that might have been Travis Fryman or Tony Phillips, actually -- but he's the most memorable Tiger of the decade, no question.

Twins: , 2B
Key fact: In franchise history, Rod Carew in 1977 is the only position player to exceed Knoblauch's 8.7 WAR in 1996.

Knoblauch's throwing issues wouldn't pop up until he was traded to the Yankees late in the decade.

White Sox: , 1B
Key fact: Is one of four players in history with a 1.000 OPS and 300 homers in his first 10 MLB seasons (1990-99).

Thomas ended up getting a World Series ring in 2005, even if he barely played, but we'll never know how that Expos-White Sox 1994 Series would have turned out.


Angels: , RF
Key fact: His 40.6 career WAR is the second most for a position player who never made an All-Star team since the event began in 1933.

Always an underappreciated player, Salmon barely edges out Jim Edmonds for the decade.

Astros: , 1B
Key fact: Posted a 170 OPS+ from 1994-99 while averaging 111 walks, 113 runs and 116 RBIs.

Bagwell would be confused to find himself over on the American League side here, but he put up stats as good as anyone in the game this decade.

Athletics: , LF
Key fact: Won AL MVP in 1990, when he joined Joe Morgan ('76) as the only players since Ty Cobb to combine a 1.000 OPS with 60 steals.

One of only three players on this list to be his franchise's best player of both the 1980s and the '90s.

Mariners: , CF
Key fact: Ranked second in the decade in homers (382) and RBIs (1,091) while winning 10 Gold Glove Awards.

The most 1990s baseball player of them all, in all the good ways. Put that hat backwards, please.

Rangers: , C
Key fact: Threw out 55% of 342 opposing base-stealers from 1996-99.

When Rodriguez first broke in at the age of 19, he was seen as more of a defensive wizard, but by the end of the decade, he was an offensive force and an MVP winner.


Braves: , RHP
Key fact: Is the only pitcher in history with multiple seasons of 200 innings and a 260 ERA+, doing it back to back in 1994-95.

You'll never see a pitcher like Maddux again, and we're all the poorer for it.

Marlins: , RF
Key fact: Sheffield's 156 OPS+ over six seasons in Miami is easily the highest for any player to spend more than one year there

The Marlins won a World Series this decade, assuring the teal will live on forever.

Mets: , 2B
Key fact: Is the only second baseman in franchise history to crack the 4-WAR mark in a season, and both times he exceeded 6 WAR.

It was a bit of a disjointed decade for the Mets, who were pretty bad in the first half of it, but had a renaissance in the latter half. Their WAR leader for the decade is actually John Olerud.

Nationals: , RF
Key fact: Walker had 21.3 WAR in the 1990s for the Expos, the most of any position player in the decade -- despite only playing there from 1990-94.

There is the first half of the decade (with Walker, Marquis Grissom, Dennis Martinez, Moises Alou) and the second half (Pedro Martinez, Vladimir Guerrero). Walker is the standout of the eras.

Phillies: , SP
Key fact: Three pitchers reached 300 strikeouts in a season in the 1990s, and Schilling was one of them, in 1997-98.

With all the drama that would come with the next decade of his career, this excellent decade with Philadelphia was almost … quiet? (It's OK if you pick any player from that 1993 team.)


Brewers: , 3B
Key fact: Cirillo played in 130-plus games in four seasons in the 1990s and hit .321 or better in three of those.

This was the decade the Brewers waved goodbye to Robin Yount and Paul Molitor … and said hello to Cirillo.

Cardinals: , CF
Key fact: Lankford's 36.1 WAR led all Cardinals position players in the 1990s.

Lankford was consistently excellent for the Cardinals all decade, but no one really noticed until Mark McGwire showed up at the end of it.

Cubs: , RF
Key fact: One of nine players to hit more than 300 homers (332) in the 1990s.

Mark Grace famously had more hits than anyone else this decade, but there are no 1990s Cubs without Sosa -- not really.

Pirates: , SS
Key fact: Bell was an All-Star in 1993 for the Pirates, also winning a National League Gold Glove and NL Silver Slugger Award.

Barry Bonds is actually the Pirates' bWAR leader for the decade, but in only three seasons, and who wants to talk about how this decade started for the Pirates anyway?

Reds: , SS
Key fact: Won NL MVP Award in 1995, but his 1996 season got MVP consideration, too, with a career-high 7.2 WAR and 33 homers.

"Chris Sabo's goggles" is another perfectly acceptable answer here.


D-backs: , SS/2B
Key fact: Led 1999 D-backs with 38 homers.

Bet you didn't imagine Bell showing up twice on this list, did you? He actually hit more homers in the first two years of the D-backs' existence than Matt Williams did.

Dodgers: , C
Key fact: Hit 240 homers in the 1990s (though not all for the Dodgers), 78 more than any other catcher, and he didn't debut until 1992.

The Dodgers turned out to get a rather decent return on investment when they drafted Tommy Lasorda's godson.

Giants: , LF
Key fact: Led all position players with 80.2 WAR in the 1990s.

And he, of course, was just getting started.

Padres: , RF
Key fact: Gwynn hit .344 in the 1990s, the highest of any player in that span (min. 3,000 plate appearances).

Gwynn is still a franchise icon 30 years later and surely will be 30 years from now.

Rockies: , RF
Key fact: Led Majors with 409 total bases in 1997, the second-most by any player in a single season in the 1990s.

Walker was the Expos' best player for the first half of the decade, and the Rockies' for the second half.