How Snell's 2023 compares with Padres' 4 Cy Young seasons

November 14th, 2023

This story was excerpted from the Padres Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.

Left-hander is the heavy favorite to become the 2023 NL Cy Young Award winner on Wednesday (watch live at 3 p.m. PT on MLB Network), which would make him the fifth Padres pitcher to earn the Cy Young honor.

Let’s take a look at how his dominant campaign ranks with San Diego’s Cy Young seasons, in countdown fashion:

5) Mark Davis, 1989

The only reliever in franchise history to claim the Cy Young hardware, the left-hander had 44 saves in 44 opportunities and a 1.85 ERA in 70 games. His bWAR of 4.4 didn’t measure up to Orel Hershiser’s 7.0, but voters of the era heavily weighted the Dodgers ace’s 15-15 win-loss record.

Davis’ Cy Young season was the final one in a stretch in which voters opted for a reliever (in either league) in seven of 16 seasons. Only two relievers have won since: Dennis Eckersley in the AL in 1992 and Eric Gagne in the NL in 2003.

4) Gaylord Perry, 1978

Perry became the first pitcher to earn a Cy Young Award in each league with a big first season in San Diego. The veteran right-hander was 21-6 with a 2.73 ERA while helping the Padres to the first winning season in franchise history.

Phil Niekro’s 10.0 bWAR with a bad Atlanta team dwarfed Perry’s 4.3, but voters weren’t ready to overlook a 19-18 win-loss mark. The spitballer was miles ahead of the knuckleballer in the balloting.

3) Blake Snell, 2023

After a slow start, Snell moved into 1968 Bob Gibson territory, posting a 1.20 ERA over his final 23 starts. The season as a whole is nearly as impressive. Not since he was the AL Cy Young Award winner for Tampa Bay in 2018 had Snell shown mastery of all four weapons: fastball, curveball, changeup and slider.

He went 14-9 and led the NL in ERA (2.25), pitchers’ bWAR (6.0), ERA+ (182) and hits per nine innings (5.75). He issued the most walks (99) but overcame that with 234 strikeouts (second in the NL) and a .152 opponents’ batting average with runners in scoring position (best in the Majors by a large margin).

2) Randy Jones, 1976

Truth be told, 2023 Snell was more effective than 1976 Jones … when Snell was on the mound. The “left-hander with the Karl Marx hairdo,” as beloved broadcaster Jerry Coleman once called him, simply was on the mound a lot more. Jones earns the nod here because of his workload -- 315 1/3 innings and 25 complete games. To put that in perspective, that’s more innings than Snell’s past two seasons combined.

Jones went 22-14 with a 2.74 ERA and a 4.7 bWAR while becoming the first face of the franchise. Mind you, crediting Jones for his workload is not to judge how Snell has been used. Times have changed. Jones paid a price for pitching so much. He suffered nerve damage that required surgery and never approached his peak again.

1) Jake Peavy, 2007

A lively fastball with movement, a deceptive delivery, a plus changeup and a devastating slider with late bite -- Peavy had it all going in 2007. The results speak for themselves.

The right-hander won the pitching Triple Crown by leading the NL with 19 wins, a 2.54 ERA and 240 strikeouts. Arizona’s Brandon Webb had the bWAR edge, 6.4 to 6.2, but the traditional stats ruled the day. Peavy earned all 32 first-place votes.