SAN DIEGO -- The Padres made decisions on three pitchers ahead of Friday’s deadline to tender contracts to their arbitration-eligible players.
They agreed to deals with righties Bryan Hoeing and Jhony Brito for the 2027 season, while non-tendering lefty JP Sears. Sears will become a free agent (along with righty relief prospect Garrett Hawkins, who was also not tendered a contract).
Earlier in the day, the Padres avoided arbitration with Gavin Sheets, agreeing to a three-year extension that contains opt-outs for Sheets after each of the first two seasons. San Diego tendered contracts to all four of its remaining arbitration-eligible players -- Mason Miller, Jeremiah Estrada, Luis Campusano and Freddy Fermin.
What it means
Friday marked the deadline for teams to tender contracts to players on their 40-man roster. By tendering contracts to Miller, Estrada, Campusano and Fermin, the Padres will now enter the arbitration process with them.
The Padres can still agree to a contract with any or all of them for the 2027 season. But if they don’t come to an agreement, both parties would submit a proposed salary for the season, and an arbitration panel would pick between the two proposals.
It’s unlikely to get that far.
A.J. Preller just entered his 13th offseason as general manager in San Diego. He’s never seen a case reach arbitration. The last Padre to reach arbitration was Andrew Cashner in 2013.
Clarity on the pitching staff
It should come as no surprise that Miller, Fermin, Campusano, Estrada and Sheets are set to return (though the nature of Sheets’ contract is certainly interesting).
The biggest decisions the Padres had to make on Friday centered around Hoeing, Brito and Sears.
Hoeing missed the 2026 season following March surgery to repair the flexor tendon in his right elbow. It’s unclear when he would be able to return, but it’s entirely possible he could miss the beginning of the ‘27 season.
Still, the Padres liked the upside enough to bring Hoeing back. In 25 appearances with San Diego after his arrival at the ‘24 Trade Deadline, Hoeing has a 1.99 ERA.
Brito, meanwhile, has a 3.93 ERA in 31 big league appearances since his arrival in the deal that sent Juan Soto to the Yankees. He figures to continue serving as a swingman, capable of both starting and relieving.
As for Sears, he arrived alongside Miller in a deal with the A’s at the 2025 Trade Deadline. He showed flashes of promise, but largely struggled, posting a 5.02 ERA in 13 big league outings for the Padres.
Recapping the state of the roster
San Diego’s 40-man roster now stands at just 34 players, leaving plenty of room to maneuver.
Friday’s moves capped a busy couple weeks of roster shuffling. The Padres recently added lefty Luis Gutierrez and righties Ian Koenig and Tucker Musgrove to the 40-man roster and they signed righty Ryan Weiss to a Major League deal (though Weiss can still be optioned to the Minors).
Gutierrez, Koenig and Weiss are expected to serve as upper-level rotation depth in the Minor Leagues, helping mitigate the loss of Sears. Sears spent most of his time with the Padres at Triple-A, but was out of options entering the 2027 season.
Sears’ departure is not a huge surprise, but it underscores just how thin the San Diego rotation currently is. Among the nine pitchers who started at least six games for the Padres last season, only one -- Randy Vásquez -- is not a free agent this winter.
The rotation, as Preller has noted time and time again, remains the top priority.
