What's the status of the Pirates' catching corps entering '27?

8 minutes ago

PITTSBURGH -- General manager Ben Cherington made it clear at last week’s GM Meetings that he’s exploring upgrades to the Pirates' outfield defense and left-handed pitching. He also must see if second baseman Brandon Lowe returns to Pittsburgh to build the infield. But when it comes to the catching position, there hasn’t been much chatter.  

Five Pirates catchers combined for 616 plate appearances in 2026, with former first overall pick  accounting for nearly half of those. The position group finished with a .742 OPS and 29 home runs, ranking seventh and fifth in the Majors, respectively. They also posted a 23.9% caught-stealing rate, which was 13th best in baseball. 

The production came mostly from Davis and two unproven backstops,  and  So what is the outlook on the position for 2027?

First, the Pirates have to determine where Davis fits into the mix. He batted .172 with a .585 OPS in his fourth MLB season, the third straight year in which his batting average finished below .200. 

There were still some bright spots in his 2026 campaign. He finished with career highs in home runs (10) and RBIs (38). His defense registered positively, as he had 3 Fielding Run Value (65th percentile) and 4 Blocks Above Average (73rd), according to Baseball Savant. 

It may just be that Davis ends up profiling more like Austin Hedges -- a defensively minded catcher who fits best in a backup role. The offensive potential seems higher with Rodríguez and Flores. 

An undrafted prospect out of Anaheim, Flores came to the Pirates at the 2025 Trade Deadline as a key piece in a deal that sent closer David Bednar to the Yankees.

Flores showcased his power once he earned significant playing time late in the year. Across 39 games in August and September, he posted an .845 OPS with 10 home runs.

“[He’s] a dangerous right-handed bat at that position,” Cherington said. “He's always hit lefties. [He had] some production against righties after he got called up in the big leagues. I think he made some adjustments and got a little bit of confidence. Defensively … he has to work at it because he's a big, athletic guy at the position. He's got to keep his technique right. And we did see him make pretty fast adjustments defensively once he was in the big leagues with his throwing.”

Flores produced a -3 Fielding Run Value, and his Blocks Above Average were -5 (19th percentile).

As for Rodríguez, the 26-year-old is a former MLB Pipeline Top 100 prospect, and he appeared to be coming into his own in 2026 with an .840 OPS in 45 games. However, he underwent season-ending surgery on his left hip in August. Rodríguez previously underwent Tommy John surgery (December 2023) and dealt with an ulnar nerve injury (August 2025). He could be non-tendered ahead of Friday’s deadline, though that seems unlikely. 

Retaining Rodríguez would maintain the catching depth in the system, an especially important task after the club parted ways with Joey Bart, Shawn Ross and Omar Alfonzo last season.