Kluber shaky as Tribe drops Game 1 to Astros

Indians ace allows 3 HRs in 4th straight rocky postseason start

October 5th, 2018

HOUSTON -- As the walls of Minute Maid Park trembled amid the chaos on Friday afternoon, Indians pitching coach Carl Willis jogged out to the mound. Anything to try to calm the calamitous atmosphere in the fifth inning, while also giving Cleveland's bullpen time to prepare for duty.
had just finished circling the bases after sending one of 's sinkers to the front of the Crawford Boxes in left field. That was the second straight home run for the reigning World Series champions, who brought Kluber's past postseason problems back to the forefront in the Tribe's 7-2 defeat in Game 1 of the American League Division Series.
:: ALDS schedule and results ::
"Last year has nothing to do with today," Indians manager Terry Francona said. "They're a good team. He made a couple of mistakes. They made him pay for it."
Cleveland now faces an uphill battle in its quest to bring the franchise its first World Series triumph since 1948. In the history of five-game series with the 2-2-1 format, teams that have won Game 1 at home have gone on to win the series 75 percent (27 of 36) of the time.
For the first three innings, Kluber and Astros ace locked horns and quieted both lineups. Verlander kept on cruising, while Kluber's outing began to fall apart at the seams in the fourth. That is when jolted the Houston crowd with a scorched leadoff shot off the Indians' two-time AL Cy Young Award winner.
"Once Bregman homered," Astros outfielder said, "that was a little bit of a game-changer for not only them, but for us."
Bregman's blast surely summoned flashbacks of last year's ALDS against the Yankees in the minds of Tribe fans. In two starts against New York last October, Kluber looked human after wrapping up his second career Cy Young Award-winning campaign. The ace worked 6 1/3 innings combined, allowing nine runs, including three via a pair of homers to Didi Gregorius in the decisive Game 5 loss in Cleveland.

That was, however, nearly a calendar year ago. In Kluber's mind, mentioning those outings in the same sentence as Friday's rough start is wasted breath.
"I don't think they're related," Kluber said. "Every start -- whether it's a good string of starts or a bad string of starts -- is individual to itself. I think I said [recently], good or bad, I don't dwell on the last outing for very long. I kind of put my head down and get to work to get ready for the next one."

Over the remainder of the fourth inning on Friday, Kluber faced six more batters, relinquishing an RBI single to Reddick before escaping further harm. In the fifth, the deficit grew, along with the ballpark's decibel level. First, crushed a full-count cutter deep to left field for a homer, while the train horn blared from above.

Altuve then shot a 1-0 sinker into the left-field seats, eliciting the eruption that prompted Willis' visit to the mound. Kluber's pitch velocity (91.5-mph average on his sinker, per Statcast™) was north of where it sat in September (90.7 mph), but the right-hander's signature command was noticeably off. Fastballs found the middle of the zone, rather than zipping to the edges.
"Really, I just left the balls elevated," Kluber said, "over and out, the middle of the plate, for the home runs. The wrong three guys to do that to. You've got to be able to keep the ball in the ballpark in these games."
Tito, Hinch handle bullpens differently in Game 1
The Astros' offensive attack continued after Kluber's 4 2/3 innings, in which he gave up four runs on six hits with two strikeouts, two walks and two hit batsmen. In the seventh, launched an elevated fastball from out to left, and Bregman later added a run-scoring single off . Reddick contributed an RBI single off Indians reliever Dan Otero in the eighth to further set Cleveland back.
The four homers by the Astros were the most for any team against Cleveland in the postseason since Oct. 10, 1999 (a 23-7 loss in Game 4 of the ALDS against the Red Sox).
Complicating matters was the lineup's inability to do much against Verlander, who pieced together five no-hit innings before giving up a single to in the sixth. The Indians, who hit just .171 with a .550 OPS in five ALDS games a year ago, did not break through until Verlander's departure, and neither run came via a hit.

"He was just coming right at us," Gomes said. "He's back to throwing 95-plus [mph] and he's living in the top of the zone. At first, we weren't able to get that many good swings on him. We were trying to put good at-bats together, but he was just getting ahead. With a guy like that, when he's throwing strikes and using the top of the zone, it's kind of hard to get comfortable."
The paltry showing by the offense (3-for-30 overall) did not help, but Kluber now finds himself under the microscope.
Kluber's first five career outings in the playoffs were nothing short of brilliant. He turned in a 0.89 ERA with 35 strikeouts and only one homer surrendered across 30 1/3 innings, while helping a depleted Cleveland staff reach the World Series in 2016. Dating back to Game 7 of that Fall Classic, though, Kluber has given up 17 earned runs with 12 strikeouts and nine homers allowed in 15 innings over his past four postseason performances.
MOMENTS THAT MATTERED
Sticking with Kluber: Kluber needed only 33 pitches to breeze through the first three innings, but he labored through a 35-pitch fourth, which featured Bregman's home run. Francona sent Kluber back to the mound for the fifth inning, and Houston kept its foot on the gas. Springer and Altuve connected for consecutive home runs to begin the inning, and Kluber was out of the game after facing three more hitters.

Francona said he did not consider pulling Kluber after the fourth.
"No, because once you go, you're committed," Francona said. "We've got a game tomorrow. Once we were behind, I wanted to try to keep it where it was -- not have the guys pitch too much, but also get them in and maybe take some of the rust off."

Astros limit damage: After Verlander walked to load the bases with one out in the sixth, Astros manager AJ Hinch emerged from the home dugout. With a 4-0 lead and slugger looming, Houston opted to hand the ball to reliever . A wild pitch brought in the Tribe's first run and Ramirez plated another with a groundout, but struck out against Pressly to halt the Indians' rally.

"That inning was spiraling a little bit," Hinch said. "[Verlander] ran out of gas a little bit against Brantley. And all we asked Pressly to do was come in against Ramirez and Encarnacion -- 60-plus homers, almost 70 homers with those guys. He can really spin the ball, which in that part of the order we liked."

Bauer's bullpen debut: Francona hinted that Bauer could be used as a multi-inning leverage arm in this series, but the goal on Friday quickly became to halt Houston's momentum. With a runner on first and the Astros holding a 5-2 lead in the seventh, Bauer took over for Allen. Bauer only worked one inning and gave up two hits, including an RBI single to Bregman.

"He needed to [pitch] regardless," Francona said. "I mean, we're not even thinking about Game 4. Our sights are set on Game 2. But I thought it was important for him to get in and pitch. With Trevor, he could probably pitch every game. … Getting in was important for him."

HE SAID IT
"The Yankees were down 0-2 against us. They came back and beat us [in the 2017 ALDS]. The Cubs were down 1-3, came back and beat us [in the '16 World Series]. I know how it feels being up and losing the series. It doesn't matter. One game is one game." --

"We have a lot of respect for him. Sometimes when you're facing a guy like him, the only thing you can do to control him is swing the bat, and that was our mindset. We were pretty aggressive swinging at the first pitch and good things happened." -- Altuve, on Kluber
SOUND SMART
Dating back to last year's World Series, Springer has homered in five consecutive postseason games for the Astros. He joins Carlos Beltran (five straight with Houston in 2004) and (six in a row for the Mets in '16) as the only players to accomplish that feat in MLB history.
UP NEXT
For Game 2 of the ALDS today, Indians righty (17-10, 3.38 ERA) will pitch opposite Astros righty (15-5, 2.88 ERA) at 4:37 p.m. ET at Minute Maid Park. Carrasco spun 5 2/3 shutout innings in a Game 3 ALDS outing vs. the Yankees last October. The big right-hander ended the year with a 2.64 ERA and 158 strikeouts against 24 walks in 116 innings across his final 20 appearances.