
Here is our ranking of the top five shortstops in Rockies history.
1. Troy Tulowitzki, 2006-15
Key fact: From 2007-11, Tulowitzki compiled a .377 weighted on-base average -- second for shortstops behind Hanley Ramirez (.387).
Troy Tulowitzki’s name sparks a wistfulness among Rockies fans who wonder what would have happened had "Tulo" stayed healthy consistently. His anger after he was traded to the Blue Jays in 2015 stayed fresh in a lot of minds. But it would be a shame to let injuries or the hard feelings of his departure overshadow the force that Tulowitzki was in purple pinstripes.
Tulowitzki accomplished five All-Star Games, two National League Silver Sluggers, two NL Gold Gloves, three top-10 finishes in the NL Most Valuable Player voting and a second-place finish for the 2007 NL Rookie of the Year Award.
Plus, he looked different. At 6-foot-3 and solid, he was bigger than any Rockies shortstop before him. No Rockies history montage is complete without his signature play -- floating to his right, throwing across his body, with the tail of his odd mullet haircut flying behind his cap and intense eyes burning just above the smudge of eye black. Add to that the sounds of the handclaps and the “Tulo” chant.
Tulowitzki dropped off the Baseball Writers’ Association of America Hall of Fame ballot after his first year of eligibility. Given he was one of the top players at his position and his accomplishments rank with some who are in, could his candidacy be re-examined in future years?
2. Trevor Story, 2016-21
Key fact: Story is the first shortstop to begin his career with four seasons of 20 or more home runs.
Tulowitzki took time during his career to mentor Trevor Story after the Rockies made him a first-round pick in 2011. The Rockies definitely benefitted from the relationship.
Story has a quieter demeanor than Tulowitzki carried, but he was every bit the force in the middle of the infield. While Tulowitzki’s first four full seasons outstripped Story’s in terms of wins above replacement, 20.8 to 18.6, using baseball-reference.com’s metrics, Story’s Rockies matched Tulowitzki’s in terms of postseason berths (two). Story had the edge in home runs 123-92 (counting the one Tulowitzki had during a 2006 cameo).
Story, who is in the same size category as Tulowitzki, even had his own signature play -- going to the middle, then spinning and pinpointing a throw to first base.
3. Clint Barmes (2003-10)
Key fact: Barmes legitimately appears on the list of Top 5 Second Basemen, but he made 303 starts at shortstop and 262 at second base during his Rockies career.
We did this exercise a few years back and made Clint Barmes an Honorable Mention. But the great thing about lists and arguments is they’re etched in cyberspace, not in stone. Barmes checks in with a 9.3 defensive WAR, which puts him third behind Tulowitzki’s 14.0 and Story’s 10.8.
4. Ezequiel Tovar (2022-present)
Key fact: Tovar’s 518 games, 495 hits and 120 doubles are the most in franchise history before a player’s age 25 season.
That’s right. Ezequiel Tovar didn’t turn 25 until Aug. 1, 2026. It seems he has packed a lot into such a short time. In 2024, his second full season, Tovar won his first Gold Glove Award and led the National League with 45 doubles while playing in 155 games. But hip and oblique injuries limited him to 95 games in 2025, and he struggled for much of 2026. Still, Tovar is seen as a key to the team’s future in the middle of the diamond.
5. Walt Weiss, 1994-97
Key fact: Weiss’ .403 on-base percentage in 1995 is highest for a Rockies shortstop in a single season.
The arrival of Walt Weiss in 1994 allowed the Rockies to play Vinny Castilla at third base, where he became one of the best at his position in club history. Weiss, who managed the Rockies from 2013-16 and took over as the Braves’ manager in 2026, posted a 3.8 bWAR with the club.
