Guardians' Top 5 managers: MLB.com's take

5:33 PM UTC

No one loves a good debate quite like baseball fans, and with that in mind, we asked each of our beat reporters to rank the top five players by position in the history of their franchise, based on their career while playing for that club. These rankings are for fun and debate purposes only.

Here is MLB.com’s ranking of the top 5 managers in Guardians history.

• Guardians' all-time team: C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | LF | CF | RF | DH | RH SP | LH SP | RP

1. Tris Speaker, 1919-26
Key fact: Player-manager for 1920 World Series championship team

Speaker joined Cleveland in 1916 following a stellar nine-season tenure with the Red Sox. It did not take the center fielder long to make a lasting impact on his new organization, which helped him earn the top spot on the list.

Speaker became Cleveland’s player-manager in 1919, and he led the franchise to its first World Series title in his first full season as skipper in ‘20. Under his leadership, the club rallied past the tragic death of shortstop Ray Chapman (who was hit by a pitch on his head in August) en route to a 98-56 finish. Cleveland held off the White Sox (96-58) and Yankees (95-59) to win the American League pennant, and then toppled the Brooklyn Robins in seven games to win the Fall Classic.

Speaker ranks fourth in wins (617) among all Cleveland managers and holds the eighth-best winning percentage (.543) of those who managed at least three seasons.

2. Terry Francona, 2013-23
Key fact: Winningest manager in franchise history

There is a compelling case for Francona to be atop this list; the lone thing holding him back is a World Series title, which he and Cleveland came agonizingly close to securing in 2016. He is nonetheless the best modern-day manager in franchise history.

Francona is Cleveland’s winningest manager (921 victories) and its longest-tenured by seasons (11) and games (1,678). Under his leadership, the club reached the postseason six times, won four AL Central titles (‘16-18, ‘22) and won one AL pennant (‘16). The ‘17 team won 102 games, which is the second most in a single season in franchise history (1954, 111 wins). 

Francona led Cleveland to four straight seasons of 90-plus wins (2016-19), which was just the second time the club reached a streak of that length (1950-55). Among those who served at least three seasons as manager, his .549 winning percentage is tied with Joe Gordon for fifth in franchise history.

3. Lou Boudreau, 1942-50
Key fact: Second in wins among all Cleveland managers and was at the helm for the 1948 World Series

There is also a convincing argument for Boudreau, another player-manager, to be higher on this list. His nine-season managerial tenure is tied for the second-longest in franchise history. That longevity helped him rack up 728 wins, which trails only Francona among Cleveland skippers. Boudreau’s winning percentage (.529) ranks 12th among those who managed at least three seasons.

And, of course, Boudreau led Cleveland to its second World Series title in franchise history in 1948, in his seventh season as player-manager.

Boudreau is often credited for being the first manager to consistently use defensive shifts, primarily against the hot-hitting Ted Williams. His 1,389 games at the helm is the second most in franchise history behind Francona, and his 79 games over .500 is fifth highest.

4. Mike Hargrove, 1991-99
Key fact: Only Cleveland manager to win two AL pennants

Hargrove led some of the best teams in franchise history. The 1990s was arguably the most memorable decade in franchise history, and the ’95 squad was one of just three to crack the 100-win milestone.

In nine seasons (tied with Boudreau for Cleveland’s second-longest managerial tenure) Hargrove won 721 games (third most in franchise history), had a .550 winning percentage (tied for third among those who managed at least three seasons) and managed 1,312 games (third most). The club won five straight AL Central titles under his direction (1995-99), and he’s the only Cleveland skipper to win two AL pennants (’95, ’97).

5. Al Lopez, 1951-56
Key fact: Has the best winning percentage of all Cleveland skippers

Of all the skippers on this list, Lopez’s stint in Cleveland was the shortest. But he was able to rack up plenty of wins in a more limited time frame than the others. In six seasons, Lopez won 570 games, which ranks fifth in team history. His .617 winning percentage ranks first among Cleveland managers, and his 216 games over .500 outpaces Francona by 52 contests for best in club history.

Lopez led Cleveland to a club-record 111 wins and an AL pennant in 1954. His 930 games managed is the seventh most in franchise history, and none of his teams finished below second place. 

Honorable mentions

It may not be long before Stephen Vogt (2024-present) makes his way higher up this list. His .546 winning percentage through three seasons ranked seventh in team history. He won three straight AL Central titles to start his managerial tenure, which came only one year after the end of his playing career. Vogt led the Guardians back from a 15 1/2-game deficit in 2025 to win the division, which was the largest a team erased to win a division (since 1969) or league (pre-’69) in MLB history. Along the way, he became one of only four skippers to win the Manager of the Year Award in back to back seasons.

Nap Lajoie was a player/manager for Cleveland from 1905-09. His 377 wins are the eighth most in club history and his .550 winning percentage is tied with Hargrove for fourth.

Eric Wedge won the AL Manager of the Year Award in 2007 and managed the fifth most games in franchise history (1,134). Although his overall record ended under .500, Wedge’s 561 wins rank sixth among Cleveland skippers.