How Ohtani creates a roster-building puzzle for the Dodgers

L.A. has to figure out how pieces fit around its star DH

November 10th, 2026

The Dodgers won 100 games in 2026, along with their 13th NL West title in 14 years, and may still be taking the most talented roster in the game into the winter, so there’s no need to pretend that the dynasty is over, or any similar nonsense. They’ve long been very good, and will continue to be very good.

Still, the second half of the 2026 season was occasionally a slog. A veteran-laden team looked old and slow, then got completely wiped out by the more athletic Brewers in the National League Championship Series, which certainly didn’t do much to dispel that notion.

That older, veteran team we just saw will simply get one additional year older and more veteran this winter, as nearly all of the position player group is set to return, save for backups Miguel Rojas (who retired) and Kiké Hernández (who, we assume, will return for his usual one-year engagement some months from now). Once Kyle Tucker celebrates his 30th birthday in January, only one projected starter will be in his 20s next year, that being 26-year-old center fielder Andy Pages.

That all leaves the Dodgers with an interesting and somewhat complicated roster-building puzzle, as the quest to get younger runs into a veteran group that is, for the most part, still performing at a very high level.

There's one additional complication, too. The Dodgers can’t use their designated hitter spot as an occasional ‘half-day off’ spot, thanks to the immovable presence of Shohei Ohtani.

It’s certainly not that having maybe the most talented player we’ve ever seen is a problem for which anyone should have sympathy. But it still adds some complications to manager Dave Roberts’ daily lineups, and to the offseason choices of the front office. 

Consider these three issues that Ohtani's presence helps create for the Dodgers, as they try to look ahead to 2027.

We’ve almost never seen corner infielders this old.

First baseman Freddie Freeman, who turned 37 in September, is locked into first base in the final year of his contract. Third baseman Max Muncy, who turned 36 in August, is in the same spot at the other corner, also in the final year of his deal. Each performed well enough in 2026. Muncy had one of the better years of his career, while Freeman, if clearly past his peak, was still an All-Star who hit 20% better than league average, with some defensive value.

Neither is in danger of losing his starting job in 2027, and normally, that’s a recipe for a day or two at DH per week for each, to get the proverbial “half-day off.” But that’s obviously not really an option here, given the presence of Ohtani, which means the Dodgers are set up to have something we have rarely ever seen: two corner infielders, playing every day, at 36 years old (or more).

After all, look at what they did in 2026. Freeman and Muncy (along with spot appearances from Rojas and Hernández) just combined for 1,211 plate appearances at the corners. It's the second-most playing time any team in the Divisional Era (1969-present) has given to corner infielders 35 years or older.

Most PA from 1B/3B at 35+ years old, since 1969

YEAR TEAM

PA

1985 Padres 1,343
2026 Dodgers 1,211
1984 Padres 1,194
2001 D-backs 1,142
2008 Orioles 1,112
2007 Orioles 1,079
1998 Padres 1,021

The 1984 Padres, obviously in a pre-DH era, had 35-year-old Steve Garvey and 39-year-old Graig Nettles, plus 37-year-old Kurt Bevacqua as a backup, and they went to the World Series. The 2001 D-backs won the title, while playing 35-year-old Mark Grace at first, receiving throws from 37-year-old Matt Williams. It's not how you'd draw it up, but it can be done. 

This list also tells us what the 2027 Dodgers are up against, because the '85 Padres brought back the same trio, but older, so 1,343 plate appearances is also the Divisional Era record for most corner infield PA given to players 36 or older. That '85 team won nine fewer games than the year before and finished third in the NL West.

The Dodgers probably won't get there. But that it's even a topic to discuss is because, like those 80s Padres, DH is not really available for their older players, either. Even if it was, neither Freeman nor Muncy is necessarily the ideal candidate on this roster to be taking any non-Ohtani days there. That’s because ...

Their best young hitter’s best position is “designated hitter.”

That’s 21-year-old Josue De Paula, who came up late in the season and then was carried on the postseason roster. We absolutely will not put too much stock in him hitting .323/.500/.581 in 41 Major League plate appearances, but there’s a reason he’s a consensus top-five prospect, and you could see that even in such a small sample at the highest level. De Paula drew 11 walks against only five strikeouts, with a top-five chase rate, and those are things that are not only meaningful quickly, but also align quite well with the scouting reports.

The problem is that De Paula’s defensive game lags far behind his hitting, with most reports considering his glove to be inferior to that of teammate Teoscar Hernández – who himself is a poor defender. The Dodgers clearly did not trust him to play the outfield, either. (“We view him as a DH,” said president of baseball operations Andrew Friedman, speaking about the right-now situation of late 2026.) While he’s expected to spend all winter on his defense, it’s an open question as to how playable De Paula can get in just one year. 

De Paula has drawn comparisons to Astros DH and AL MVP Yordan Alvarez, in ways both good (the elite offensive approach and command of the strike zone) and poor (you ideally never want either to wear a glove). If De Paula can get the glove to be merely competent, then he’s likely to play left field every day and potentially see Hernández depart via trade. But if he can’t, then there may not be a way to keep him on the roster right now, despite a bat that is clearly Major League ready immediately.

Their other best young hitter isn’t healthy enough to field.

That’s Dalton Rushing, a catcher who turns 26 in February, and showed himself to have a quality left-handed bat in 2026, posting a 115 OPS+ in part-time play. He’s already blocked behind the plate by Will Smith, one of baseball’s best all-around backstops, and that’s another situation where the usual “get him a start at DH each week” would help, if it were available. But there’s a larger issue here, too: Rushing, at least for months to come, is unlikely to be healthy enough to get behind the plate.

In early August, Rushing injured his throwing elbow, costing him weeks on the injured list. He returned in September as a hitter only, but lasted just five days before aggravating the elbow, which knocked him out for the playoffs and eventually led to surgery in October. “His timeline to return to catching is nine months,” wrote Dodgers beat reporter Sonja Chen on Oct. 21, “and he is expected back as a hitter well before then.”

Nine months would put him around the All-Star break before he’s able to get behind the plate, but he’d be available to hit long before that. Another example of, “it sure would be great to let him DH at least part of the time.” The Dodgers will either have to spend a roster spot on a pinch-hitter, or otherwise send Rushing back to Triple-A until he’s healthy enough to catch.

So, what we’re left with is that the Dodgers have five players (Freeman, Muncy, Rushing, De Paula, and Hernández) who really should be getting some or much of their time at designated hitter in 2027, but none of them can expect any significant time there because DH is simply spoken for and unavailable, as long as Ohtani is healthy enough to be in the lineup. 

It's not the worst problem to have, obviously. This only happens since the Dodgers have Ohtani's bat -- once again expected to be one of baseballs best -- in the lineup. But it is a problem nonetheless.

So what can be done about it? 

For 2027, barring a wildly unexpected trade of a core piece, there are really only two realistic options. The first is obviously to put De Paula in left field, if the Dodgers trust him enough defensively to give that a shot.

The second is to have Tommy Edman (who will be 32 in May) shift from being the regular starter at second base to more of the multi-positional role he filled earlier in his career and which he may be better suited to handle at this point. Maybe that opens up the keystone for 25-year-old Alex Freeland, though more likely he’s taking over Rojas’ backup infielder spot, and a new second baseman comes from outside the organization. That could be either via free agency, which wouldn’t likely add youth, or from dealing out of the team’s excess of young outfield prospects for a younger infielder. 

Really, though, this is a problem that comes into focus after 2027, not before it. Not that Ohtani is going anywhere, but Freeman’s contract will be up, and so will Muncy’s, and Hernández’s as well. That doesn’t mean neither infielder can return, but at least it some options will be available. Plus, Mookie Betts will be heading into his age-36 season and potentially isn’t an everyday shortstop any longer, with a likely slide over to second base in his future at some point.

None of this is the end of the Dodgers’ run of success. Far from it, really. But it’s feeling a little like an inflection point, just like how the core in the earlier part of this successful run was more about Justin Turner, Cody Bellinger, Corey Seager, Clayton Kershaw and Kenley Jansen before that group moved on and was replaced by the current one. It’ll happen again, too, as the baton is passed to De Paula, Mike Sirota, Eduardo Quintero and other prospects from MLB Pipeline's top-ranked farm system.

It’s not all about youth, because the youngest teams tend to be rebuilding clubs with few established veterans, and older teams like the Dodgers and Phillies have superstars who have been doing this for a long time. But as the game gets younger and faster and more athletic, it’s not a topic that can be overlooked, either.

The Dodgers have to find a way to make this work. The evolving game demands it.