Mixed reactions to Hill being pulled from perfect game

September 11th, 2016

In one of the most memorable and controversial managerial decisions of the 2016 season, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts removed starter on Saturday after he had compiled a perfect game through seven innings against the Marlins.

Hill had thrown just 89 pitches while retiring the first 21 batters with very little stress, but Roberts, considering both Hill's injury history and the fragile state of his current rotation, removed him from a chance at history.

After the Dodgers' 5-0 win, Roberts revealed that another blister may have been forming on the index finger of Hill's left pitching hand.

Such issues have already cost Hill several weeks of playing time this season, leading some observers and fans to praise Roberts on social media for keeping the team's bigger picture in mind by saving his pitcher from further injury.

Still, others were upset that Hill was kept from achieving something that only 23 other pitchers in the history of baseball have been able to do: Throw a perfect game.

Dodgers pitcher , who has been on the disabled list with a back injury of his own, made reference to the tough decisions Roberts has had to face this year in regard to Hill and rookie , who was removed after tossing 7 1/3 no-hit innings back on April 8. Anderson also said the most important result is that Hill remain healthy for potential Dodgers playoff series this fall.


Former big league pitcher C.J. Nitkowski took the opposite stance, stating that Hill should have stayed in the game regardless of whether he was feeling discomfort with a potential blister issue.

Nitkowski's opinion elicited even more debate, including from another former pitcher, Dan Haren.

Reporters from outside the game of baseball also took to Twitter to send their support to Roberts, who admitted afterward that he "felt sick to his stomach" about his decision to pull Hill when he was so close to history.

Whether Roberts made the right decision to remove Hill, the left-hander is pitching about as well as anyone in baseball as the regular season comes to a close. The 36-year-old southpaw has yet to allow a run in his first 19 innings in a Dodgers uniform while holding his opponents to just six hits and two walks over his first three outings for Los Angeles. In addition to the return of , the Dodgers' oft-beleaguered rotation could suddenly become a force in October.