Globe iconLogin iconRecap iconSearch iconTickets icon

MLB News

Potential All-Star replacements at the ready @castrovince

If we know anything about the All-Star rosters, it's that they are fungible properties basically up until the day of the Midsummer Classic itself. Things happen. Guys get hurt. Guys pitch on Sunday and pull themselves out of availability. Guys get stuck on a layover at O'Hare and can't make it to Cincinnati.

Cast your Esurance MLB All-Star Game Final Vote

If we know anything about the All-Star rosters, it's that they are fungible properties basically up until the day of the Midsummer Classic itself. Things happen. Guys get hurt. Guys pitch on Sunday and pull themselves out of availability. Guys get stuck on a layover at O'Hare and can't make it to Cincinnati.

Cast your Esurance MLB All-Star Game Final Vote

OK, that last one's a stretch, but it's no stretch to assume that some of the guys notable in their absence from the All-Star rosters announced Monday night and the Esurance MLB All-Star Game Final Vote will still attain All-Star status eventually.

Here, then, is a rundown of the guys at each position from each league who should keep his phone handy for the next week.

Starting pitchers

If we're going purely off in-season merit, the strongest candidates would be Scott Kazmir (5-5, 2.56 ERA), Hector Santiago (5-4, 2.40) and Yovani Gallardo (7-6, 2.56). That said, don't totally rule out the possibility of reigning American League Cy Young Award winner Corey Kluber getting some overdue All-Star love despite less-inspiring surface-level stats (3-9, 3.64 ERA), though he's scheduled to pitch Sunday.

:: All-Star Game on Fox: July 14, 7 ET air time | 8:15 game time ::

Johnny Cueto, Clayton Kershaw and Carlos Martinez are all in the Final Vote mix, but Lance Lynn (6-4, 2.53) also looms as a strong replacement candidate (the fact that the Cardinals have three starters worthy of an All-Star look tells you a lot about how they've gotten off to such a scorching start). Like Lynn, Cole Hamels (5-6, 3.02) is scheduled to pitch Friday and, ergo, would be readily available. The Cubs' Jake Arrieta (8-5, 2.80) also has a nice case.


It used to be tough for non-closers to crack the All-Star roster, but we've already got Darren O'Day, Kelvin Herrera and Wade Davis on the AL squad. If there's any justice, the next man up ought to be the Astros' Will Harris, who took a 0.75 WHIP and 0.93 ERA into Monday's play. That said, it could go to Angels closer Huston Street (23 saves, 2.34 ERA).

Video: SF@WSH: Storen reties Blanco to lock down the 3-1 win

In the National League, Nats closer Drew Storen would be the safe play, with 25 saves and a 1.97 ERA. Jason Grilli (22 saves) has also had a solid year. But Bruce Bochy wouldn't be rocking the boat too much if he went with one of his guys -- closer Santiago Casilla (20 saves), setup man George Kontos (1.74 ERA) or lefty Javier Lopez (1.99).


Should something happen to Salvador Perez, Russell Martin or Stephen Vogt between now and Monday, Brian McCann (.803 OPS, 13 homers) is the no-brainer pick in the AL.

Video: TB@NYY: McCann delivers fireworks with walk-off homer

The NL, where Buster Posey, Yadi Molina and Yasmani Grandal are on the roster, is a little trickier. Most likely, the Padres' Derek Norris (11 homers, 20 doubles) would get the call should somebody go down, but Francisco Cervelli (.782 OPS) has had a nice all-around year for the Pirates and is also worthy.

First basemen

Joey Votto (.864 OPS, 14 homers) can and should get the call should a need arise on the NL roster. He's the face of the Reds' franchise and has an All-Star case up there with that of Adrian Gonzalez, who was a Bochy selection.

Video: MIN@CIN: Votto plates a pair with single to left

Miguel Cabrera's injury ensured neither Albert Pujols nor Mark Teixeira got snubbed, and Prince Fielder made it as the backup designated hitter. So Jose Abreu (.843 OPS) would make sense as the next man on the depth chart.

Second basemen

Jose Altuve had the votes, Jason Kipnis had the numbers and now Brian Dozier is on the Final Vote ballot. The guy lost in all of this is the Rays' Logan Forsythe (.790 OPS), who has been a big offensive and defensive key in their contention status.

Video: TB@NYY: Forsythe singles in two runs in the 8th

And while you can't fault the players for voting in DJ LeMahieu or Bochy for going with his guy Joe Panik behind Dee Gordon at second base, Kolten Wong (.780 OPS) is as deserving as any of those guys.


Honestly, the shortstop position in both leagues is pretty thin beyond the guys already named to the rosters (Jhonny Peralta and Brandon Crawford in the NL, Alcides Escobar and Jose Iglesias in the AL) and the Final Vote (Troy Tulowitzki in the NL, Xander Bogaerts in the AL).

Video: HOU@BOS: Correa ties the game with a two-run blast

That's why it's not at all crazy to stump for a guy who has only been in the big leagues for a month. It would be a lot of fun to see Carlos Correa (.932 OPS) jump right into the mix, kind of like how Mike Trout and Bryce Harper both got in back in 2012 (albeit with a little more service time).

The next-best NL option might be Adeiny Hechavarria from the Marlins.

Third basemen

In terms of everyday third basemen, Matt Carpenter (.818 OPS) might make the most sense now that Todd Frazier, Nolan Arenado and Kris Bryant are all on the squad. But how can you ignore what the Dodgers' current third baseman -- the flexible, pliable, productive Justin Turner (.943 OPS) -- is doing?

Video: SEA@LAA: Seager belts a solo homer to tie game in 9th

In the AL, the Mariners' Kyle Seager (.743 OPS) is the next-best all-around option behind Manny Machado, Josh Donaldson and Final Vote candidate Mike Moustakas.


George Springer would have been a really fine reserve choice in the AL, but he's hurt. Josh Reddick (.809) had a strong start. And there are guys like the Rays' Kevin Kiermaier and Kevin Pillar who probably deserve more love for their gloves. But Mookie Betts makes the most sense here, now that his bat has begun to produce as prescribed.

Video: MIL@CIN: Braun singles home Parra to put Crew on top

And while the name is more toxic than it was the last time he made the All-Star team, back in 2012, you can't deny that Ryan Braun (.838 OPS, 15 homers) has worked himself back into viable All-Star consideration.

On that note ...

Designated hitters

Hey, if wanting to see Alex Rodriguez (.902 OPS, 16 homers) in this All-Star Game is wrong, I don't want to be right. But if things were to go south with Nelson Cruz or Fielder, Yost would have the option of going with his guy, Kendrys Morales (.795 OPS, 10 homers).

Video: TB@NYY: A-Rod puts Yanks on the board with solo homer

Voting is open now at to select the final player for each League's 34-man roster via the 2015 Esurance MLB All-Star Game Final Vote. Fans can cast their votes from a list of five players from each League until 4 p.m. ET on Friday.

And the voting doesn't end there. During the Midsummer Classic in Cincinnati on Tuesday, July 14, fans can once again visit to submit their choice for the Ted Williams Most Valuable Player Award presented by Chevrolet. Voting exclusively at, online and via their mobile devices in the 2015 All-Star Game MVP Vote presented by Chevrolet, the fans' collective voice will represent 20 percent of the overall vote that determines the recipient of the Arch Ward Trophy.

MLB.TV Premium subscribers will be able to live stream the All-Star Game via MLB.TV through FOX's participating video providers. Access will be available across more than 400 supported MLB.TV platforms, including the award-winning At Bat app. will provide extensive online coverage of the All-Star Week festivities, including the 2015 Gillette Home Run Derby presented by Head & Shoulders, part of Gatorade All-Star Workout Day on Monday, July 13. The Derby will feature a new format with brackets and timed rounds and will be broadcast live by ESPN and beginning at 8 p.m.

Anthony Castrovince is a reporter for Read his columns and follow him on Twitter at @Castrovince.