David Bednar impressed the Yankees with a splitter-heavy repertoire and can-do spirit in claiming the closer’s role, prompting general manager Brian Cashman to call him “a cool customer” whom the club would be lucky to keep within the fold.
For at least one more year, they will.
Bednar accepted a qualifying offer ahead of Tuesday’s 4 p.m. ET deadline, valued at $23.15 million, keeping the 32-year-old installed in the late innings as the Yankees look to maintain the strength of a bullpen that proved a difference-maker this past year.
Bednar was one of two Major Leaguers to accept the qualifying offer. Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers –- a one-time Yankees trade target -– was the other.
“We’ve been lucky … to have somebody with a strong presence and great leadership to lead out there [in the bullpen],” Cashman said of Bednar during the General Managers Meetings in Las Vegas. “He checked all those boxes, along with the performance. He’s been a good addition so far.”
This marks the second straight year a Yankee has taken the qualifying offer, with outfielder Trent Grisham having accepted in 2025.
Cashman has described the bullpen as a priority for the Yankees early this offseason, with numerous contributors having filed for free agency.
They agreed to a one-year, $2.25 million deal to retain left-hander Tim Hill earlier this week, a pact that includes a $2.5 million club option for 2028, but club officials were less certain about their chances of keeping Bednar.
Acquired from the Pirates in July 2025, Bednar has posted a 2.39 ERA across 86 appearances with the Yankees, including 45 saves.
This past season, he was 7-3 with 35 saves and a 2.47 ERA in 64 appearances, setting career highs in wins and innings pitched (69 1/3). Bednar tied for third in the American League in saves, tied for first in wins and ranked sixth in the AL with an 89.7 save percentage.
His 35 saves were the most by a Yankee in a single season since Aroldis Chapman’s 37 in 2019. Bednar didn’t allow a run in 37 of his final 43 appearances, posting a 1.30 ERA with 24 saves over that span.
He also converted 17 straight chances from May 18 to Aug. 11.
“I think it's just trying to do a task, finish a task, and just take it one at a time,” Bednar said during the postseason. “When I'm down there, I'm ready for whenever the phone rings in whatever situation, whatever the team needs me to do to keep getting outs. So whenever that may be, I'm always prepared.”
Bednar and Hill will rejoin left-hander Brent Headrick as part of a late-inning mix that still appears under construction.
They would like to re-sign Paul Blackburn and have expressed interest in free agent left-hander Adrian Morejon, as well as a potential reunion with right-hander Jonathan Loáisiga.
As Cashman said in Las Vegas, retaining Bednar would represent an important step toward “surrounding him with more quality individuals that our manager can turn to late in the game to try to close things out.”
Earlier this year, Bednar described the Yankees' relievers as "a really tight-knit group."
"I think that's important in a bullpen," he said. "You want to be out there for the next guy and pick the next guy up. It's really about, just keep passing the baton and doing whatever we can to help the team win, in any fashion."
