Globe iconLogin iconRecap iconSearch iconTickets icon
The Official Site of the Pittsburgh Pirates
news

Pirates News

Projecting Pirates' 25-man Opening Day roster

Starting pitching depth could allow Hurdle to be creative with bullpen
MLB.com @adamdberry

PITTSBURGH -- In a radio interview last month, manager Clint Hurdle began looking forward to what he called "a new era of Pirates baseball." He wasn't exaggerating.

An outfield without Andrew McCutchen. A rotation without Gerrit Cole. A roster with, at most, seven of the 25 players who were with the Pirates at PNC Park for the 2015 National League Wild Card Game.

PITTSBURGH -- In a radio interview last month, manager Clint Hurdle began looking forward to what he called "a new era of Pirates baseball." He wasn't exaggerating.

An outfield without Andrew McCutchen. A rotation without Gerrit Cole. A roster with, at most, seven of the 25 players who were with the Pirates at PNC Park for the 2015 National League Wild Card Game.

Spring Training: Info | Tickets | Schedule | Gear

With so many new faces set to enter the Pirate City clubhouse in the coming days, projecting Pittsburgh's Opening Day roster is no simple task. It's further complicated by the number of free agents still available. But before Spring Training begins, here is our first shot at predicting which players will line up for the Pirates in Detroit on March 29.

:: Spring Training coverage presented by Camping World ::

Catcher (2): Francisco Cervelli, Elias Diaz
Pretty straightforward, especially with Diaz out of options.

First base (1): Josh Bell
No questions here, either. This is Bell's job.

Second base (1): Josh Harrison
Harrison requested a trade if the Pirates don't intend to contend soon, but club management has insisted they will compete sooner than expected. Although they still could trade him, a logical landing spot came off the board when the Mets filled their infield need with Todd Frazier.

Video: Bucs' options at second if Josh Harrison is dealt

Third base (2): Colin Moran, David Freese
Moran will get a chance to start. Ideally, Freese will back up him and Bell.

Shortstop (1): Jordy Mercer
This will be Mercer's fifth (and likely final) Opening Day start as the Pirates' shortstop.

Utility (3): Adam Frazier, Sean Rodriguez, Max Moroff
Frazier and Rodriguez will be on the roster, but if the season began today, one of them might be starting in the outfield.

The last spot comes down to the switch-hitting Moroff and outfielder Jordan Luplow, as Jose Osuna would be redundant with Freese as a right-handed-hitting corner infielder. Moroff gets the nod -- for now -- based on his versatility. The Pirates prefer to carry a backup option at shortstop, and it might have to be Moroff if Frazier or Rodriguez is a starting outfielder.

Video: Luplow is the Pirates' Pipeline hitter of the year

Outfield (3): Starling Marte, Gregory Polanco, Daniel Nava
Marte's in center. Polanco could play either corner, but he's better off in right. Pittsburgh could answer a lot of questions by signing or trading for a regular left fielder.

Video: Possible options for Pirates' outfield in 2018 season

Top prospect Austin Meadows needs another (healthy) trip through Triple-A Indianapolis after struggling last season. Nava, signed to a Minor League deal, will serve as a fourth outfielder if he makes the roster.

Video: Outlook: Marte likely to rank among steals leaders

The Pirates have suggested that No. 23 prospect Luplow could spend more time in Triple-A, so unless he emerges as a full-time or platoon starter this spring, perhaps he'll play regularly in Indianapolis to begin the season rather than sitting on the Major League bench.

Rotation: Jameson Taillon, Ivan Nova, Joe Musgrove, Chad Kuhl, Trevor Williams
In December, general manager Neal Huntington all but officially said the rotation would be Cole, Taillon, Nova, Kuhl and Williams. Trading Cole created an opening, which the Pirates expect Musgrove to fill. Steven Brault, Tyler Glasnow and Nick Kingham are also in the mix.

Musgrove headlines young group of newcomers

Bullpen: Felipe Rivero, George Kontos, Daniel Hudson, Michael Feliz, Kyle Crick, Brault, Glasnow
Rivero, Kontos and Hudson are in. It seems likely that Feliz and Crick, a pair of hard-throwing right-handers, have an edge as recent trade acquisitions. They could use another lefty and a couple multi-inning relievers, so let's pencil in Brault, who has little else to prove as a Triple-A starter.

Video: Berry on Smoker's chances to make Pirates' bullpen

There are a bunch of candidates for the final spot. A.J. Schugel is out of options. Dovydas Neverauskas and Edgar Santana could be late-inning relievers someday. The Pirates clearly valued Josh Smoker enough to trade for him, Jack Leathersich enough to claim him and Jordan Milbrath enough to take him in the Rule 5 Draft. Fellow Rule 5 pick Nick Burdi will be in the discussion when he's healthy.

They all have a chance, so this projection could change. But the Pirates have suggested their depth would allow Glasnow -- who still has top-of-the-rotation stuff -- to pitch in relief if he doesn't crack the Opening Day rotation. They won't learn if he's ready to realize his potential by watching him carve up more Triple-A lineups.

Adam Berry has covered the Pirates for MLB.com since 2015. Follow him on Twitter and Facebook and read his blog.

Pittsburgh Pirates