2 postseason contenders need to rebuild an entire rotation. Here’s how to do it

3:00 AM UTC

Just over two years ago, took the Wrigley Field mound for the Cubs in Game 1 of the National League Wild Card Series against the Padres. The veteran left-hander, amid his first All-Star season, allowed just one run in 4 1/3 strong innings.

The Cubs turned to six pitchers for a Game 2 win and series win, with spinning four bulk innings of two-run ball.

Fast forward to the 2026 NL Wild Card Series, and these two clubs met again, this time at Petco Park. started for San Diego in Game 1 and flirted with a no-hitter, allowing just one hit across seven scoreless innings. He outdueled Boyd in the process.

​

took the ball in Game 2, completing 3 1/3 innings with just one run allowed. The Padres got to Cubs starter for three runs and advanced to the NL Division Series, where they fell in four thrilling games against the Brewers.

It’s now mid-November. None of the aforementioned starting pitchers remain under contract with either the Cubs or Padres. And they’re not the only ones. Both of these clubs, among baseball’s best over the past two seasons, must replace virtually their entire rotations.

How’d we get here? What’s next on the mound for two teams that are looking to remain competitive next season and beyond?

Let’s take a look.

Who’s gone?

Cubs: Chicago has a whopping seven starters from the ‘26 squad now on the open market. That includes the entire end-of-year rotation -- Boyd, Imanaga, Gausman, and David Peterson -- as well as two swing types who served valuable roles in  and .

Padres: The free-agent number is eight for San Diego, though it’s a mixed bag of names. King and Pivetta, as well as Trade Deadline pickups and , are out the door. The other four are (32 starts), (11 starts), (10 starts) and (five starts).

Who’s left?

Cubs: The Cubs actually have at least five starters on their current roster whom you could conceivably pencil into the 2027 rotation. That includes , , , and .

Here’s the problem: None of them is exactly a certainty. Assad led the group with 94⅓ innings in 2026 across 11 starts and 17 relief appearances. Cabrera made the most starts (15) after a marquee offseason trade from the Marlins, but he had an inflated 5.96 ERA and dealt with multiple injuries, which prompted the Cubs to push him to the bullpen for the home stretch. 

Brown looked like a breakout star with a 1.85 ERA in 20 appearances (eight starts) but then missed the rest of the season with a neck injury that required offseason surgery. Horton looked to build on an excellent rookie campaign in 2025 but needed season-ending elbow surgery after two starts. Steele did not pitch despite a comeback attempt from his 2025 elbow surgery.

Padres: The Friars jump-started their 2027 rotation outlook with an under-the-radar signing of righty , who struggled in nine big league appearances with the Astros but impressed at Triple-A as the season wound down. He should at least compete for a spot next season.

The best of the rest is , who posted a 3.90 ERA in 32 appearances (23 starts) in 2026. He flashed high upside at times in his age-27 season but also had periods of struggle.

From there, San Diego would turn to (mulling retirement); (made one bullpen appearance in the postseason, has not started since 2024); (six starts, 4.68 ERA); and (five relief appearances in return from elbow surgery).

What’s the buzz?

Cubs: The Cubs have been tied to just about every free-agent starter out there, though they reportedly won’t be looking to spend at the level of contract the top prize -- -- is expected to receive.

Namely, the Cubs have shown interest in fellow lefty , according to The Athletic’s Sahadev Sharma (subscription required). Reports have also tied them to Japanese righty Kaima Taira after his posting this offseason.

But the Cubs simply need depth, so until there’s more concrete reporting available, you can probably pencil them into the race for any of the free-agent arms (perhaps except Skubal).

Padres: San Diego president of baseball operations A.J. Preller joked (was he joking?) during the GM Meetings in Las Vegas when asked how many starters his team would look to add. Three? Four?

“Keep going,” Preller said.

And yes, that search will include Skubal. Whether the Padres landing the two-time Cy Young winner is a likely outcome remains to be seen, but they reportedly met with the top free agent this week to make their pitch.

Elsewhere, the Padres are still interested in a reunion with King. He, Pivetta and Buehler all said publicly that they’d welcome a return to San Diego. But a lot is still up in the air for the Friars.