| 2025 | Kyle Schwarber (DH), Zack Wheeler (P) |
| 2024 | Alec Bohm (3B), Bryce Harper (1B), Jeff Hoffman (P), Cristopher Sánchez (P), Matt Strahm (P), Ranger Suárez (P), Trea Turner (SS), Zack Wheeler (P) |
| 2023 | Nick Castellanos (OF), Craig Kimbrel (P) |
| 2022 | Bryce Harper (DH), Kyle Schwarber (OF) |
| 2021 | J.T. Realmuto (C), Zack Wheeler (P) |
| 2020 | No game due to COVID-19 pandemic |
| 2019 | J.T. Realmuto (C) |
| 2018 | Aaron Nola (P) |
| 2017 | Pat Neshek (P) |
| 2016 | Odubel Herrera (OF) |
| 2015 | Jonathan Papelbon (P) |
| 2014 | Chase Utley (2B) |
| 2013 | Domonic Brown (OF), Cliff Lee (P) |
| 2012 | Cole Hamels (P), Jonathan Papelbon (P), Carlos Ruiz (C) |
| 2011 | Roy Halladay (P), Cole Hamels (P), Cliff Lee (P), Placido Polanco (3B), Shane Victorino (OF) |
| 2010 | Roy Halladay (P), Ryan Howard (DH), Chase Utley (2B) |
| 2009 | Ryan Howard (1B), Raul Ibanez (OF), Chase Utley (2B), Shane Victorino (OF), Jayson Werth (OF) |
| 2008 | Brad Lidge (P), Chase Utley (2B) |
| 2007 | Cole Hamels (P), Aaron Rowand (OF), Chase Utley (2B) |
| 2006 | Tom Gordon (P), Ryan Howard (1B), Chase Utley (2B) |
| 2005 | Bobby Abreu (OF), Jimmy Rollins (SS), Billy Wagner (P) |
| 2004 | Bobby Abreu (OF), Jim Thome (1B) |
| 2003 | Randy Wolf (P) |
| 2002 | Vicente Padilla (P), Scott Rolen (3B), Jimmy Rollins (SS) |
| 2001 | Jimmy Rollins (SS) |
| 2000 | Mike Lieberthal (C) |
| 1999 | Paul Byrd (P), Mike Lieberthal (C), Curt Schilling (P) |
| 1998 | Curt Schiling (P) |
| 1997 | Curt Schilling (P) |
| 1996 | Ricky Bottalico (P) |
| 1995 | Darren Daulton (C), Lenny Dykstra (OF), Tyler Green (P), Mickey Morandini (2B), Heathcliff Slocumb (P) |
| 1994 | Mariano Duncan (2B), Lenny Dykstra (OF), Danny Jackson (P), Doug Jones (P) |
| 1993 | Darren Daulton (C), Dave Hollins (3B), John Kruk (1B), Terry Mulholland (P) |
| 1992 | Darren Daulton (C), John Kruk (1B) |
| 1991 | John Kruk (1B) |
| 1990 | Lenny Dykstra (OF) |
| 1989 | Von Hayes (OF), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1988 | Kevin Gross (P), Lance Parrish (C) |
| 1987 | Steve Bedrosian (P), Juan Samuel (2B), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1986 | Shane Rawley (P), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1985 | Ozzie Virgil (C), Glenn Wilson (OF) |
| 1984 | Al Holland (P), Juan Samuel (2B), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1983 | Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1982 | Steve Carlton (P), Pete Rose (1B), Mike Schmidt (3B), Manny Trillo (2B) |
| 1981 | Steve Carlton (P), Pete Rose (1B), Dick Ruthven (P), Mike Schmidt (3B), Manny Trillo (2B) |
| 1980 | Steve Carlton (P), Pete Rose (1B), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1979 | Bob Boone (C), Larry Bowa (SS), Steve Carlton (P), Pete Rose (1B), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1978 | Bob Boone (C), Larry Bowa (SS), Greg Luzinski (OF) |
| 1977 | Steve Carlton (P), Greg Luzinski (OF), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1976 | Bob Boone (C), Larry Bowa (SS), Dave Cash (2B), Greg Luzinski (OF), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1975 | Larry Bowa (SS), Dave Cash (2B), Greg Luzinski (OF), Tug McGraw (P) |
| 1974 | Larry Bowa (SS), Steve Carlton (P), Dave Cash (2B), Mike Schmidt (3B) |
| 1973 | Wayne Twitchell (P) |
| 1972 | Steve Carlton (P) |
| 1971 | Rick Wise (P) |
| 1970 | Joe Hoerner (P) |
| 1969 | Grant Jackson (P) |
| 1968 | Woodie Fryman (P) |
| 1967 | Richie Allen (3B), Chris Short (P) |
| 1966 | Richie Allen (3B), Jim Bunning (P) |
| 1965 | Richie Allen (3B), Johnny Callison (OF), Cookie Rojas (2B) |
| 1964 | Jim Bunning (P), Johnny Callison (OF), Chris Short (P) |
| 1963 | Ray Culp (P) |
| 1962 | Johnny Callison (OF), Art Mahaffey (P) |
| 1961 | Art Mahaffey (P) |
| 1960 | Tony Taylor (2B) |
| 1959 | Gene Conley (P) |
| 1958 | Richie Ashburn (OF), Dick Farrell (P) |
| 1957 | Jack Sanford (P), Curt Simmons (P) |
| 1956 | Stan Lopata (C), Robin Roberts (P) |
| 1955 | Del Ennis (OF), Stan Lopata (C), Robin Roberts (P) |
| 1954 | Smoky Burgess (C), Granny Hamner (2B), Robin Roberts (P) |
| 1953 | Richie Ashburn (OF), Granny Hamner (SS), Robin Roberts (P), Curt Simmons (P) |
| 1952 | Granny Hamner (SS), Robin Roberts (P), Curt Simmons (P) |
| 1951 | Richie Ashburn (OF), Del Ennis (OF), Willie Jones (3B), Robin Roberts (P) |
| 1950 | Willie Jones (3B), Jim Konstanty (P), Robin Roberts (P), Dick Sisler (OF) |
| 1949 | Andy Seminick (C), Eddie Waitkus (1B) |
| 1948 | Richie Ashburn (OF) |
| 1947 | Schoolboy Rowe (P), Emil Verban (2B), Harry Walker (OF) |
| 1946 | Del Ennis (OF), Frank McCormick (1B), Emil Verban (2B) |
| 1945 | No game due to World War II travel restrictions |
| 1944 | Ken Raffensberger (P) |
| 1943 | Babe Dahlgren (1B) |
| 1942 | Danny Litwhiler (OF) |
| 1941 | Cy Blanton (P) |
| 1940 | Kirby Higbe (P), Pinky May (3B), Hugh Mulcahy (P) |
| 1939 | Morrie Arnovich (OF) |
| 1938 | Herschel Martin (OF) |
| 1937 | Bucky Walters (P) |
| 1936 | Pinky Whitney (3B) |
| 1935 | Jimmy Wilson (C) |
| 1933 | Dick Bartell (SS), Chuck Klein (OF) |
