This story was excerpted from Jason Beck’s Tigers Beat newsletter. To read the full newsletter, click here. And subscribe to get it regularly in your inbox.
The Tigers made it clear at last week’s GM Meetings that their priority this offseason is pitching, both starting and bullpen. That doesn’t mean they’re going to ignore a positional roster that struggled offensively and defensively at various points, but part of their improvement is expected to come internally, some from the development of their prospects, some from the health of their more experienced players.
Kerry Carpenter firmly falls in the latter. His rebound is critical, for the Tigers and for himself.
“It's a big winter for Kerry,” president of baseball operations Scott Harris told reporters last week, echoing comments manager A.J. Hinch made in September.
It’s almost entirely about health, a recurring theme over his four-plus seasons in the big leagues.
When Carpenter is healthy and getting regular at-bats to get his swing right, he mashes right-handed pitching, and he’s enough of a threat against certain left-handed pitching that he has to be respected. But after a 26-homer season in 2025 put Carpenter on the verge of a breakout as a near-everyday power threat, he played in just 81 games this year due to injuries – three weeks lost in May to a shoulder injury, then the final two months to a heel injury that he aggravated in September.
Those games Carpenter did play saw the lowest production of his career. His .692 OPS was 114 points below his career rate. His .416 slugging percentage was 76 points below his career clip. His home run rate was just slightly below his average, but his doubles power nearly disappeared. His average exit velocity of 89.8 mph was his lowest since his first Major League stint in 2022. He never seemed to find his swing, and the heel injury denied him a chance to recover from a 3-for-28 slump out of the All-Star break.
“He was banged up for most of the year, as we all saw,” Harris said. “He deserves credit for grinding through a number of things. But listen, he's still the same guy that took [Guardians closer Emmanuel] Clase deep in the playoffs [in 2024], and he's still the same guy that opposing managers were navigating around, whether it was walking him or pitching around him or using their ‘pen to match up against him. So we know what the ceiling is. We've just got to get a healthier version of him, and we have to make sure he has a really good winter, because our best lineup has him in it.”
That not-so-distant form is a big reason to keep him around into his second offseason of arbitration eligibility. Another reason is the Tigers’ top prospect.
Zyhir Hope isn’t ready yet, but the Tigers expect him to get to the Majors at some point next season. Like Carpenter, he’s a left-handed-hitting outfielder with massive power but more speed and better defense. The Tigers want to keep his path to Detroit clear. That’s easier to do with Carpenter around and able to shift to designated hitter than with an outfield addition on a multi-year deal.
“Zyhir has to prove it in Triple-A,” Harris said. “And if he does, then we have a lot of really good options. That's the place our organization's trying to get to.”
