No one loves a good debate quite like baseball fans, and with that in mind, we asked each of our beat reporters to rank the top five players by position in the history of their franchise, based on their career while playing for that club. Here is Thomas Harding’s ranking of the top third basemen in Rockies history.
1. Nolan Arenado, 2013-20
Key fact: With five seasons of 30 or more homers, three seasons of 40 or more homers and Gold Glove Awards all eight of his seasons with the club, he has a good argument to join Larry Walker and Todd Helton as Hall of Famers representing the Rockies
Much could be said about Arenado's offensive abilities, but don’t forget all the gold. No other National Leaguer had won as many as five Gold Glove Awards to start his career. After Arenado was traded to the Cardinals, he even tacked on two more Gold Gloves. He won four straight Platinum Gloves with the Rockies and two more with the Cardinals. The real comparison is not to Rockies at the position, but to all third basemen in baseball history.
Arenado made two postseason trips with the Rockies, and will forever be known for his desire to win.
2. Vinny Castilla, 1993-99, 2004, '06
Key fact: Castilla’s 320 career home runs are most in history for a Mexican-born player
The list of third basemen with three 40-homer seasons (minimum 75 games at the position in a season) consists of Hall of Famers Mike Schmidt and Eddie Mathews, possible future Hall of Famer Arenado, and Castilla, who did it for the Rockies from 1996-98.
Castilla, one of the franchise’s first stars, departed in a December 1999 trade that cleared a spot for another player on this list, Jeff Cirillo. Castilla returned in 2004 and led the National League with 131 RBIs before finishing his career in Colorado with 15 games in '06. He has worked as a special assistant to the general manager since his retirement.
3. Ryan McMahon (2017-25)
Key fact: McMahon’s 16.7 bWAR ranks him third among third basemen in club history, behind Arenado’s 39.7 and Castilla’s 17.5
The Rockies introduced McMahon to the Majors at first base, and he played solidly at second base when asked. But it was at third that he made his biggest impact, with four straight years of being a National League Gold Glove finalist. He continued the success with another finalist honor in the American League with the Yankees in 2026. McMahon also reached or exceeded 20 home runs with the Rockies five times.
4. Garrett Atkins, 2003-09
Key fact: Atkins had 54 home runs and 231 RBIs from 2006-07
Atkins won the starting job in 2005 but sustained a hamstring strain in the final exhibition game, so his impact was delayed. But Atkins was healthy enough to play in 157 games in '06, when he posted career highs with a .329 batting average and a .556 slugging percentage.
Atkins was considered more offensive than defensive, but former manager Clint Hurdle noted that the balls Atkins could reach got converted into outs.
5. Jeff Cirillo, 2000-01
Key fact: Cirillo made the All-Star Game with the Rockies in 2000
While Cirillo is more identified with the Brewers, he had his most productive season by tying his career high in batting average (.326) and setting career marks in RBIs (115), runs (111) and doubles (53). In two seasons with the Rockies, he amassed 7.9 wins above replacement, per Baseball Reference.
